Author Archives: wcw

Celebrate and be proud of our diversity

How we wish the building of churches in Malaysia could be much simpler. In reality, permission to build churches is fraught with many forms of obstacles, with numerous government agencies seemingly taking their time to approve applications. And there has been more bad news than good. 

The result is that more and more Christians have to attend services in office blocks, shopping complexes, hotel ballrooms and even warehouses. 

These days, proper churches have become heritage buildings. Just take a stroll down Pitt Street in Penang and you will see how mosques, churches and temples can co-exist but in new housing estates, we are told this cannot be possible. 

True Christian values require followers to be grateful and thankful for what they have. The law must always be respected and there must be no two ways about it. 

Certainly, we will pray for our leaders and civil servants to have the wisdom, justice and courage to do what is right for Malaysians, regardless of their race and religion. 

Thankful we should be. Malaysian Christians, who make up about 10% of the population, are able to celebrate their festivities openly, which comes as a surprise for many foreigners because of the country's predominant Muslim population. 

They do not expect to see huge Christmas trees and colourful decorations on display at shopping malls and hotels. They reckon the festival is celebrated on a small scale behind closed doors. What's more, Christmas is a national holiday and there is even an annual national-level Christmas celebration, which is attended by key government leaders. 

More importantly, Christians in Malaysia are able to worship without fearing for their security. There is no need for vigilantes to stand guard outside churches to prevent religious violence. 

Even in China, where most Christmas gifts and toys are manufactured, Christmas is tolerated only from a commercial and holiday perspective but not from a religious angle. Christmas service or mass is mainly for expatriates. 

There are no threats of extremists wanting to bomb churches and our government has consistently demonstrated its tough stand against extremists who threaten the country's security. 

For that, Malaysians must appreciate the stability in our country. It sounds like a cliche and sometimes we take this for granted. We become overly critical of ourselves. We tend to forget that not everyone shares the insensitive actions or words of a few people. 

In a multi-cultural society like ours, there are bound to be diverse views and prejudices. Sometimes these views clash, leading to much uneasiness, hurt and insecurity. 

There will always be times when the ride becomes bumpy but generally Malaysians, regardless of their ethnic and religious view points, believe in living in peace. 

Malaysia has always been a melting pot. It is in many ways a country of immigrants. A look at the country's history since the glorious days of the Malacca Sultanate will testify to that. 

The diversity and multiculturalism of Malaysia is something we should be proud of. There is no need to be apologetic about it and we must certainly resist any attempts to stop it. 

Malaysians have lived in harmony for over 50 years, tolerating and understanding each other's way of life, and we should never let any politician tell us to live differently. 

We should also be wary of those who use religion to justify their actions, particularly when it is their own interpretation of religious matters. No one has a monopoly over religion. All followers and those affected by it have the right to discuss and deliberate on such matters. Religion is not the sole right of scholars, theologians, missionaries and priests. 

The beauty of Malaysia lies in the fact that the majority of its people are tolerant, moderate and open-minded. We are quick to shout down the killjoys who tell us not to attend open-house events or to wish each other happy holidays. 

Eating turkey, singing carols and donning the red Santa headgear does not make one a Christian. It is simply a time for winding down, meeting up with friends for a meal and spending some money. 

We believe that most Malaysians are decent, practical people who understand that the country is multi-racial and we all need to appreciate and understand its pluralism. 

And certainly, my friends of all races and religions have never let the minority impose their views on them. 

Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to all Malaysians.  

You won’t see me in this club

More so when there are men with tight-fitting jeans or shirts unbuttoned to their navels.  

I do not know what message Datuk Nik Abdul Nik Mat is trying to send. He must have the best of intentions but, hey, for sure, many Malaysian males do not want to send the wrong message. 

The Kelantan Mentri Besar has said he has no problem with dancing but it has to be strictly between men and men. And of course, women and women. We can imagine the kind of tourists Kelantan would soon be attracting. 

Many Malaysians must have thought that the state PAS government had come to their senses by proposing a tourist belt where tourists and non-Muslims could have some night entertainment. 

A kind of restricted zone where tourists need to produce their passports or identity cards to gain entrance.  

The 1980s word "disco" was even used, never mind if the term "clubs" are more understood among the young these days. 

It seemed possible as the PAS government appeared to have relaxed the rules by allowing pop concerts, which it had once frowned upon. Never mind if there was still gender segregation at these concerts. 

But State Local Government, Housing and Health Committee chairman Takiyuddin Hassan has now said that he was misquoted and that there were no plans to set up such entertainment outlets for non-Muslims in the state. 

What he had proposed was the setting up of a cultural village near the Pantai Cahaya Bulan stretch to promote tourism in the state. 

On Saturday, Nik Aziz made sure everyone understood that the conservative party was still running the state. 

There would be no alcohol, no mingling between men and women and no showing of the aurat (body parts that must be covered under Islam). 

The Kelantan Mentri Besar said he did not oppose dancing in discos "but it must be between members of the same sex." 

Recently, the Kota Baru Municipal Council decided to fine women working in retail outlets caught wearing "sexy" clothing, which include tight jeans and body fitting blouses, up to RM500. The council also banned the showing of navels. 

It is unlikely that businessmen would take up Nik Aziz's proposal of dancing clubs exclusively for men or women. 

Not only is his idea bizarre but it does not make practical sense.  

The people of Kelantan are also unlikely to take up his suggestion. 

After all, Golok, known for its adult entertainment, is just across the river on the Thai side, so why bother with all these restrictions? 

For the young, there is always the Internet. According to statistics, web surfers in the state topped the list for searching the term "Melayu bogel" (naked Malays) on Google's search engine.  

With so many social and economic problems, including drug addiction and unemployment, Nik Aziz should channel his energy to solving these issues instead of worrying about trivial matters. 

While the younger PAS leaders are attempting to project a moderate and gentler image, the older group is still not letting go of their orthodox brand of politics. 

Some of us will just dismiss the statements by Nik Aziz as part of the party's series of eccentricities but for many of us, this is the kind of government that PAS want to impose on the rest of Malaysia. 

Many of us in our 40s still love listening to the 80s hits by Boy George and George Michael, but an all-men club? Thanks, but no thanks.  

 

 

Sorrows of 1997 too painful to forget

There are no permanent enemies or permanent friends in politics, as people say. Not only did they shake hands, Dr Mahathir even said Soros was not to blame for bringing down the ringgit in the 1997 financial crisis. 

The former premier said he accepted Soros' explanation that he was not involved in the devaluing of the ringgit and that it was done by other traders. 

Soros complimented his former nemesis for his "great contribution" to Malaysia's material development, describing him as a "great man". 

And we thought we have heard and seen it all. The pat on the back must have surprised many of us. 

In 1997, Dr Mahathir had blamed currency speculators for the Asian financial crisis, singling out Soros. In one year, the ringgit plunged from RM2.52 to the US dollar to RM4.596. 

Dr Mahathir had then said that Soros was using the wealth under his control to punish Asean for welcoming Myanmar. 

"There is definite evidence that we cannot disclose. There is no doubt he did it," he was quoted as saying. 

Soros maintained that he wasn't involved except for a single trade in mid-June 1997 and that his funds had not sold ringgit or baht. 

Ten years later, the wound must have healed. Or circumstances have changed. Dr Mahathir is no longer prime minister and Soros, who operates the Open Society Institute, has shifted his interest from promoting democracy in countries like Myanmar to fighting drug dealers. 

Whether Soros did attack the ringgit or not is now purely academic but the fact remains that he had attained renown for his attacks that forced the British pound sterling out of the European Monetary System in 1992. 

His alleged involvement in Asia following the attacks by Dr Mahathir helped him gain notoriety. Soros may plead innocence and perhaps he is telling the truth but he is no angel. That is certain. 

Rogue speculators, to borrow the words of Dr Mahathir then, such as Soros had caused much misery to Asians, especially Malaysians and Thais. And many Asians have not forgiven Soros. 

To be fair to Dr Mahathir, he said he was still concerned about currency speculation wrecking the economies of poor countries. 

As Japanese strategist Kenichi Ohmae then said, if Soros had not come into the picture, "someone else would have done the same thing". 

In short, while we have been quick to blame external factors, not many Asian governments were prepared to admit their own mistakes. 

The fact then was that despite the entry of China and India into the international export markets, the South East Asian economies failed to restore their competitiveness by making drastic adjustments to their exchange rates. 

There were also macro-economic weaknesses in several countries in the region, more than the governments would care to admit. 

Some of us may remember that we were lulled into a false sense of security and even superiority. 

We were tagged the Asian Tigers and economist John Nasbitt made lots of money writing books praising the South East Asians. All of us believed in our superiority and even invincibility. 

The Malaysia Boleh spirit carried us too far as we were kept busy making the biggest popiah and longest satay

Some economists had asked us to look at our wastage on unproductive projects and, of course, the region's notorious reputation for corruption but the calls went unheeded. 

With plenty of money in our pockets, many voters were prepared to tolerate the abuses of their leaders. 

They argued that it was okay for politicians to be corrupt so long as the people also got their share. Democracy and human rights were the least of their concerns. 

It is always easy to blame outsiders because many of us refuse to accept our own weaknesses. We like to live in a state of denial, preferring to fault others instead of taking a hard look at our flaws. 

Ten years later, we need to ask ourselves whether we would still give simplistic explanations for our financial failures at the micro or macro level. 

We have taken steps to protect our ringgit from the likes of Soros, who destroyed many families in the region with their greed. It is strange that he is now regarded as some kind of a hero. 

Until Dr Mahathir pegged the ringgit with his unconventional but effective financial methods, it was chaos for many businessmen as they saw the ringgit dip. 

Whether it was the failure of their governments, the greedy currency trader or Soros, they remember the sorrows of 1997. 

 

  • Wong Chun Wai can be reached at onthebeat@thestar.com.my
  • Malaysia is for all races

    All the parades and celebrations would have little meaning if Malaysians do not appreciate, let alone understand, the meaning of independence. 

    We must have the mood to celebrate National Day. Let no one say there is none because we have plenty of reasons to celebrate. 

    Unlike the independence of other countries, Malaysians achieved theirs without shedding any blood. 

    That is simply because we have always believed in the politics of consensus and moderation. That means no one race will have their way 100% and, so far, the leadership has carried that well. 

    Our founding fathers recognised that compromise was a strength and not a weakness. 

    No doubt we can do better and, as Pak Lah said, race relations is still fragile and brittle. Certainly, we all agree that more must be done for the sake of the country, especially the future generation.  

    All of us must work on it. It does not just involve ordinary Malaysians – our politicians must be equally responsible. 

    Irrespective of their positions, they must be accountable for their actions and what they say. Politicians cannot preach national unity and at the same time make racist statements that hurt the feelings of fellow Malaysians. 

    Whether they are from the ruling parties or the Opposition, politicians must learn to restrain themselves from raising communal issues. 

    The same applies to civil servants, religious leaders and non-government organisations that try to exert their influence on us. 

    They must emulate Pak Lah if they genuinely support him and his model of politics, as he has always been consistent. 

    He enjoys telling his friends of his childhood days as a boy scout at the Bukit Mertajam High School in Penang where he met boys from other races. 

    His scoutmaster was a Chinese teacher who taught him what leadership and team spirit was all about. Certainly he played a part, whether big or small, in moulding the character of Pak Lah. 

    National Day, as the Prime Minister said, should not be celebrated by just one race but by every Malaysian. 

    That is simply because Malaysia belongs to all races. It is what it is today because of the hard work of all races. 

    We have put in our share of toil and no race should be made to feel that he does not belong here. There are no more immigrant races because we are Malaysians. 

    In the words of Pak Lah, we must be united as Malaysians to take on the world. Time is not on our side. 

    The petty squabbles have sapped much of our energy. That has to stop. We need to catch up in this highly competitive world that does not tolerate the mediocre and those who are not prepared to fight the economic battles. 

    We have to worry about the Chinese, the Indians, the Indonesians and Vietnamese. And we have to remind the Americans that we exist and that we are in the game too. 

    Yes, we are a small nation, just in case we get carried away with our Malaysia Boleh spirit.  

    Malaysians have had enough bad news. It is surely time for some feel-good news again and all of us must aim for that by playing our part. 

     

  • Wong Chun Wai can be reached at onthebeat@thestar.com.my 
  • Kota Baru ruling on sexy dress lays blame, again, on women

    The council has just come out with a decision to fine women working in retail outlets and restaurants should they wear clothes deemed to be sexy or revealing.  

    The offending clothes include tight fitting blouses, jeans, shorts and mini-skirts, according to the new ruling.  

    Council public relations officer Mohd Azman Daham said those found wearing offensive clothes could be fined RM500.  

    I am not sure whether wearing these clothes can create a riot or lead to political instability in Kelantan, but certainly many of us want to see, well, some transparency in the enforcement.  

    The reason given by Mohd Azman is quite pathetic really.  

    The council, it seems, had received complaints that some retail outlets and restaurants were resorting to getting their workers to wear sexy clothes to woo customers.  

    That's a laugh really. Certainly, the men in Kelantan would feel insulted by that kind of restaurant.  

    We believe Kelantanese have better taste – we are talking about food in the state, that is.  

    For non-Muslim women, they would be banned from showing off their navel, so no ala Britney Spears, or anything that emphasises the buttocks.  

    It may be easier to stop women from showing their navel but the council has to ban jeans completely if they want anything that "emphasises the buttocks" to be disallowed.  

    For Muslim women, they don't appear to have much choice because they need to wear the tudung or a clothing that covers right down to the ankles.  

    When it comes to Kelantan, the blame is always on the women.  

    We have lost track of the number of times when Kelantan PAS leaders, including its Mentri Besar Datuk Seri Nik Aziz Nik Mat, pointed their fingers at women.  

    The simplistic argument has always been that dressing is to be blamed for rapes and sexual molest cases.  

    Still in a perpetual denial state, they chose to look the other way when confronted with facts and figures that even grandmothers, many in tudung, have been raped.  

    Certainly, they were not dressed sexily and indecently.  

    This is despite the fact that gender segregation is still enforced at supermarket check-out queues and the lights are still on in cinemas.  

    But this obsession with sex is prevalent too among a few Barisan Nasional Members of Parliament.  

    A few suggested that foreign sex workers be whipped as a form of punishment.  

    Again, this came from Sri Gading MP Datuk Mohamed Aziz who strives on controversy at the Dewan Rakyat.  

    No doubt the number of foreign sex workers arrested are high.  

    There were 5,783 arrests in 2004, 6,484 in 2005 and 3,245 in the first six months of this year.  

    Deputy Internal Security Minister Datuk Johari Baharum said those arrested were mostly from China, Indonesia and Thailand.  

    There is no reason why men who seek the services of sex workers should be spared.  

    Their pictures should be put up on websites like what some states in the United States are doing.  

    Many sex workers these days opt for the trade to earn fast money but many have also been forced into it by circumstances – some have been abandoned by their husbands and some by husbands who have stopped paying alimony after the divorce.  

    While they have no justification for becoming sex workers, there is really no black and white approach.  

    The simplistic argument from these politicians aside, the sad fact is that these men still see women as objects.  

    Surely, they must have mothers, sisters and daughters.  

    What next from the PAS state government – a ban on the Pagoda brand singlet for it can be indecent to some?  

    Use our strengths to compete on world stage

    The group was there under the Global Leadership Development Programme organised by the International Centre for Leadership in Finance, which comes under Bank Negara. 

    Dr Rubinstein, a highly sought-after speaker on decision-making and innovation, served as a consultant to a committee set up to investigate the loss of a US$125mil (RM448mil) spacecraft belonging to Nasa in 1999. Billions of dollars were lost from research and satellite hardware left in orbit. 

    But Dr Rubinstein, who also teaches engineering, said what was more shocking was the reason for the fiasco – it was the result of a failure to translate the English units of feet and inches into metric units by a ground-based mission software. 

    In short, the spacecraft was lost due to translation failure. The fault was detected early but left alone until a major error occurred, resulting in the spacecraft losing its navigation path. 

    The person who found the error had sent a notification to another person and presumed it had been received. 

    Sounds familiar? We send an e-mail or SMS and we assume that it is received. Often, we do not acknowledge receipt of the note. 

    The message from Dr Rubinstein, who has written eight books on problem solving, is simple: never let a small problem, even if it looks simple, grow big until it cannot be fixed. 

    The guru of strategy shares another message: no matter how difficult a challenge, it can be overcome if people are prepared to collaborate. 

    He cited the construction of the Santa Monica freeway, which was rebuilt in 66 days by a dedicated group after being destroyed in an earthquake. The experts had said it would take two years. 

    There are applications and tools for solving problems but we do not need an expert to tell us about using common sense. 

    On a macro level, the same can be said about the political developments in Malaysia over the recent weeks. 

    We have wasted enough time on issues that have clouded our judgment and stirred our emotions unnecessarily. 

    Malaysia needs to move on and look at the bigger picture. What is over is over and there is no need to keep harping on them. 

    Surely, there are more pressing matters that warrant the attention of all Malaysians instead of useless political rhetoric from various parties and groups. 

    As a small nation, we need to compete for attention in the world economy. We need to tell the world that we are in the game. 

    But we have to get our act right. Malaysians need to put their strength and resources together to check the growing competition from other economies. 

    Our Prime Minister has pointed out that the old economic model no longer works. He is right because the cost of labour in Malaysia is now higher than in Indonesia and Vietnam. 

    What we can do is to leverage our strengths – in terms of networking and cultural links with the three biggest markets in Asia, namely China, India and Indonesia. 

    The Malays have their links to Indonesia, the Chinese and Indians with the two other huge countries. 

    None of our other competitors, either in the region or elsewhere, enjoy the same kind of leverage that we have with these three economies. 

    We are familiar with their languages and way of thinking and doing business, unlike other competitors outside the region. 

    Many of our companies have, in fact, beaten the others in the game long before Indonesia got onto the radar screen. This is particularly so with our plantation and poultry companies. 

    But we need to up the ante, as the saying goes, because there are many other areas we have yet to take advantage of. 

    Prof Uday Karmakar, who teaches at the Anderson School of Management at UCLA, posed one question to his Malaysian listeners: "Why aren't the Asian banks, including those in Malaysia, zooming in on India when the Europeans banks are moving in aggressively?" 

    The Indian-born American academic serves as a consultant for companies such as Ford, GM, IBM, Xerox, Thomson Publishing and the Aditya Biria Group. 

    For the many bankers in the Malaysian group, it is a question many find hard to answer but Malaysian companies certainly need to look beyond our shores. 

    We need to consolidate our strengths, even merge, to compete for a bigger pool of the profits. With just weeks before we begin the 50th year of independence, we need to begin lifting the spirits and stir the passion of all Malaysians.  

     o Wong Chun Wai can be reached at onthebeat@ thestar.com.my

    Comments about this personal website are most welcomed. Please email me.

    Sex city claim can hurt KL

    Bukit Bintang is known to have the best shopping malls, restaurants, hotels and entertainment spots.  

    But has anyone seen Malaysian women in bikinis pole dancing on bar tops or touts inviting foreigners to tiger shows?  

    According to Mohd Said, his Arab friends told him that the sex activities made Malaysia "better than Thailand".  

    Mohd Said is known as the "close one eye" MP for his controversial
    remark to Customs officials to overlook a consignment belonging to his
    company's client that was seized for exceeding the size limit.  

    He had also accused certain Customs officials of selling confiscated
    luxury cars cheaply to their friends in the palace. He could not
    produce any evidence to back his allegations.  

    Mohd Said should have personally investigated what his Arab friends had
    told him and if he could not do it personally, he should have submitted
    the information to the authorities.  

    To make these allegations, just when Malaysia is about launch Visit Malaysia Year 2007 is damaging, to say the least.  

    We like to be known as a destination for family holidays and one where
    wives have no reason to worry when their husbands are here on business
    trips.  

    Most wives know there are very few options for their husbands when they
    come to Kuala Lumpur, but not so in Bangkok, Manila, Phnom Penh,
    Singapore or even Jakarta.  

    Tourism Minister Tengku Adnan Tengku Mansor has correctly rebutted Mohd
    Said, saying that Malaysians and not foreigners are confused as to how
    Malaysia was being promoted overseas.  

    Correction Tengku, it is Mohd Said who is confused and not Malaysians.
    The rest of us are proud of the commercials being aired to promote
    Malaysia ahead of the big event because we understand the economic
    impact.  

    We are ready to put on our best smiles and to extend our famed
    hospitality to the millions of tourists coming our way because they
    like the seas, the forests, the multi-culturalism and the food.  

    These tourists know what to expect of Malaysia when they planned their
    holidays and if racy adult entertainment is their choice, it is
    unlikely that they will pick KL.  

    Sure, there are nightclubs, and if foreigners look hard enough, there
    would be sex workers but surely not on the scale of other sex cities.  

    And if there are local women who like foreigners at bars and pubs, who
    can stop them if they want to go further! It's nobody's business.  

    Let's not mistake the foot massage outlets along Bukit Bintang for tired shoppers, because these are clean places.  

    Bukit Bintang MCA chief Senator Datuk Dr Lee Chong Meng has good
    reasons to be upset and to feel insulted by Mohd Said's remarks. He
    should know his territory better.  

    As Tengku Mansor, the Federal Territory Umno chief said: "We cannot go
    around branding everything which resembles entertainment as sinful and
    illicit."  

    The trouble with many politicians is that while they are quick to
    criticise what they perceive to be sinful, the same decibel is not
    heard when it comes to corruption.  

    Corruption is a sin and surely we should hear more politicians back
    Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi in his fight against graft.  

    Not only are many of our politicians not on the forefront, but they
    also seem to shy away from talking about accountability and
    credibility.  

    Many, including those seemingly religious in their diet and dressing,
    appear to be selective when it comes to their pick of sins. Somehow,
    corruption, abuse of power and women do not affect their religious
    practices, regardless of their spiritual belief.  

    The authorities should also call on Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
    lecturer Zawawi Muhammad Lukman to back his claim in a survey of 4,000
    people, that minors between the ages of nine and 18 were involved in
    vice.  

    This is a serious allegation. He also said he came across a mother who
    asked her 11-year-old daughter to have sex with her boyfriend.  

    The police must find out whether this is a case of sexual abuse, rape
    or prostitution because providing sex for money is something different
    all together.  

    We hope the newspaper has quoted the researcher wrongly, and
    Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Musa Hassan has correctly said the
    police would probe the matter.  

    Again it is an issue that has tarnished the image of Malaysia. For many
    people, including those involved in non-governmental organisations,
    they can only express disbelief.  

    People in position, politicians or otherwise, must realise that they
    cannot simply make general statements which can bring negative
    implications.  

    This damage is irreversible.  

    The bottom line is let's open our eyes when we see something that we know must be brought to the notice of the authorities. 

    Most of us want to move forward

    Malaysians generally do not expect our politicians to admit they have done wrong, let alone to apologise. 

    But it cannot be denied that many Malaysians, regardless of their race, have expressed their unhappiness and uneasiness at the inflammatory speeches made by some Umno delegates. 

    Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and his deputy Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak have done a good job at the party assembly putting the remarks in perspective. They have also given their assurance to non-Malays that they have rights as citizens. 

    Najib has also asked the authorities to investigate the Umno speakers who made remarks deemed to be seditious, describing some as "extreme."  

    Outspoken Umno leader Datuk Seri Nazri Aziz said the law would be allowed to take its course against those who had gone too far. 

    He warned that those who had spoken out of line at the party assembly should be prepared to face the consequences, saying "those who made speeches that were seditious will face the music." 

    Barisan Nasional component party leaders, who attended the Cabinet meeting last week in their capacity as ministers, also expressed their unhappiness at the hurtful remarks made by these delegates. 

    The statements from Umno leaders like Abdullah, Najib and Nazri are reassuring to Malaysians, as their views will be regarded as the official stand of the Umno leadership. 

    If action were to be taken against these irresponsible speakers, it would set a precedent and serve as a warning to other communal-minded politicians from other parties. 

    The message is simple and clear: if you exploit the subjects of race and religion in your fire-and-brimstone speeches, you will be burnt. 

    Umno delegates, in their preoccupation with their share in the Malaysian economy, could have spent more time deliberating on the economic aspects of Pak Lah's speech. 

    Even the media should be blamed. Perhaps there were just too many news angles to choose from and the more sensational aspects like religious ultra-conservatism, press freedom and corruption were picked. 

    Many Malaysians have expressed their views on what they regard as an economic slowdown. Bank Negara may have released good growth figures but among many ordinary Malaysians, the pinch of an increasing cost of living is being felt. 

    Businessmen have complained of fewer jobs and contracts while others have expressed fear of competition from other countries, particularly our drop in Foreign Direct Investments (FDI). 

    Pak Lah has addressed their concerns in an honest and open manner. Those who missed these crucial parts should refer to his full speech again. 

    He acknowledged that Malaysians "want quick results" with complaints "that FDI is slowing" and the "stock market is sluggish." 

    But he has offered reasons – some of our neighbours post impressive FDI numbers because they have allowed their companies to be bought by foreign investors. 

    "We believe in selective mergers and acquisitions, and maintaining control of strategic assets," he said. "We can increase the FDI figures many times over with the stroke of a pen but it will mean loss of control. If I do that, you will be the first to condemn me." 

    He also gave this advice to Umno delegates: be more competitive and innovative because the new way breeds more confidence, and that future economic growth will not just be dependent upon government spending but will be based on innovation and creativity. 

    It's a shame that the words of the Prime Minister were lost in the sound and fury of some Umno speakers. 

    In a globalised economy, where even the concept of a nation-state is losing its importance, we cannot escape from adapting to a borderless world. 

    Pak Lah has spoken of a "transformative effect" that he wished to create – it is now up to Malaysians to help him realise his wish. 

    No Malaysians should blame their fellow countrymen if they fall behind.  

     

  • Wong Chun Wai can be reached at onthebeat@thestar.com.my 
  • No place for racist remarks

    The newspapers and TV stations can be directed to tone down political temperature but Internet news websites and bloggers are there to record the irresponsible words spouted by these politicians. 

    And thanks to free video-sharing website YouTube (www.youtube.com), we may even get to see the antics of those who get carried away with their rhetoric in the belief that they can play to the gallery, be popular and still not be held accountable for their words. 

    The days of politicians saying one thing in the Malay newspapers and giving another version to the English or Chinese newspapers, to cater to different audiences for political expediency, are over too.  

    Nothing escapes the attention of Malaysians these days and if politicians have still not woken up to this reality, then they will be haunted by the ghosts of their communal statements at the next general election. 

    Neither can they escape the heat by blaming the press for misquoting them. Politicians must be accountable for their words and actions. It's that simple. 

    The issue is not whether the annual general meetings of communal-based parties should be telecast live. The issue is that delegates to these party assemblies must take responsibility for what they say. It's the content, not the communication tool, that matters. 

    The speakers are after all picked by their respective state liaisons. The permanent chairmen of the various parties, who preside at these meetings, can interrupt to stop speakers from making remarks that are not just hurtful to other Malaysians but can be seditious in nature. In short, there is no place for issues relating to race and religion in Malaysia. 

    If these delegates were to carry on with their fire and brimstone speeches, then the wrong message would be sent out. Worse, Malaysians may assume that their views have been endorsed even if they were just expressing their personal views.  

    But when delegates speak at assemblies, they also represent their respective state or division. 

    In one particular case, Umno Youth information chief Datuk Azimi Daim is a state executive councillor in Kedah.  

    He is a senior Umno leader and should be wise and responsible enough to refrain from making remarks that might give rise to misinterpretation. 

    On Monday, Umno deputy president Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak said future Umno general assemblies may not be telecast live, given the flak the party has received over this year's proceedings. 

    Many people felt that the telecast was an inappropriate thing because it gave a distorted view of Umno proceedings.  

    Najib who is Deputy Prime Minister said it was up to the Umno supreme council to decide but said the leadership was seriously looking into the wisdom of having a live telecast. 

    He also admitted that certain speeches during the just concluded assembly were extreme, adding that delegates should realise that "when they speak, there are others outside the party who are also listening." 

    The racist remarks by a few delegates created unease among the Barisan Nasional component members and have continued to be a talking point among ordinary Malaysians, who felt it was out of place in our attempts to forge national unity. 

    On Tuesday, MCA vice-president Datuk Seri Dr Chua Soi Lek also said such AGMs should not be televised, saying all AGMS were racially charged including the MCA and MIC meetings. 

    It is common to hear delegates at Umno, MCA or MIC meetings talk about defending their community rights but there is surely no need to intimidate or make threats. 

    Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi has proven that he did not have to make racial statements to climb to the top of the party hierarchy.  

    He has always been consistently moderate, which puts him high above the rest. He should be a model for party aspirants as he stands for all Malaysians, not just one race. 

    Umno leaders have tried to assure non-Malays over the past few days that the views of these few delegates did not represent the thinking of the Umno leadership. Most Malaysians would agree but certainly it was not comforting for many.  

    Malaysians look forward to the day when party delegates speak of orang kita, woh men or nam el lorum, when they really mean their fellow Malaysians and not just their own race.  

    After all, they get their votes in the general election from not just one but all ethnic groups.  

     

     

    Listen to the voice of reason

    He may not be an eloquent speaker but it was surely one of Abdullah's best speeches. 

    The Prime Minister could have played to the gallery to boost his popularity, in the wake of a challenge against his leadership, with rhetoric on the Malay Agenda.  

    But he did not, remembering that he is the leader of all communities. 

    And he rightly lowered down the political temperature in this winding-up speech on Friday by declaring that Umno must speak for all. 

    More important, he said Umno must never forget the rights of the other races as stipulated in the Constitution. 

    Umno leaders, especially elected representatives, must also never forget that their victory at the general election is not from the support of one race.  

    In close contests, particularly in predominantly Malay constituencies, they need the deciding votes of the non-Muslims. 

    It is the same for MCA and Gerakan leaders. They can demand Chinese rights loudly but they must never take for granted the Umno leaders who deliver the Malay votes for them. 

    It is this arrangement that has worked so well for Barisan Nasional because the leaders understand that they need each other. 

    It is easy to label the DAP or PAS as being extremists but such elements do exist within Barisan component parties as well. They are probably more damaging than the opposition. 

    Criticism and unhappiness on sensitive issues have always been discussed within the BN forum but when the floodgates are opened with direct attacks on fellow BN leaders, it would be more difficult to contain. 

    Component party leaders, under pressure from their members and voters, may feel compelled to speak up to show their political bravery but this can only bring short-term gains.  

    The long-term damage is far greater because there is always a price to pay for hurtful words. 

    Likewise, the keris-rattling and posturing on Malay dominance at the assembly is disturbing.  

    It cannot be denied that many non-Malays are concerned. 

    A statement by Malacca delegate Hasnoor Sidang Hussein, who reportedly reminded party members that the time had come for Malays to act against those who undermined Malay rights, was clearly seditious. 

    So was talk about unsheathing the keris, which is now being openly debated over the Internet.  

    What would young Malaysians think of their future?  

    Pak Lah has opened up the democratic space and exercised greater tolerance for dissent, but there must be self-restraint and ground rules. 

    The advice given before the assembly by Pak Lah and his deputy Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak that delegates should not hurt the feelings of other races seems to have fallen on deaf ears among some Umno delegates. 

    Kedah delegate Tajul Urus Mohd Zain, in his attempt to defend Port Klang Assemblyman Datuk Zakaria Deros, came out with figures of illegal places of worship with claims of an agenda against the Selangor strongman. 

    Not only was there a racial slant, he conveniently forgot to mention that Zakaria did not bother to pay his assessment fees amounting to over RM46,800 for the last 12 years. Only recently did he finally pay up. 

    How many Malaysians, including Umno members, would be able to get away with that? 

    Tajul Urus said that "certain people had used the Zakaria issue to tarnish the image of Umno" – which seems an odd way to defend Zakaria. 

    Delegates should also research better for the assembly because some speakers quoted wrong facts and figures. 

    One delegate criticised those who spread the rumours alleging a baptism ceremony of Malays at a church but went on to repeat the figure of 200,000 Malays said to have become apostates.  

    That figure, which is an imaginary number, has long been disputed. 

    Ayer Itam Wanita delegate Rahimah Idris criticised the wives of ministers for their dressing, citing a minister's wife who wore a skirt at her ex-husband's funeral.  

    We are not sure whom she was referring to, but there is no such image in our photo archives. 

    Surely there were more urgent and serious matters to discuss at the general assembly of our country's dominant party. 

    It is easy to demand for slices of the economic cake, but it would have been good to hear from the delegates how the country's economic policies and strategies could be strengthened and improved. 

    There is too much head-to-head competition in an economy that is already slow, and it has seemingly led to what is called a struggle over a shrinking profit pool. 

    In Pak Lah's words: "Bumiputras are unhappy that targets have not been reached while non-bumiputras are restless because they perceive that a time extension might mean they will not achieve equality." 

    He clearly understands that Malaysia is not built by the blood, sweat and tears of one race but by all Malaysians.  

    The Malays should not be made to feel insecure and, certainly, the Chinese and Indians are no longer immigrants but citizens with equal rights. 

    There is a need to move away from the "them versus us" mentality because, as what has been described as the Blue Ocean Strategy, everyone should work together to look for uncontested market space and to make competition irrelevant. 

    For example, the country's demography has changed tremendously with Malays making up over 60% while the Chinese population has shrunk. More and more hotels and restaurants now serve halal food because they see the expansion of a Malay middle-class, which is good for the country. 

    Likewise, Chinese-owned direct-selling companies have focused their attention on Malay customers.  

    It is here where the Malays and Chinese can forge true business partnership. 

    With the shift towards West Asia, it helps to have Muslim partners and executives for non-Malay companies. 

    There is no need for Malays to be uptight when Chinese companies insist on Chinese-speaking workers for trading with mainlanders.  

    It may seem like discrimination but it is also against many English and Malay-educated Chinese. 

    The investments of Malaysian companies overseas brought home RM1.4bil in 2005 from RM400mil in 1999. 

    The bottom line, as Pak Lah said, is that in a flattening world Malaysians – regardless of race – need to improve in order to become marketable and adaptable in a globalised world.  

    Malaysians should have a wider perspective of economic issues as trade barriers and protectionist rules are dismantled. 

    It is clear from this Umno general assembly that the Prime Minister is very much in control. Make no mistake about it.