Author Archives: wcw

Heritage preservation over politics


No profit in it: The piece of land on which KLSCAH sits is no longer of any commercial value because it cannot be converted into any other use such as to put up an office block or a high-rise residential condominium. — Filepic/The Star

THIS is what happens when everything is looked at through a racial lens.

There is now a hue and cry over the 99-year lease extension for the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall (KLSCAH) at a nominal premium of RM1,000.

Across the country places of worship, mission schools, charitable organisations, and cultural associations regularly receive token land premiums or quit-rent reductions.

Granting nominal premiums to non-profit, religious, educational, and heritage bodies is a long- standing administrative practice across Malaysia, not an exception carved out for one group.

The rationale is simple: When an organisation operates on a non-profit basis and serves a public or community function, public policy favours allowing it to channel its limited resources into maintenance and community programmes rather than paying commercial land taxes to the state.

The KLSCAH issue has triggered a largely unnecessary public controversy.

What ought to have been a straightforward discussion on heritage has instead degenerated into a debate with racial overtones.

Could this be because Federal Territories Minister Hannah Yeoh happens to be a DAP leader and is an easy target?

At the heart of the dispute is a comparison between the RM1,000 nominal fee and the site’s estimated commercial renewal valuation of RM4.67mil.

Critics have seized upon this figure to argue that the government forfeited millions in public revenue to favour a specific community institution.

However, framing the issue as a zero-sum racial concession ignores the strict legal conditions attached to the renewal, as well as established land administration norms in Malaysia.

First and foremost, KLSCAH did not receive a commercial windfall; in fact, it permanently surrendered its commercial development rights.

According to clarifications from Yeoh and the hall’s leadership, the nominal premium was granted only after KLSCAH agreed to convert the land’s status from commercial to institutional use.

In short, the piece of land on which KLSCAH sits is no longer of any commercial value because it cannot be converted into any other use such as to put up an office block or a high-rise condominium.

Under its previous title, the prime Jalan Maharajalela plot reportedly held substantial market value precisely because it could theoretically be redeveloped for such commercial purposes.

By accepting institutional zoning, KLSCAH has given up its commercial interest. It is now legally barred from monetising the land for private commercial development.

Expecting a non-profit organisation to pay a commercial-rate premium for land it can never commercially exploit runs counter to basic principles of land valuation.

Second, the building’s status as a protected historical monument places heavy financial responsibilities on its custodians.

Completed in 1934, the distinctive 103-year-old neoclassical structure was officially gazetted as a National Heritage site in 2007 under the National Heritage Act 2005.

While heritage gazettement recognises a building’s architectural and historical significance to the nation, it also imposes strict limitations on renovations and demands continuous, specialised maintenance to preserve the facade and interior.

Unlike a commercial landlord who can tear down an ageing structure to maximise floor-area ratios, a heritage custodian bears the ongoing cost of conservation for the public’s cultural benefit.

In short, KLSCAH has no commercial development value and runs an annual operating deficit of about RM400,000 as a result of its ageing structure and increasing maintenance costs.

KLSCAH has long played a huge role in Kuala Lumpur’s civic life.

Although founded a century ago to serve the Chinese community in Selangor and Kuala Lumpur, the hall has evolved over the decades into an inclusive public square.

Its auditoriums and meeting rooms routinely host multiracial civil society forums, academic lectures, arts performances, book launches, and national dialogues open to all Malaysians regardless of background.

Treating the institution purely through a narrow communal lens overlooks its broader contribution to the capital’s democratic and cultural fabric.

Strangely, the loudest critics to the nominal premium to KLSCAH are often also the quietest mice over the colossal sums of corruption and financial abuses in the country.

Why LTAT must pause and explain the RM4.3bil Boustead Plantations deal

AT a glance, a take-over of a palm oil plantation would just be a simple business transaction and a business news report, except that in this case, it involves a huge asset of the Armed Forces Fund Board (LTAT).

The LTAT has a huge role as it manages the pension savings fund for members of the Malaysian Armed Forces and volunteer forces.

Enlisted personnel contribute 10% of their monthly salary while the government contributes 15%, totalling 25%.

It operates as a government-linked investment company holding stakes in major enterprises such as Boustead Holdings and Affin Bank.

So, eyebrows were raised when the media recently reported that LTAT had selected Achi Jaya Plantations Sdn Bhd for a reported RM4.3bil takeover of Boustead Plantations Bhd (BPlant).

The almost unheard-of company edged out major industry contenders SD Guthrie Bhd and Tradewinds Plantation Bhd.

It has raised questions and concerns as strategic Malaysian assets and retirement funds are managed.

When a deal of this magnitude involves the savings of our armed forces personnel, the public deserves far more clarity than what has been offered so far. Given the unanswered questions surrounding the transaction.

It would not be wrong for LTAT to seriously consider deferring the deal until full transparency is provided. The biggest issue is the question of scale and capability.

Looking at the numbers, the disparity between the winning bidder and the asset being acquired is hard to ignore.

Based on its November 2025 Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) audit, Achi Jaya manages 11,702 hectares of planted oil palm in Chaah, Johor.

BPlant, on the other hand, holds a total land bank of roughly 97,500 hectares, including 72,200 hectares of planted oil palm.

In practical terms, Achi Jaya is taking on a plantation operation more than six times its current planted footprint.

Yet, it has successfully outbid two established heavyweights: SD Guthrie, one of the world’s largest palm oil producers, and Tradewinds Plantation, a major domestic operator.

Without an explanation from LTAT, it is difficult to understand what operational or strategic edge placed a much smaller private firm ahead of these industry giants.

There are also many unanswered questions on financing and ownership. The estimated RM4.3bil price tag represents a 23.9% premium (roughly RM830mil) over the RM3.47bil equity valuation of Kuala Lumpur Kepong Bhd (KLK).

The deal collapsed following intense political pushback over concerns that LTAT would cede control of a strategic Bumiputera-linked plantation asset to a non-Bumiputera conglomerate.

Kudos must be given to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim for stopping it given the political sensitivities. In the process, the value has now gone up by about RM2bil.

In the case of the current take-over, neither LTAT nor Achi Jaya has issued an official statement detailing the exact equity stake being sold, the payment structure, or how Achi Jaya intends to finance a multi-billion-ringgit acquisition.

A search with the Companies Commission of Malaysia (SSM) showed Achi Jaya has links to Tan Sri Onn Mahmud, the younger brother of former Sarawak governor and chief minister, the late Tun Abdul Taib Mahmud.

Onn holds a direct 11.91% stake in Achi Jaya and an additional 14.3% through Achi Jaya Holdings.

Meanwhile, the majority of the company is split evenly between two entities—Grand Shine Trading Ltd and Herolite Investment Ltd—each holding a 36.89% stake, according to The Edge Malaysia. Questions have been raised about Hong Kong business interests or offshore-linked entities involved.

The reality is that LTAT is not an ordinary investment institution — it holds in trust the retirement savings and future of Malaysian Armed Forces personnel and veterans.

Any high-value disposal without clear financial justification risks would have serious implications, as it can potentially erode public confidence.

As Berita Harian rightly pointed out, “Until LTAT addresses the glaring information gaps, governance advocates argue that the transaction should be placed on hold. “

With the retirement funds of Malaysia’s armed forces personnel at stake, market watchers maintain that speed cannot come at the expense of accountability—and that pausing the deal for full disclosure is the most prudent path forward.

The newspaper suggested that deferring the execution of the sale would allow LTAT to publicly establish three critical safeguards, namely proof of financial capacity, bid comparison transparency and beneficial ownership disclosure.

The deal involves national strategic assets and Bumiputra equity objectives, and the retirement funds of Malaysia’s armed forces personnel are at stake.

There is no reason to rush through this, as accountability is a top priority and pausing the deal for full disclosure would be the best path forward.

Reality of Malaysia’s changing demographics


For young parents, having more children involves significant opportunity costs and additional expenses, including childcare, housing and education. — Magnific

THE Malaysian Chinese population has been shrinking steadily as a proportion of the country’s population, so no one should be surprised by the latest figures.

According to the Department of Statistics Malaysia, Chinese Malaysians number about 6.83 million, accounting for 22.1% of the country’s 34.39 million population. The Malays make up 58.3%, Indians 6.5%, while other bumiputra account for 12.3%.

The figures become particularly stark when viewed over several decades. In 1970, Chinese Malaysians made up 34.1% of the population. By 2020, that proportion had fallen to 23.2%, and by 2024, it stood at 22.4% of the citizen population.

There is, however, an important distinction. The absolute number of Chinese Malaysians has not declined. Those numbers increased from approximately 3.6 million in 1970 to around 6.9 million in 2024.

It is their proportion of the overall population that has steadily diminished. We do not need experts to explain why. Much of the answer is visible around us.

Chinese Malaysians are generally marrying later, often in their late 20s or early 30s. Career advancement and financial stability tend to take priority, while the cost of raising children has become an increasingly important consideration.

For women, delaying marriage and motherhood can also affect the number of children they eventually have. The average Chinese family today is more likely to have one or two children, compared with larger families in previous generations. Malay families, on average, tend to be bigger, with marriages also generally taking place at a younger age.

There is another issue that deserves attention: the emigration of young Malaysians.

Many Chinese Malaysian families have children studying abroad, and some eventually decide to build their lives elsewhere. Australia, Britain, Singapore, Canada and even China have attracted Malaysians seeking education, employment and professional opportunities.

We should resist the temptation to blame young people for choosing to have fewer children. They are making decisions based on the realities of their lives, including financial pressures, career aspirations and changing expectations.

Part of the responsibility lies with governments, employers and society who need to create an envi­­ronment in which starting and raising a family is less difficult.

The reality is that wealthier, highly urbanised and educated societies tend to experience lower fertility rates. This is happening not just in Malaysia but also in Singapore, Japan, Taiwan and Hong Kong.

Malaysia must therefore prepare for a future in which its population structure will look very different from what previous generations experienced.

For the Chinese Malaysian community, this means recognising that cultural continuity cannot be taken for granted. Language, traditions, schools, businesses, associations and community institutions all require the younger generation’s interest and participation if they are to survive.

There are also political implications.

The Indian community is no longer numerically predominant in any state or parliamentary constituency, and the same demographic reality could eventually affect Chinese Malaysians.

But we must not turn demographics into an ethnic competition. Instead, this should be approached with sensitivity. Malaysia must place greater emphasis on our shared identity as Malaysians rather than race and religion.

Politicians who continue to exploit racial and religious sentiments may eventually find that such narratives have diminishing returns. The Chinese community, too, can only be used as a political bogeyman to a certain extent.

Malaysia’s strength is not measured by whether one ethnic group increases or decreases its share of the population.

Its success should be measured by whether all communities can live together, contribute to the economy and enjoy dignity and equal opportunities. The demographic challenge should concern us all regardless of ethnicity.

Indeed, while Chinese fertility is particularly low, Malaysia’s overall fertility rate has also fallen below replacement level.

The country is heading towards being an ageing society, making this a national challenge rather than an exclusively Chinese one.

A demographic transition takes decades to unfold, and reversing it, if possible, takes even longer.

In his latest book, In the Realm of the Last Man, political scientist Francis Fukuyama has written about the global decline in birthrates, particularly in wealthier societies. He cites Italy, Spain, Japan, Singapore, Taiwan and South Korea, the last of which has a total fertility rate hovering below 0.8, far below the replacement level of about 2.1 children per woman.

He argues that female education and employment are among the fundamental drivers of declining fertility.

A stay-at-home mother, he observes, is essentially an uncompensated worker. As women’s incomes and employment opportunities rise, it makes economic sense for more women to enter the paid workforce, while childcare and other responsibilities increasingly have to be outsourced.

Having more children therefore involves significant opportunity costs and additional expenses, including childcare, housing and education.

In many wealthy societies, more young women are now receiving higher education than men, giving them stronger lifetime earnings prospects.

Consequently, some are putting off marriage and childbearing, while others are choosing not to have children at all.

The question is not whether Malaysia’s population will change. It already has.

The real question is whether we are prepared for the economic, social and cultural consequences of that change.

Selective outrage of our race-and-religion politicians

Many here are celebrating the victories by some Muslim candidates in the US mid-term elections, but the results are more than about those few wins – they are about inclusivity, diversity and shared power.

IT’S twisted logic, really. There is something rather amusing, even ironic, about the way some of our politicians are reacting to the US mid-term elections.

When it comes to Malaysian politics, some are quick to invoke race and religion, insisting that these are the most important considerations when deciding who should lead the country.

One particular party leader has even said that is better to vote for a corrupt Muslim leader than an honest non-Muslim one.

They have built much of their political messaging around racial identity, religious affiliation and the need to protect particular communities.

Yet, when the results of the recent US midterm elections came in, some of these same politicians were quick to celebrate the victory of Muslim candidates. Suddenly, the message was about representation, diversity and the breaking of barriers.

There was much enthusiasm over Abdul El-Sayed becoming the first Muslim elected to the US Senate.

It was certainly a historic achievement, and there is every reason to acknowledge the significance of his victory.

But why stop there? The Nov 3 elections produced a remarkable list of historic firsts.

They saw women, African Americans, Latinos, Native Americans and members of the LGBTQ community elected to important positions.

Among them was Chris Pappas, who became the first openly gay man elected to the US Senate. Deb Haaland became the first Native American woman elected governor of a state.

Keisha Lance Bottoms became the first Black woman to occupy the governor’s office in Georgia.

Gina Hinojosa made history as Texas’ first Latina governor, while Peggy Flanagan became the first Native American woman elected to the US Senate.

These were not insignificant achievements. They represent a broadening of political representation in a country that has long struggled with questions of race, identity and equal opportunity.

Yet, one wonders whether our politicians who were so enthusiastic about the Muslim victories would be equally generous in acknowledging the achievements of these other candidates.

Why celebrate one identity while conveniently overlooking others?

The irony becomes even more apparent when we consider that these victories were not confined to one political party.

Florida elected Republican Byron Donalds as its first Black governor, while other historic breakthroughs came from Democratic candidates.

The American electorate, whatever its political divisions, has demonstrated that voters can choose candidates from different backgrounds and identities based on a much wider range of considerations.

It would not be wrong to assume many American voters were simply fed up of President Donald Trump’s war cry and religious chest-thumping – in this case, the White Christian narrative.

Of course, nobody should suggest that Malaysia can simply transplant the American political system into our own.

Our history, constitutional arrangements, demographics and political realities are different.

But there are lessons worth considering.

The American elections showed that a candidate’s religion, race, gender or sexual orientation need not automatically disqualify that person from seeking the highest public office.

Voters are also capable of looking beyond identity to examine a candidate’s policies, leadership, experience and ability to serve the wider population.

That is the distinction our politicians should understand.

In Malaysia, we have too often witnessed political narratives that encourage communities to view one another with suspicion. Race and religion are repeatedly brought into political conversations, sometimes at the expense of more pressing national concerns such as the cost of living, education, employment, corruption and economic opportunities.

Our politicians cannot have it both ways.

They cannot champion religious representation when it suits their political narrative abroad, but question the legitimacy or suitability of people from other backgrounds when discussing leadership at home.

If the election of a Muslim senator in America is celebrated as a victory for inclusion, then surely the election of a woman, a Black politician, a Latino, a Native American or an openly gay politician should also be recognised as part of the same democratic principle.

Representation should not be a selective celebration.

There is also an important distinction between respecting someone’s religious identity and expecting political leaders to govern primarily along religious lines. A Muslim politician in America is elected to represent all constituents, not Muslims alone.

The same applies to a Christian, Jew, Hindu or a politician of no religious faith. That is what public service is supposed to mean.

Malaysia, with its multiracial and multireligious population, has much to gain from a political culture that puts the interests of the nation above narrow communal considerations.

We should be asking whether our leaders can bring people together, rather than constantly reminding us of the differences that separate us.

Perhaps our politicians should look at the US results more closely. Not just at the Muslim victories that they were so eager to celebrate, but at the entire picture.

The message from the ballot box was much bigger than religion.

It was about the right of people from different backgrounds to participate in democracy and be judged as individuals.

If we can applaud that principle in America, why should it be so difficult to practise it in Malaysia?

Unity cannot be celebrated selectively, and diversity cannot be embraced only when it suits our political convenience.

That is a lesson worth bringing home. Malaysia belongs to Malaysians of all faiths and races.

A greeting by any other name is just as sweet


Happy Diwali or Happy Deepavali? What is more important is that we always celebrate together as Malaysians. — KAMARUL ARIFFIN/YAP CHEE HONG/The Star

FOR a long time, we have wished our Indian friends “Happy Deepavali”, our Malay friends “Selamat Hari Raya” and our Chinese friends “Kong Hei Fatt Choy” in Cantonese or “Keong Hee Huat Chye” in Hokkien.

It was that simple. Everyone understood the goodwill behind the greetings. Nobody needed a dictionary, a cultural seminar, or a social media debate to explain what we meant.

Today, even the names of festivals can become controversial: Deepavali versus Diwali, Hari Raya versus Lebaran, buka puasa versus iftar, and Kong Hei Fatt Choy versus Gong Xi Fa Cai.

Call them what you will; the celebrations remain essentially the same. But identity matters, and we know how sensitive cultural and ethnic issues can be.

The irony is that Malaysia’s multicultural character has always rested on shared celebrations, open houses, exchanged greetings and food from different communities. Yet social media can turn almost every linguistic difference into a dispute.

Take Deepavali and Diwali. Both refer to the Hindu festival of lights, with the names shaped by regional, linguistic, and cultural traditions. Deepavali is widely used in Malaysia, Brunei, and Singapore, while Diwali is more common in parts of India and among Indian communities in countries such as the United States and Britain.

Neither should be treated as a threat to the other.

The same applies to Hari Raya and Lebaran. Hari Raya Aidilfitri is familiar in Malaysia, while Lebaran is widely used in Indonesia, alongside Idulfitri.

Shared traditions do not require identical vocabulary. We can appreciate our neighbours’ expressions without abandoning our own.

Buka puasa and iftar likewise refer to breaking the Ramadan fast. One term is a deeply familiar one in Malaysia, while the other is the Arabic term widely used across the Muslim world. Neither makes someone more religious or authentic.

The spirit of Ramadan lies in generosity, compassion, and fellowship, not in policing the words used at the dining table.

Among Malaysian Chinese, “Kong Hei Fatt Choy” and “Gong Xi Fa Cai” reflect different linguistic traditions. Cantonese, Hokkien, Hakka, and other Chinese dialects have shaped local speech, while Mandarin has become increasingly prominent through education and the media.

A Cantonese greeting is not outdated, just as a Mandarin greeting does not erase local heritage. Both have a place in our linguistically diverse society. Ultimately, the choice may come down to personal preference, family tradition, or simply what is most convenient.

But the growing dominance of Mandarin worries me, particularly in Penang, where the distinctive local variety of Hok-kien risks being lost.

Many younger Chinese Malaysians, having attended Chinese primary schools, are more comfortable speaking Mandarin than Hokkien. For Baby Boomers like me, who received our education in English-medium schools, navigating conversations in Penang can sometimes be a struggle.

I insist on speaking my distinctive Penang Hokkien, which I am proud of, but it may be a losing battle.

Then there is the wider debate over Christmas greetings.

In many Western countries, “Merry Christmas” was once the standard seasonal greeting, used freely in public spaces, workplaces, and schools. Increasingly, some institutions and corporations have adopted “Happy Holidays” instead.

There is a reasonable explanation for this. Christmas falls during a period when people also observe Hanukkah, New Year, and other religious or cultural occasions. “Happy Holidays” is intended to include everyone, including those who do not celebrate Christmas.

It can be a courteous gesture, although commercial considerations may have also played a part. The intention is to avoid assuming that everyone shares the same faith or tradition.

However, the growing use of “Happy Holidays” has also led to debates over what is commonly called woke culture, particularly the argument that public language should be adjusted to avoid excluding or offending particular groups.

In the United States and parts of Europe, critics argue that traditional Christian greetings are being abandoned in the name of diversity, sometimes creating the impression that the majority must set aside its customs to accommodate others.

There is a distinction between being considerate and becoming excessively anxious about causing offence.

In its best form, inclusive language encourages sensitivity and respect. In its worst form, it can make ordinary expressions seem unacceptable simply because not everyone shares the same beliefs.

There is nothing inherently wrong with saying “Happy Holidays” when addressing a mixed audience. Nor is there anything wrong with wishing someone “Merry Christmas”.

The problem begins when one greeting is presented as morally superior to the other, or when people are made to feel that saying “Merry Christmas” is insensitive, outdated, or politically incorrect.

Christians should not have to apologise for saying “Merry Christmas”, just as non-Christians should not be pressured to use the greeting.

Courtesy should leave room for both. A company may choose “Happy Holidays” for a general advertisement, while an individual may warmly wish a Christian friend “Merry Christmas”. There is no contradiction.

The purpose of inclusive language should be to widen the circle of respect, not erase familiar traditions. If every religious greeting is replaced by a neutral phrase for fear of offending someone, public life may become less contentious but also less meaningful.

Diversity should not require us to remove all references to faith and culture from our shared vocabulary.

The larger problem is not that different names exist, but that we sometimes treat those differences as challenges to our identity.

Learning another community’s preferred terminology is respectful. Humiliating someone for using a familiar expression in good faith is not.

If someone wishes us Happy Deepavali, Selamat Hari Raya, Kong Hei Fatt Choy or Merry Christmas, our first response should be to appreciate the goodwill behind the greeting.

Of course, precise terminology matters in certain contexts, including official documents and educational materials. Commu-nities should also be free to explain how they prefer their festivals to be named.

But respect must work both ways. We should not belittle another community’s language or demand that people abandon expressions rooted in family, heritage, and memory.

We must also distinguish genuine courtesy from compulsory conformity. It is courteous to ask how someone prefers to be addressed or to learn the name a community uses for its celebration. It is unreasonable to assume that every traditional expression is offensive simply because it is not universally shared.

Our multicultural identity is not built on having identical words for everything. It is built on understanding differences without feeling threatened by them.

Deepavali can co-exist with Diwali, Hari Raya with Lebaran, buka puasa with iftar, Kong Hei Fatt Choy with Gong Xi Fa Cai, and Merry Christmas with Happy Holidays.

Cultural pride should give us the confidence to cherish our own traditions while making room for others. If we can share our homes, food, friendships, and celebrations, surely we can accommodate different names for the same joy.

More importantly, Malaysia’s tradition of holding open houses during festive occasions remains one of our greatest strengths. Malaysians of different ethnicities and faiths visit one another, share meals, and celebrate together.

We do not need to turn every festival greeting into a religious or ideological debate. Sometimes, all it takes is common sense and a willingness to appreciate one another as fellow Malaysians.

Our country has long shown that people can live together without speaking, praying, or celebrating in exactly the same way. We should not allow excessive sensitivity to turn every greeting into a test of political correctness.

Good manners are not about finding one approved phrase for everyone. They are about understanding the person, the occasion, and the goodwill behind the words.

In Malaysia, we do not need to speak exactly the same language to understand one another. Sometimes, the most Malaysian response is also the simplest: smile, say thank you, and wish one another well.

After all, whatever names we use for our festivals, the spirit remains the same. We are Malaysians celebrating together, sharing goodwill, and embracing the goodness that brings us closer.

Mat rempit are not political props


Danger on the roads: A file photo provided by the police of a round-up of motorcycle riders caught performing stunts near in George Town. — PDRM Penang

IT used to be just a small group of young men speeding down the road on their roaring motorcycles – but now, it seems to have grown monstrously.

Last week, Penang police had to break up a large illegal street racing event near the Butterworth Outer Ring Road toll plaza in Bagan Ajam.

A large-scale operation was carried out after viral social media videos showed a massive crowd of mat rempit. They reportedly blocked the highway toll exit with their bikes to turn the public road into a makeshift racing circuit. The illegal blockade forced heavy vehicles like lorries to slam on their brakes, disrupting traffic and causing severe safety risks.

In April, a group of mat rempit in Kota Baru turned the flyover ramp of the newly upgraded Sultan Ismail Petra Airport into an illegal racing track.

While these are obviously illegal gatherings, Malaysians have also noticed large scale “convoys”, or sanctioned motorcycle rides, led by politicians.

No one argues against convoys that have received the approvals of the respective authorities, including the police.

But there have been fatal accidents.

In July, four riders died in a crash involving 12 motorcycles and a car on the East Coast Highway near the Jabor toll plaza in Kuantan.

They were reportedly travelling towards Kemaman, Terengganu, for a RXZ members gathering (RXZ refers to the Yamaha RX-Z motorcycle model).

In August, five participants died in separate road accidents while travelling to or returning from the RXZ members 7.0 gathering in Terengganu.

The event attracted thousands of motorcycle enthusiasts. Obvi-ously, there is an attraction among Malaysia’s young voters for motorcycle convoys.

But there is something seriously wrong when politicians, who should be setting examples of responsible behaviour, choose to court popularity by organising or joining motorcycle convoys without giving sufficient attention to the message they are sending.

The sight of a politician surrounded by hundreds of motorcyclists may make for an impressive photograph.

The roar of engines, the cheering crowds, and the spectacle of motorcycles moving together can create an atmosphere of excitement. For a politician seeking public attention, it is an opportunity that’s difficult to resist.

But beyond the photographs and social media postings, a more fundamental question needs to be asked: What exactly are these politicians promoting?

Are they encouraging responsible riding, road safety, and constructive engagement with young people? Or are they simply exploiting the appeal of the mat rempit culture for political mileage ahead of the general election?

This is not an argument against motorcyclists. Far from it.

Millions of Malaysians depend on motorcycles for their daily commute, while many young people have a genuine passion for motorcycles, engines, and motorsports. They deserve respect, opportunities, and the right to pursue their interests safely.

We must also be careful not to label every young motorcyclist a mat rempit. Not everyone who joins a convoy is involved in illegal racing, dangerous stunts, or traffic offences.

There is a clear distinction between celebrating motorcycle culture and appearing to glamorise behaviour associated with reckless riding, illegal street racing, and a disregard for traffic laws.

Politicians, of all people, should know the difference.

More importantly, they should understand that their public appearances carry a responsibility that goes beyond the immediate excitement of an event.

Malaysia has spent years trying to educate road users about the dangers of reckless riding. Road safety campaigns warn against speeding, dangerous manoeuvres, and the failure to wear helmets.

Families have lost sons and daughters in road accidents, while survivors have had to live with permanent injuries.

Motorcyclists are particularly vulnerable because they have little physical protection when an accident occurs. A moment of recklessness can destroy not only the rider’s future but also the lives of family members who depend on them.

Against this backdrop, politicians should be sending an unmistakable message: Obey the law, respect other road users, and never put lives at risk for entertainment, excitement, or public attention.

Instead, there are political leaders who enthusiastically associate themselves with motorcycle gatherings without making responsible riding a clear priority.

These politicians risk sending precisely the wrong signal. It is not enough to insist that an event is merely a community engagement programme.

Last month, a political party even added a religious twist to its massive motor convoy by claiming it was aimed at propagating faith.

The public is entitled to examine the circumstances, the conduct being encouraged, and the example being set.

If politicians want to reach out to young motorcyclists, they should do so by promoting discipline, providing opportunities, and addressing their concerns. They should not depend on the spectacle of a convoy to create an impression of popularity.

Unfortunately, this sort of political theatre has become increasingly familiar.

A politician turns up at an event, is greeted enthusiastically by a crowd, poses for photographs, perhaps climbs onto a motorcycle, and leaves with a collection of images suitable for social media platforms.

The message is simple: Look at how popular I am; look at how many young people support me.

But popularity is not the same as good leadership, and a large crowd is not proof that a politician has earned the public’s trust.

The problem with politics built around such spectacles is that it rewards immediate visibility rather than meaningful results.

Politicians cannot tell young people to obey the law on Monday and then appear indifferent to the same issue when seeking their support on the weekend.

It would be good if politicians use such gatherings to promote helmet use, road discipline, and community safety, and not merely to “ride” a wave of popularity.

If the principal attraction is the political spectacle, then the exercise deserves greater scrutiny.

Where are the politicians when the cameras are gone? The real test begins when the engines stop and the cameras are switched off.

What have these politicians actually done for the young people whose company they so eagerly seek?

These are fair questions, not an attempt to deny politicians the right to engage with any section of society.

Young people should not be treated as a convenient audience that can be mobilised whenever a politician needs to demonstrate grassroots support.

They are citizens with real problems, ambitions, and expectations. They deserve more than an occasional appearance by an elected representative.

For some, motorcycles are simply a means of getting to work. For others, they represent an affordable hobby or a possible career.

A minority may be drawn into illegal racing because of peer pressure, the excitement of speed, or the desire for recognition.

The motivations are not all the same, and the solutions cannot be reduced to blanket condemnation.

Neither can the problems be solved by politicians who choose to flatter young people without challenging behaviour that endangers them and others.

A responsible leader must be prepared to tell a crowd what it needs to hear, not merely what it wants to hear. That includes reminding riders that public roads are not racing circuits, that dangerous stunts are not a demonstration of courage, and that no politician’s presence gives anyone permission to break the law.

Politicians must also recognise that public perception matters. Their actions can legitimise an activity, influence behaviour, and communicate priorities, whether or not that is their stated intention.

If they want to participate in motorcycle events, they should make their commitment to road safety visible and unmistakable.

They should also be quick to condemn dangerous behaviour regardless of whether or not the offenders are their supporters.

Ordinary Malaysians who drive home after work, parents taking their children to school, and pedestrians crossing busy roads have every right to expect that public safety will not be com­promised for a politician’s publicity.

That is a far more constructive approach than treating motorcycle convoys as political rallies in disguise.

Ultimately, the measure of a successful motorcycle event should not be the number of engines roaring down the road, the size of the crowd, or the number of views generated on social media. It should be whether the event promotes responsible riding, strengthens community ties, and leaves participants with a better understanding of their responsibilities.

There is nothing wrong with a politician wanting to connect with young people. Politicians are free to ride alongside the people they represent. But they must also be prepared to lead them in the right direction.

A convoy may generate publicity for a politician. But it takes a real leader to ensure that young Malaysians do not become casualties of a culture of recklessness – or victims of political expediency.

F1 fever must not cloud judgement


Speedy thrills: Eventual race winner Max Verstappen leading the field at the start of the race in Sepang on Oct 4. Will the thrill continue if Malaysia begins hosting F1 regularly again? — GLENN GUAN/The Star

THE excitement after the spectacular race at Sepang is understandable, but before Malaysia welcomes Formula 1 back on a permanent basis, we need to know whether the numbers add up.

After nine years away from the F1 calendar, Sepang once again became the centre of international motorsport attention when it hosted the Bahrain Grand Prix from Oct 2 to 4.

The roar of the engines, the excitement of the crowd and the sight of the world’s best drivers battling it out at Sepang brought back wonderful memories for Malaysians.

The race delivered a spectacle, drew an unprecedented crowd, reportedly over 200,000, and reminded us why this circuit remains one of the finest in the region.

There is little doubt that F1 has not lost its appeal among Malaysians. The atmosphere was electric, and the sight of fans filling the grandstands was encouraging for everyone who wants to see Sepang retake its place on the international sporting stage.

But before we allow ourselves to be swept away by the euphoria, we need to take a deep breath.

A successful race weekend does not automatically make a commercially viable annual event. That is the distinction we must make as discussions gather pace over the possibility of bringing F1 back to Malaysia permanently.

After witnessing the enthusiasm at Sepang, it is easy to conclude that Malaysia should seize the opportunity before it disappears.

The temptation is understandable but let’s not let our euphoria affect our thinking.

A major sporting event is not simply about the excitement it generates over three days. It is also about the financial commitments that come with it, year after year.

And F1 is an expensive business.

Sepang International Circuit chief executive officer Azhan Shafriman Hanif has estimated that Malaysia would need to spend at least RM300mil annually to secure a permanent place on the F1 calendar, including hosting rights and local preparations.

That is a substantial sum, particularly when the government must balance competing demands on public finances at a time it is cutting its spending.

Malaysia’s previous experience should also serve as a reminder.

The country hosted the Malay-sian Grand Prix from 1999 until 2017, when the race was dropped because the costs had become difficult to justify against the returns.

We have been down this road before. We should not assume that the economics have suddenly changed simply because the crowds returned for a weekend.

There is, of course, an important difference between the recent Bahrain Grand Prix and a regular Malaysian Grand Prix. Bahrain bore the hosting rights fees for the Oct 2-4 event, while Malaysia paid for local preparations, estimated at between RM10mil and RM16mil.

In other words, this was not a test of whether Malaysia can bear the full financial burden of hosting an annual F1 race.

It was an opportunity to demonstrate that Sepang could deliver a major international event at short notice, attract fans, and provide a venue capable of meeting the sport’s demanding requirements.

It was a valuable achievement. But it is not the same as proving that a permanent return would pay for itself.

The distinction matters because the headline figures can be misleading. Estimates that a race could generate more than RM1bil in economic activity are certainly encouraging. Hong Leong Investment Bank Research has put the potential economic output of the October event at between RM1.1bil and RM1.3bil.

However, economic output is not the same as revenue collected by the government, or profit earned by the circuit.

A hotel room booked by a foreign visitor, a meal purchased at a restaurant, and a taxi ride taken during race weekend all contribute to economic activity.

But the government does not receive the entire value of those transactions. Businesses incur their own costs, while some of the spending would have taken place in Malaysia even without the race.

We need to distinguish between gross economic impact, direct commercial revenue, tax receipts, and the actual financial return on public expenditure. These are not interchangeable figures.

Malaysian Investment Development Authority chairman and senior political adviser to the Prime Minister Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz rightly said that while Sepang remains a world-class circuit, a return cannot rely on prestige alone.

He asked for the government to carefully weigh the high hosting costs against the actual economic return on investment.

“Can we make F1 profitable enough for Malaysia?” he said, asking everyone to look at the broader economic returns.

Perhaps the burden of hosting an F1 race in Malaysia should not just be shouldered by the government but also by corporate and private entities who can support the event.

A proper cost-benefit analysis must therefore go beyond the number of spectators or the estimated value of tourism spending.

It must establish how much money Malaysia can realistically earn, how much it must spend, and who ultimately benefits.

Ticket sales, corporate hospitality, sponsorship, broadcasting, and commercial partnerships must all be examined.

So must hotel occupancy, airline bookings, visitor spending, and the number of tourists who come to Malaysia specifically because of the race.

Just as importantly, the analysis must identify how much of that spending represents genuinely additional economic activity rather than expenditure that would have occurred anyway.

There are also costs that may not be immediately obvious to the public.

These include circuit upgrades, safety requirements, transport arrangements, traffic management, security, staffing, logistics, and other operational expenses. We must also consider the cost of tying up public funds that could be used for other priorities.

A five-year hosting commitment at RM300mil annually would amount to RM1.5bil before allowing for any additional costs or changes in expenditure. That is not a small undertaking.

The government must be satisfied that the benefits justify such a commitment, rather than relying on optimistic projections or the assumption that a prestigious event will inevitably bring prosperity.

None of this means that Malaysia should abandon its ambition to host world-class sporting events. F1 offers international exposure, attracts a global audience, and can help promote Malaysia as a destination for tourism, business, and investment.

The event can also support local businesses, create employment, and inspire a new generation of motorsport enthusiasts. Sepang has an established reputation, and the recent race has shown that there remains considerable interest in the sport in Malaysia.

We must also be realistic about the extraordinary circumstances surrounding the Bahrain Grand Prix in Malaysia. The event was a one-off arrangement following the cancellation of the original race in Bahrain amid the conflict in the Middle East.

The novelty of seeing F1 back at Sepang after nine years, coupled with the unusual circumstances of the event helped generate considerable interest.

Can the same attendance figures be sustained every year?

Will international visitors continue to arrive in similar numbers once the novelty wears off?

We should also examine the practical lessons from the race. The large crowds demonstrated the circuit’s appeal, but reports of transport difficulties highlighted the need to improve the overall spectator experience.

A successful event must be judged not only by what happens on the track, but also by how efficiently people can get there, move around, and return home.

If Malaysia is serious about hosting F1 again, these issues must be addressed as part of a comprehensive business plan.

There is another consideration: competition.

Malaysia is not the only country interested in hosting F1. Other venues are competing for places on a crowded calendar, and any return of the race in Malaysia would depend on securing a slot as well as negotiating acceptable commercial terms.

We cannot assume that the opportunity will automatically be available, nor should we agree to unfavourable terms simply because we fear losing out to another country.

An independent assessment would help separate genuine returns from promotional claims. It would also provide a sound basis for comparing F1 with other major sporting and tourism events that Malaysia could host with the same resources.

But we should not confuse caution with a lack of ambition.

A country can be proud of its sporting achievements while remaining disciplined about public expenditure.

Ultimately, the question is not whether Malaysians want F1 back. The recent race has shown that many clearly do.

The question is whether Malaysia can afford to host it year after year, whether the returns justify the costs, and whether the benefits will reach the wider economy and the public.

Let us enjoy the spectacle, celebrate Sepang’s success and welcome the renewed international attention. But before we sign a long-term contract, let us make sure the numbers add up.

When it comes to spending public money, enthusiasm is welcome. Euphoria, however, must never replace sound judgement.

The haze knows no borders

THE rain over the past few days has brought some relief to Malaysians suffering from the haze caused by Indonesia’s worst wildfire crisis in more than a decade. But it is only a temporary reprieve.

The haze continues to affect Malaysia, Brunei and Singapore, with the situation particularly worrying in Central Kalimantan, where thick smoke, hazardous air pollution and widespread damage to forests and wildlife have been reported.

This is no longer just Indonesia’s environmental problem. The fires are affecting neighbouring countries, turning a domestic crisis into a regional concern.

Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi has said Malaysia is still awaiting a formal response from Indonesia to its offer of assistance.

Malaysia is prepared to deploy firefighting assets, including a Bombardier CL-415MP water-bombing aircraft, three helicopters, and 52 to 55 personnel from various agencies.

The offer was conveyed directly to Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto and Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka during Ahmad Zahid’s official visit to Jakarta.

Yet, there has been no formal response so far. Media reports suggest Malaysian officials remain positive, indicating that Indonesia may either feel it does not need outside assistance or believes it can manage the fires with its own resources.

Perhaps our offer, while well-intentioned, is simply not enough to address the enormous scale of the operation required.

Indonesia has reportedly mobilised substantial domestic resources, including thousands of ground personnel, military personnel and volunteers across Sumatra and Kalimantan. Helicopters have also been deployed to tackle hotspots.

It is fair to acknowledge that Indonesian authorities know the terrain better than anyone else. The absence of a formal response does not necessarily signal a breakdown in communication, as bilateral discussions are continuing.

Cross-border assistance in such situations is diplomatically sensitive.

Governments naturally prefer to manage emergencies within their own borders, particularly when these involve sovereign authority and the enforcement of domestic policies. Indonesia is no exception.

But while the fires continue to burn, its neighbours are left choking.

As of Oct 10, Central Kalimantan reportedly recorded 288 high-confidence fire hotspots, the highest among Indonesia’s six priority fire-control provinces. Fires around Palangka Raya have contributed to a deterioration in air quality.

The scale of the disaster is alarming. Reuters has reported that Indonesia is experiencing its most intense wildfires in 11 years.

Estimates from environmental organisations suggest that at least 800,000ha of land has caught fire across Indonesia in 2026, although the exact figure remains uncertain.

Wildlife is also under threat. Videos circulating on social media have shown various animal species, including orang utans, caught up in the fires and their aftermath.

Conservation teams have been rescuing animals suffering from burns and smoke exposure. In West Kalimantan alone, local conservation authorities have reportedly rescued 46 orang utans since August.

Indonesia may prefer to handle the crisis independently, but the situation remains troubling.

The country’s Forestry Ministry reportedly recorded 793 high-confidence hotspots nationwide on Oct 10, up from 437 the previous day. Central Kalimantan alone accounted for 288 of them. The ministry has said it is strengthening ground and aerial firefighting operations.

One of the biggest challenges is that many fires occur on peatland. Such fires can smoulder underground and reignite even after surface flames have been extinguished.

Hot, dry conditions associated with El Nino are making the situation harder to control.

For Malaysians, the consequences are all too familiar. Smoke can travel across the Malacca Strait, affecting air quality far from the fires themselves.

This is more than an inconvenience. Fine particulate matter in haze can aggravate asthma and other respiratory conditions, while increasing the risk of cardiovascular problems.

School closures, reduced outdoor activities and disruptions to daily life also carry economic costs. Businesses may suffer as people stay indoors, while tourists may reconsider visiting Malaysia if the haze persists. The resulting losses could be substantial.

What we are witnessing is no longer merely a seasonal forest-fire problem. It has become a serious regional environmental and public health crisis.

How long will it last? Reports suggest the crisis could continue into November if significant rainfall does not arrive.

Against this backdrop, a statement reportedly made by Syahganda Nainggolan, head of Indonesia’s government communications agency, is hardly helpful.

He was quoted as saying: “We don’t just send smoke. When there is no smoke, we send oxygen. The oxygen in Singapore and Malaysia also comes from our forests.”

Such remarks do little to reassure Indonesians’ neighbours, whose citizens are bearing the consequences of the fires.

Malaysia has offered assistance, and Indonesia has the right to determine how best to manage the emergency within its borders. But the haze does not respect national boundaries, and neither should the spirit of regional cooperation.

Asean has long recognised the need for countries to work together on transboundary haze pollution. This is precisely the kind of crisis that calls for that commitment to be put into practice.

The immediate priority must be to contain the fires, protect vulnerable communities and prevent further damage to forests and wildlife.

The skies may clear after the rain but unless the underlying problem is addressed, the haze will return.

For Malaysia and its neighbours, the question is not simply when the smoke will disappear. It is whether the region can work together to stop it from returning.

The ‘unknown’ Aziz Ishak

By Founding Fathers with Abu Talib Ahmad


Cabinet colleagues:Abdul Aziz having a conversation with the Tunku after the first Cabinet was formed.

ABDUL Aziz Ishak (1922-1999) was a controversial figure, whether as colonial civil servant, journalist or politician. He remains an enigma unlike his brother Yusof who was well known both as a journalist and the founder of Utusan Melayu and as the first President of Singapore after the separation with Malaysia in 1965.

Aziz was, in fact, the only member of the pre-war Kesatuan Melayu Muda (KMM) to have served in the 1955 and post-Merdeka Cabinets under Tunku Abdul Rahman. Be-tween 1955 and 1963, he was the Minister for Agriculture and Co-operatives. He resigned from the Cabinet due to irreconcilable differences with the Tunku and other Cabinet colleagues.

As Minister of Agriculture and Co-operatives, his efforts in rural development to improve the lives of padi farmers and fishermen were important although less known compared with similar efforts undertaken by the Rural Development Ministry.

Another equally important aspect of his political career was his detention between 1965 and 1966 under the Internal Security Act during the Indonesian confrontation.

He was accused of being a traitor and collaborating with Indonesian agents to form a government-in-exile, a charge that he denied.

In his book Special Guest: The Detention in Malaysia of an Ex-Cabinet Minister he describes in detail the irreconcilable differences with the Tunku and the events that led to his resignation, subsequent detention and release. The book was banned and only allowed restricted access in university libraries.

His earlier biographical account Katak Keluar dari Bawah Tempurong stopped at 1955 and his subsequent appointment as minister.

As a result, not much is known about Aziz Ishak and his role in the struggle for independence through the newspaper Utusan Melayu and in the political arena when he was head of Selangor Umno and Selangor Alliance in the mid-1950s when the political bargaining among the Alliance partners were struck.

It was through journalism that Aziz became widely known in Malaya. He wrote feature articles on Umno, on the state and federal administrations and occasionally editorials.

Aziz was a member of the KMM while he was a fisheries officer in Kuala Kurau. In 1946, he and Abdul Samad Ismail formed Gerakan Ang-katan Melayu Sedar (Geram), which was refused registration by the colonial authority. It was closely watched by the Special Branch.

Geram was critical of the Malayan Union; it was also critical of Umno because of the prominent role of the feudal aristocracy within the movement. Geram died a natural death when Aziz moved to Kuala Lumpur in 1948 as Utusan Melayu correspondent in the central region.

Aziz was the only journalist who was appointed a member of the Federal Legislative Council and he played an active role in its proceedings.

In September 1951, he urged the government to declare an end to the Emergency.

His political involvement was varied. Before 1942, Aziz was a member of the KMM and after 1945 sympathized with the PKMM. However in 1950 he joined Umno when it was still led by Datuk Onn Jaafar although his idea of full independence for Malaya at this time was neither acceptable to Onn nor the Tunku.

When the Independence of Malaya Party was formed in 1951 by Onn, Aziz became deputy chairman of the IMP’s Kuala Lumpur branch and contested the 1952 elections in Sentul but lost to the Alliance candidate.

In the same year, he left the IMP due to personal differences with Onn. Upon the Tunku’s encouragement, he rejoined Umno in April 1953.

Aziz then held important positions within Umno and the Alliance. In 1953, he was appointed to the Alliance Round Table Confe-rence that called for an early general election in Malaya.

In 1955, he was appointed head of Selangor Umno and chairman of the Selangor Alliance. He was very much involved in drafting the 1955 Alliance manifesto for the general election held that year; the manifesto covered issues such as Malay language, agriculture, economy, education, and finance.

In the elections, he stood on the Alliance ticket and won in Kuala Langat. He faced a Parti Negara candidate, a former schoolmate.

Despite official backing for Parti Negara, including from the colonial police force, the Alliance went on to win the first national elections, taking 51 of the 52 seats.

Earlier in September 1954, Aziz had campaigned actively with the Tunku in the Terengganu election which was won by the Alliance despite open support for Parti Negara by the British.

Aziz was appointed Minister of Agriculture and Co-operatives, a post he kept until 1963. Tun Abdul Razak took note of Aziz’s useful work among the rural folk, especially the setting up of co-operatives to eliminate the exploitation by middlemen.

The year 1955 saw a growing rift between Aziz with his Cabinet colleagues, notably the Tunku and Abdul Razak who was overall in charge of rural development.

Aziz’s blunt criticisms of ministers, such as the wearing of uniforms, did not endear him well with the Tunku.

He was also unhappy at the Alliance’s neglect of the 1955 manifesto due to the exuberant push for political independence.

In his memoirs, Aziz claimed that the 1955 Cabinet was beset with policy differences on various issues, including the replacement of expatriate British officers with Malayans or Malayanisation. Aziz was equally passionate on press freedom that he claimed had been eroded after 1955.

Aziz resigned from the Cabinet in 1963 after he was transferred to the Health Ministry. Soon after, he was expelled from Umno.

Perhaps there was no place for a socialist in a Cabinet that was pursuing capitalistic policies and firmly committed to upholding a free-market economy. He turned down all subsequent offers of state and federal awards. Yet one cannot deny his contributions in the struggle for independence.

Abu Talib Ahmad is Professor of History at Universiti Sains Malaysia and author of Malay-Muslims, Islam and the Rising Sun: 1941-4. The Founding Fathers series is coordinated by Dr Joseph Fernando of Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, and Research Editor Dr Lee Kam Hing (leekh@thestar.com.my).

Compassion has limits, so must immigration


Tipping point: A bus carrying Myanmar nationals being repatriated from Malaysia seen heading toward to navel base in Lumut. —AFP

IT’S a problem that has been festering for far too long. Now, Malaysia has reached a point where we can no longer avoid having an honest conversation about illegal immigrants and refugees living and working in the country.

We already have more than 200,000 UN-registered refugees and maybe tens of thousands more unregistered ones. The Government’s decision to begin repatriating Myanmar nationals who are willing and eligible to return home is therefore understandable and deserves to be supported.

It is part of the basic responsibility of any government to manage its borders, enforce immigration laws and determine who has the right to remain in the country.

The first group of 1,476 Myanmar nationals has been repatriated under a wider programme involving 5,000 people. The Government has stressed that that the process is voluntary and will be carried out in coordination with Myanmar.

That distinction matters.


Myanmar refugees getting on board Myanmar’s naval ship UMS Moattama for their journey home. — Bernama

Malaysia can be compassionate without abandoning immigration control. We can be humane without allowing our immigration policies to become meaningless.

For years, Malaysia has opened its doors to people fleeing war, persecution and poverty. We have done so even without being a signatory to the 1951 UN Refugee Convention.

The burden has nevertheless grown enormously as the birth rate of certain ethnic groups exploded. As of February this year, UNHCR figures showed some 215,600 refugees and asylum seekers registered in Malaysia, including about 193,800 from Myanmar.

Of these, around 126,000 are Rohingya, which has resulted in a great deal of unhappiness among many Malaysians regardless of race and religion.

The continuous presence of many foreign beggars at tourist spots especially around the prime Bukit Bintang area – and the inability of the authorities to stop them – has angered many Malaysians.

Without a doubt, behind every statistic is a complicated human story. Some came because they were escaping persecution. Others came because Malaysia offered jobs and economic opportunities.

Some have legal documents, some have refugee documentation, while others have fallen outside the system altogether.

This is precisely why we need a proper distinction between refugees, asylum seekers, legal foreign workers and undocumented migrants.

They cannot all be treated as one. The most difficult question, of course, concerns the Rohingya.

Social media is full of videos from netizens complaining about their lifestyles and inability to live with their Malaysian neighbours, especially in the Selayang area.

There is a growing rumbling among Malaysians that those who have been here for years should be returned home to Myanmar.

That is understandable from the perspective of a country struggling to manage a large foreign population. But saying that people should return is much easier than making it happen.

Myanmar has historically refused to recognise the Rohingya as citizens, and the conditions in Rakhine State remain deeply complicated.

The United Nations refugee agency has also warned that Myanmar remains unsafe and that any return must be voluntary, informed, safe and dignified.

If Malaysia wants the Rohingya to return, the question is not simply whether Kuala Lumpur wants them to go.

The question is whether Naypyidaw will genuinely accept them back, whether they will have a place to return to, whether they will be safe and whether there will be an international mechanism to monitor their return.

Without those conditions, forced repatriation would simply move a humanitarian problem from one country to another.

That does not mean Malaysia has to accept an open-ended refugee policy either. It means we need a realistic policy. Malaysia cannot become a permanent settlement for refugees from every regional conflict.

Our politicians have to be blamed. They were the ones who welcomed them, believing that playing the “Muslim brotherhood” narrative would win them votes.

In 2016, then-Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang attended a solidarity rally in Kuala Lumpur to express support for the Rohingya.

Decades later, it has backfired badly, and these politicians washed their hands of this fiasco.

At the same time, we cannot simply deport people to places where they may face genuine danger, or even death.

There is a middle ground: registration, screening, temporary protection, work rights where appropriate, strict enforcement against criminal activity, and eventually a credible pathway towards voluntary return when conditions permit.

The same principle should apply to foreign workers. Malaysia has benefited enormously from foreign labour. Our plantations, construction sites, factories, restaurants and other industries have relied on workers from countries such as Bangladesh, Pakistan, Indonesia, Nepal and Myanmar.

And we should acknowledge an important fact: many of these workers are here legally. The Immigration Department lists Bangladesh and Pakistan among approved source countries for foreign workers, subject to the relevant rules and quotas.

So, the issue should not be about nationality but neither should we dismiss the discomfort felt by ordinary Malaysians when they see large concentrations of foreign workers in their neighbourhoods, public spaces and businesses.

That discomfort needs to be understood, rather than immediately dismissed as xenophobia.

There is a difference between saying “we don’t want foreigners” and saying “we need better control of the number, location and conditions of foreign workers”.

Malaysia needs foreign workers in certain sectors. But such labour should supplement our workforce, not become an excuse for employers to avoid investing in productivity, automation and better wages for Malaysians.

The Government therefore has to manage both sides of this equation: the needs of business and the concerns of citizens.

Legal workers must be treated properly and paid according to the law. Employers must be responsible for their workers. Recruitment agents must be properly regulated.

And when employment ends, repatriation must actually take place rather than leaving people stranded or slipping into the undocumented economy.

Our own immigration rules already require employers to ensure that foreign workers are repatriated when their employment ends, through the proper channels.

The bigger issue is enforcement. For too long, Malaysia’s immigration debate has swung between two extremes – complete tolerance on one side and blanket hostility on the other but neither approach works. We need a grown-up immigration policy.

For the Rohingya, Malaysia will need diplomacy, not slogans. If Myanmar is eventually prepared to accept them and create genuine safe conditions, voluntary return should be part of the solution.

The problem now is that no one wants the Rohingya. Myanmar does not want them as they are not recognised as its citizens.

Western countries which may criticise the repatriation do not qualify to take a strong stand against us – they are welcome to take in the Rohingya to walk the talk.

But until then, Malaysia needs to manage the reality in front of us. We cannot permanently carry the refugee burden for the region and pretend that immigration controls do not matter.

Malaysia can remain a compassionate country while also being a country with borders, laws and limits.

That is not a contradiction. It is what a responsible country is supposed to be. However, patience among many Malaysians is running thin.