Author Archives: wcw

Anwar’s first 100 days as the first PM from a multi-racial party


IF there’s one point that has been unceremoniously downplayed in the volumes of news reports and articles about the Prime Minister’s 100 days in office, it’s that Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim is the country’s first PM from a multi-racial party.

His predecessors have been from Umno, which led the Alliance and then Barisan Nasional coalitions.

Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia, which is headed by Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, is mono-ethnic with Malay rights its predominant priority.

Anwar is the first PM to head a unity government which includes parties PKR has bumped heads with.

He has also taken on the job while Malaysia is facing huge financial constraints resulting from many factors, including the damaging 1MDB scandal.

As we take stock and assess his 100 days in office with his hits and misses, it’s important to remember how tightly bound his hands are.

The sound bites from his opponents suggest that the “traditional” race and religion card is being used yet again ahead of the elections in six states.

These politicians are compelled to believe that this is the most effective weapon – at least for Malay voters outside Selangor, Kuala Lumpur and the major cities.

Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, who quit Pejuang to join Putra, is still claiming the Malays are left behind although he had the chance to change that in his 22 years as PM.

He has insisted that the Malays have lost their dominance in politics in Malaysia, on top of their lack of economic control.

It’s quite amazing that the nonagenarian, who still doesn’t understand why he lost his deposit as a candidate in the GE15, has now claimed that the government may change electoral boundaries to reduce Malay constituencies.

The reality is that the Malays in Peninsular Malaysia will continue to dictate the political bearing of the country as they form the majority in 57% or 128 of the 222 parliamentary seats.

The Chinese have only 37 majority seats and the community’s population continues to shrink.

Sarawak has 31 and Sabah 25 seats with the breakdown of 10 Malay/Melanau, 10 Iban, six Chinese, two Orang Ulu and three Bidayuh, while in Sabah, the Chinese have three, non-Muslim nine and Muslims have 13 majority seats.

In 2021, it was reported that the number of Malays in Penang was increasing and has already outnumbered the Chinese by 0.7% and for sure, it will get higher.

We’d like to know if Dr Mahathir is making those assumptions to drum up the fear factor.

He’s not alone though. PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang is fond of that same MO.

The Marang MP has twice said that the unity government could collapse any time soon, but that prediction sounds baseless, so I don’t think many Malaysians will buy it.

His party has governed Kelantan for three decades and it’s incredulous how PAS can tell non-Muslims that it’s a model state when it’s one of the poorest.

It can’t even provide clean water, and one wonders how it can uplift the economic status of the Malay majority there.

Old guard politicians like Tan Sri Annuar Musa and Datuk Seri Shahidan Kassim have also used the same race and religion narrative, angling to have the optics of being champions for the Malays and Islam.

So, let’s give credit where it’s due. Race and religion haven’t been Anwar’s narrative, and instead, he has reminded Malays that corruption is the main threat.

His standing among the Malays remains a sensitive point as survey readings show contrasting results.

The issue remains a hot topic with Anwar insisting that his party’s research had placed Malay support for Pakatan Harapan at 31%. Last year, Bridget Welsh claimed Pakatan only polled 11% in GE15 and she was immediately challenged.

Merdeka Centre has found that the PM’s approval rating in a survey, held from Dec 26 to Jan 15, stands at 68% involving 1,209 voters across all ethnic groups.

All these surveys provide a barometer of the people’s opinions, although we may question the methodology and accuracy. That said, Malaysians are generally well-informed on issues.

The cost of living, job security and education were top concerns before GE15, and these haven’t changed within 100 days, so we don’t need desk-bound academicians to tell us that.

Ahead of the state elections, the unity government will depend on Umno to deliver the Malay votes, but it wasn’t able to do so in GE15.

Umno president Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi has said that there were no factions in the party, but the consensus knows he was merely being politically correct.

He will have a small window of opportunity to bring the party together, following the party polls and a series of sackings and suspensions, to campaign in the polls.

It’s also not helpful for non-Malay leaders in the government to be talking about recognition for the Unified Examination Certificate (UEC) for Chinese independent schools and reforms in the civil service.

The timing isn’t right and there are no quick fixes, but more importantly, they don’t need the PM’s immediate attention.

His hands are tied and given the short 100 days, I think Anwar has done a decent job. Let’s not expect miracles.

The 100 days is an indicator to evaluate a leader’s performance, but the US-based Brookings Institute has also described it as “somewhat arbitrary and an artificial milestone” and as quoted by David Alexrod, a top aide during President Obama’s time, it is as an occasion of “having lots of attention but no significance.”

Its origin dates to President Hoover’s reign during the 1930s, whose 100 days were marked with bold and new actions.

Malaysia needs a fresh story for the world beyond race and religion and corruption.

We have a PM with extensive global goodwill. Let’s use it to the fullest.

Evil from across the sea

IT’S been 10 years since a group of Sulu gunmen loyal to the self-proclaimed Sultan of Sulu, Jamalul Kiram III, intruded into Lahad Datu in Sabah on Feb 9, 2013.

There were two fronts – one group landed in Lahad Datu’s coastal Kampung Tandao and another at Kampung Simunul in Semporna town.

As the fighting broke out between our security forces and these attackers, which led to casualties on both sides, I headed for Simunul.

I arrived at the sprawling village, with houses on stilts on the outskirts of Semporna, just a couple of days after six policemen were gruesomely killed.

The police immediately carried out a mop-up operation which saw seven of these Filipinos killed and even as I landed, the near deserted village remained a security risk.

Ten years later, I am still asking myself what made me decide to go to Kampung Siminul, the largest of the squatter colonies scattered along the Sabah coastline.

It remains a maze of rickety walkways and when I walked in then, it hit me immediately: why our brave policemen got lost inside and found themselves trapped by seven heavily- armed attackers.

I took a one-and-a-half-hour journey by road from Lahad Datu to Semporna, a distance of about 140km.

At Kampung Simunul, most of its thousands of settlers, mainly Suluk, had disappeared, with their homes locked up and belongings removed to safer places.

But several villagers had steadfastly remained, saying they did not want to camp out in a school hall or community centre.

My colleague from the Kota Kinabalu bureau, Muguntan Vanar, had made calls to local contacts to guide us into the village. I told myself we were taking a huge risk, but it was for a scoop. My dear wife, who is adventurous by nature, was crazy enough to follow me in.

I remember getting a call from a senior police officer demanding to know what we were doing there without informing the police!

It was a frightening time. No one knew the actual size of this village. Some said there were between 300 and 500 houses in there, while others claim that the number was closer to 1,000.

Today, not much has changed, I am told.

This is home to the Suluks, who fled the southern Philippines in the 1970s during the civil war in Mindanao. They had originally settled in refugee enclaves set up by the UNHCR, the United Nations refugee agency, but some had since become Malaysian citizens, while a large number probably had no documents with them.

The water village has a reputation for harbouring bad hats, and the locals avoid entering the area.

It is difficult to navigate the maze of wooden boardwalks, and in the incident on March 5, 2013, that was how our policemen were ambushed as they lost their way in this place.

When I walked into Lorong 4 with my colleagues, we felt like we were being watched by figures in the shadows. An elderly man approached us and asked what we were doing there. He seemed a little friendlier when we told him we were from the media.

“Do you want to see the bullet holes and the spots where the three gunmen were killed?” he offered, as a few others suddenly appeared to join us.

I had to watch my step, as one could easily fall into the water as the boardwalk had many gaping holes.

“The water below was filled with all sorts of rubbish, and a horrible stench emanated from it. I could not help wondering how these people live in such filthy conditions,’’ I wrote in my article in 2013.

We had to take a detour to reach Lorong 5, where the fight took place, because village headman Ramli Sara-man had ordered the boardwalk from Lorong 4 to be broken down as a symbolic gesture to show the “bad men” were from Lorong 5.

They showed us a home that was riddled with bullet holes and pointed out the spots where three of the intruders were killed, and their bodies left untouched for three days.

One was on a boat, one on the walkway and another on the verandah of a home. The splattered blood, close to where the bodies were found, was still very visible when we arrived.

The bodies, which included that of a Filipino councillor of Pulau Sitangkai in the southern Philippines, were eventually removed for burial by the religious authorities.

But the superstitious villagers excused themselves when we walked towards the abandoned home where a policeman was beheaded, saying they did not want to go into that “house of evil”.

We saw what appeared to be the remains of human tissue – it looked like parts of a human brain – by the wooden entrance.

Today, as I read news reports of the heirs of the so-called Sulu Sultanate taking legal action to seize our national assets, I am infuriated.

Not many Malaysians are aware that two of our men in blue were beheaded while another had his eyes gouged out. That was how cruel these intruders were.

I remember walking inside the house even as I thought of the horrible and cruel acts that had been carried out by these heartless militants.

I felt angry and sad at the same time, wondering how human beings could carry out such brutal acts.

The television set had clear traces of blood, which horrified me. The walls of the home were adorned with family photographs, like most ordinary homes, except that something extraordinarily evil had taken place right there.

None of us wanted to stay longer than necessary in that place. As we walked out of the village, we came across a young boy who had come back to collect some of his belongings, saying the family was not ready to move back in.

The men we met said they feared more gunmen may come back and, more so, they feared repercussions from our security men. They said they were just ordinary people trying to eke out a living in peaceful Malaysia, but these militants had given the Suluks a bad name.

Ironically, the word “Semporna” is said to mean “a place of rest” or “a journey completed”, but it wasn’t so.

Many Malaysians have long questioned the influx of these foreigners into Malaysia, especially in Sabah, and if we do not take a stronger, even harsher, stand against such easy entry into our country, we only have ourselves to blame when security threats arise.

Semporna is the gateway to Sipadan, one of the world’s most beautiful diving spots, but it should never be a gateway for illegal immigrants.

It remains a huge dump site, an embarrassing eyesore to tourists, with the local council continuing to struggle with the bad practices of the people living there.

It is 10 years later, and we need to ask ourselves – have we put in enough resources, manpower and assets for our security to keep our long coastal line safe? Safe from these Sulu intruders whose families are hanging on to dreams of reclaiming what they think are their ancestral rights.

If you’re fond of sand dunes, souks and mountains, head to Morocco


Sunset at Djemaa-el-Fna square in Marrakesh. — Five Travel

During a dinner dialogue with some diplomats many years ago, I asked these well-travelled people to name their favourite cities and countries.

Half of them named Morocco, with Marrakesh as their most preferred city.

That was almost three decades ago when I was covering the foreign ministry as a reporter.

Having travelled to more than 60 countries for work and holidays, I finally made it to Morocco. I criss-crossed this country for eight days, with my sojourn extending beyond Marrakesh and Casablanca.

The diplomats were right. I don’t know why it took me so long to visit this north African nation, which overlooks the Mediterranean Sea to the north and the Atlantic Ocean to the west.

Perhaps I didn’t take the views of those diplomats seriously, but I never forgot their preference. It’s never too late, as the adage goes.

Morocco isn’t just about deserts and camels, as most of us would imagine of Arab nations. From deserts to snow-capped mountains to sea sides, Morocco is truly a land of contrast.

And the breadth of its culture stretches from belly dancing in Marrakesh to deeply religious Berber folk in rural villages, to women who dress up and look like fashion models in Rabat, the capital of Morocco.

I chose February for the journey since it’s viewed as a low season. The peak period is the yearend, but by February, the holidays are over. And the winter period would also be at its tail end.

Apart from avoiding the crowd, it was simply so that I could get a reasonably priced air ticket and accommodation.

After having worked out my budget, I decided that signing up for a group tour was the most cost-effective way to go. Never mind if it meant getting up at 6.30am every day and spending hours on the bus to reach the next city.

I have long believed in being a digital nomad, so I carried my laptop and used a local SIM card for my mobile.

My first stop, after arriving in Casablanca, was Marrakesh. It was exactly everything that I had expected and imagined.


The writer checking out some fossils in Ouarzazate, Morocco. — Photos: FLORENCE TEH

Sitting in a café and sipping my mint tea, I soaked in the atmosphere of the sprawling Jemaa el-Fna square with its snake charmers, fortune tellers, story tellers, acrobats and men attached to macaques chained by the neck.

My advice – ignore these people who exploit animals for money. Exotic as all these may seem, I don’t think they deserve 20 dirhams (RM10) for a photo opportunity.

The rule here is, never look interested and don’t even start a conversation because these snake or monkey men can be pushy.

But all these aside, the medina, or the meeting place of an old-walled part of North Africa, is indeed a sight and experience.

It’s a cliché I tell young reporters to avoid, but I’m going to use it here. It was indeed like a setting from an Indiana Jones movie, Raiders Of The Lost Ark, to be precise.

I continued my trip to another medina in Fez, which is regarded as the largest living medieval town in the Arab world.

The guide kept reminding the undisciplined Malaysians that if we didn’t follow him closely, we could be lost in the labyrinth of 9,000 alleyways and narrow streets, which dates to the ninth century.

These souks are pleasantly chaotic, with the delightful scents of spices and perfume lingering in the air.


Inside Rick’s Cafe in Casablanca.

The alleys are packed, and I held on dearly to my phone and wallet. As we jostled for space, we sometimes had to make way for the unexpected passing of mules, which are still being used as a form of transportation.

Many of the locals, dressed up in their hooded jaballah (robes), worked as artisans and craftsmen.

They appeared as if they were locked in another time – a lost time. I saw a comb maker meticulously creating his product from sheep and cow horns.

These are more than pieces of art, but I wondered if he would earn enough money to feed his family.

Nestled in the medina is the world’s oldest university, the al-Qarawiyyin, which was founded by Tunisian woman Fatima al-Fihri in 859 and officially recognised by Unesco.

I must confess what an ignorant fool I’ve been thinking that the old universities must be in Europe or China, not knowing the existence of this famous institution.

This turned out to be one learning expedition. I headed to the desert town of Ouarzazate and found out that the deserts – where I did the customary touristic camel ride – used to be an ocean.

Fossils of trilobites, ammonites and other prehistoric life are plentiful here, proving that the deserts were, indeed, once ocean floors. These 250-million-year-old relics are found in abundance and on sale in government certified shops, if you seek authenticity.

We stopped at Chefchaouen, renowned for its iconic, blue-coloured stairs, buildings, sidewalks and structures. These are certainly one of the most photographed places on Earth.

Framed against the backdrop of the stunning Rif Mountains, I had mistakenly believed the blue stairs were in Marrakesh.

In any case, how does one remember the name of a town like Chefchaouen, let alone pronounce it correctly?

The final stop was Casablanca, a city which evokes nostalgia and romance, ably aided by the 1942 romantic thriller of the same name starring Humphrey Bogart and Ingrid Bergman.

A poster of that movie has been on my library wall for decades. My wife and I had only one night in Casablanca, but we were told by the tour guide that Rick’s Café – the recreation of the famous restaurant from the film – was fully booked.

But that wasn’t going to stop us from having a drink, at least, at this gin-joint, dreaming of a black pianist playing As Times Goes By in the background. It wasn’t smoke filled, like in the movie, and there was only Arabic folk music playing. I was told that they often have jazz sessions, too.

A resourceful phone call to a Moroccan friend, Imane Sakhi of Five Travel agency, who seems to be able to connect anyone to everything, got us two seats at the bar – so I had my local brew, the Casablanca.

One lasting impression of the trip was the visit to the beautiful ancient fortress village of Ait-Ben-Haddou, located 30km from Ouarzazate.

This kasbah, the sprawling settlement of the Berbers, sits on the foot of a cliff, and it will immediately “evoke in the visitor a sense of having travelled back,” as one writer aptly described the country’s most famous kasbah.

The red earthen fort has been the location of numerous movies including The Mummy, The Gladiator, The Jewel Of The Nile, The Prince Of Persia and more recently, Game Of Thrones.

This ancient oasis town used to be an old caravan route running between the Sahara and Marrakesh.

But today, it’s one of the star attractions for tourists from around the town, who are guaranteed a spellbinding experience.

I will certainly return to Morocco again, because I’ve fallen in love with this country, where its people have no hangups and are so easy going.

Each morning I was greeted with the customary assalamualaikum, which means peace be upon you, and I was expected to reply walaikumsalam, which means peace also be upon you.

I didn’t have the heart to tell my guide that as a non-Muslim living in Malaysia, I’m not obliged to use that greeting.

They are such lovely people with broad cosmopolitan views and yet, retain their religious and cultural identities and beliefs.

In my own take of the famous line from Casablanca where Ingrid Bergman tells the pianist, “Play it again, Sam,” I’ll simply say, “I’ll be back.”


Dying art: A man making combs from lamb and cow horns at Fez medina. — Photos: FLORENCE TEH


All kinds of bread for sale in Chefchaouen, Morocco.


Folks at the Fez medina are still selling chickens the old-fashioned way.


You can buy many varieties of dates at Fez.


Ait Benhaddou in Ouarzazate is a Unesco Heritage Site. — Five Travel


Fanciful shoes on sale at Chefchaouen, Morocco.


Night view of the Djemaa-el-Fna square in Marrakesh. — Five Travel


One of the 9,000 alleys of Fez Medina.


A tannery at Fez, where some of the best leather goods can be found.


The writer at the entrance of the Chefchaouen market square.

Politicians mustn’t refuse to listen to bad news or rely on sycophants

Politicians, like most corporate leaders, rely heavily on their staff, colleagues, and other sources of information.

With their tight schedules, especially those holding Cabinet posts, they need to be surrounded by good people.

The last people they should listen to are sycophants who only tell them things they want to hear.

As for the media, they are used to being shot at despite the idiom saying, don’t shoot the messenger.

On Tuesday (Feb 28), Communications and Digital Minister Fahmi Fadzil lost his cool over the findings of a survey on the Unity Government’s 100 days in office that was conducted by a research firm.

The survey was carried out by O2 Research company and jointly published by Astro Awani, The Star, Sinar Harian, Sin Chew Daily and the Malaysia Nanban – media houses which work closely together.

The survey, among other things, found that the respondents wanted the Prime Minister to focus on the cost of living (80%), education (56%), job opportunities (53%), health (52%) and political stability (49%).

The five biggest concerns for households were inability to afford needs (80%), financial savings (61%), overburdened to pay debts/loans (56%), low wage rates (53%) and education funding for self/children/family (52%).

Here’s the unhappy news – 50% felt that the economic growth was not handled well with another 52% having the same negative sentiment on food supply.

In terms of ethnicity response, the unfavourable views, on the various broad topics including the state of the country and economic outlook, the Malays from the peninsula were the most critical.

The online survey polled 35,077 people nationwide from Feb 6 to Feb 16, 2023, and was carried out before the Budget.

But 54% of the respondents accepted the Unity Government, 47% backed Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim as the PM.

Rather than take an emotional and defensive response to the survey, it is better that the government use this as a finding to gauge its level of support and to identify its strengths and weaknesses.

It serves as an information guide on how Malaysians, especially the predominant Malay voters, feel about the first 100 days of the Unity Government in power.

We must also accept that no government in the world can deliver a miracle, especially with the current economic climate, within three months.

This is the worst time to be a PM as expectations can sometimes be unrealistic but the ordinary people are struggling with soaring bills.

Essential food items have shot up, but wages haven’t, and it is also not fair for employers to simply increase wages when they are also grappling with the cost of production. The ringgit has weakened when much of the raw materials must be paid for in dollars.

Anwar and the government, in all fairness, are doing their best to meet the economic challenges, as can be seen in the recent Budget where the attention was focused mostly on the B40 and M40 groups.

The unhappiness of the respondents is a mere expression of how Malaysians feel about the economy and if Malays make up the majority, it is simply because they form the bulk of the population.

It need not necessarily be a perception towards the popularity of the government or Pakatan Harapan because generally most Malaysians do not want to see a change of government or PM.

You don’t even need a survey for that. So, the acceptance of Anwar is there.

The 02 survey actually showed that of these respondents, 37% voted PH/Muda, 29% Perikatan Nasional and 21% Barisan Nasional, Gabungan Parti Sarawak (5.5%) and Warisan (1.4%).

As with any survey, there will always be criticisms, including its methodology especially sampling size, locations, and margin of error.

Surveys have gone wrong including even the famous CNN poll which wrongly predicted Donald Trump would lose in the 2016 United States presidential elections.

Based on anecdotes, even our Special Branch and military have made wrong predictions of the outcome, based on its own surveys, of past general elections, it seems.

It is perfectly acceptable for Fahmi or other researchers/academicians or rival media groups to question the accuracy of the survey by O2.

It is good for Fahmi to find out more from the media outlets and 02 about the survey so he can understand better.

The media would also like to hear the shortcomings of the said survey, if any, so we can improve ourselves better.

It will also be good for him to understand the operations of the media better as there is no requirement to wait until the 100 days proper before publishing the findings.

Likewise, the media no longer waits until Dec 31 before publishing their yearly wrap-up.

There is absolutely no need for Fahmi to raise doubts on the media outlets that published the survey.

To say that these outlets “do some promotion or deceive the people’’ and the reports were ‘’insincere and dishonest’’ are statements which have libellous implications.

Fahmi is also reportedly upset that the sample had too many men, saying it had 81% men when it should be more than 31% to 41%.

Speaking personally for myself, I agree that it could be better balanced in terms of gender.

But that does not mean that the participating media outlets have any agenda, which seems to be the normal obsession of most politicians. Anything that does not serve their interest would be deemed as a motive.

Fahmi is a really nice and decent bloke. It’s refreshing to have a minister like him who prefers informality. Most of us in the mainstream media have much respect for him.

He is accessible and friendly, so we expect much better from him.

He is no longer in the Opposition and he has to remind himself of that. It is much easier to criticise than to be criticised, and as a Minister, he has to accept the good and bad news.

Ironically, it was the same research house – O2 – which reported on May 20, 2022, that PH will fare well in the general election, in a survey involving 1,601 people.

Interestingly, no one from PH complained that the survey was inaccurate, dishonest or out to deceive or a promotion agenda.

It will be at the government’s peril if it merely wishes to listen to the findings of their friendly academicians, especially those from their party think-tanks.

Unfinished Business with Frances Yip

 

Poser parade


Cosplay convention? : The Himpit parade participants, dressed in medieval militant garb with a green theme, also carried fake swords, spears, bows and arrows. – Facebook

NO one would bat an eyelid if someone walked around Kuala Lumpur’s busy Bukit Bintang area dressed up as an anime or superhero character.

Everyone would just assume that the person was heading for a cosplay event. But it’s something else when PAS members arm themselves with fake weapons in rural Setiu, Terengganu.

PAS has never been known to endorse such performance art, but since last week, following the controversial parade comprising PAS members brandishing fake swords, spears, bows and arrows, cosplay has become the buzzword of party leaders.

The march was reportedly part of a two-day PAS Youth gathering dubbed “Himpunan Pemuda Islam Terengganu” (Himpit).

There was also a pickup truck with a huge fake sword in its cargo bed while some participants, dressed in medieval militant garb with a green theme, were seen standing in the same crammed space.

The gathering has caused concern because the Islamist party has a blemished past. Its leadership may not endorse violence or militancy of any kind, but given the party’s track record, questions have obviously been raised.

The defenders of the parade should not blame non-Muslims for their conjecture because criticism came from the Malays as well. So there’s no need to play the race-religion card. It’s pathetic to resort to such a tactic.

PAS, predictably, fended off criticisms against the party with the routine line of “anti-Islam and Islamophobia”, but the truth is that PAS is just another political party led by ordinary human beings with political expediency and ambitions.

It may be still uncomfortable to talk about the Memali incident after nearly 40 years, but in that 1985 tragedy, police had to lay siege to a village in Baling, Kedah, which was occupied by Ibrahim Mahmud aka Ibrahim Libya.

The incident resulted in the deaths of 14 villagers including Ibrahim, an active PAS member, and four policemen. Ibrahim, who had studied Islam in Tripoli, Libya, contested twice as a PAS candidate in two general elections but lost narrowly to Barisan Nasional.

The villagers were armed with machetes, sharpened bamboo rods and other weapons.

It’s a sad part of the nation’s history with a deadly ending, when clashes between Umno and PAS peaked with Umno members declared infidels (apostates) and those who died as al-shahid (martyrs) by PAS.

PAS members have also been involved in terrorist activities. That is a fact, although the party has issued immediate statements each time to distance itself from these individual acts, including resorting to expulsions from the party.

In 2014, PAS activist Mohd Lofti Ariffin aka Abu Afghan, 46, was killed in an assault by Syrian government forces. He claimed he was fighting for the Ajnad-al-Sham faction, a breakaway from the Islamic State (IS) group.

Another Malaysian fighter, Mohammad Fadhlan Shahidi, was also killed in the incident.

Mohd Lofti, a former Kedah PAS information chief, had attracted a large following on social media with regular posts of pictures, videos, and calls for jihad from the Syrian frontline.

The veteran jihadist had also fought in Afghanistan against the Russians and was detained under the Internal Security Act (ISA) upon returning to Malaysia.

But what was disturbing following his death in Syria was the eulogising on social media by several PAS personalities, underlining sympathy for the militants’ cause that created a security headache for the Malaysian government.

One senior PAS leader praised Lotfi as a “martyr” in a Facebook post and reportedly recounted a religious anecdote from what he said was Lotfi’s final visit to Malaysia in 2013 when he helped with PAS flood-relief efforts.

But the party had also said Lofti’s membership had been terminated earlier and that it disavowed militant actions.

In 2014, the party sacked three party members who were among five people wanted by police for involvement in militant activities. They were Universiti Malaya (UM) lecturer Dr Mahmud Ahmad @ Abu Handzalah, Selayang Municipal Council worker Muhammad Joraimee Awang Raimee and UM stationary shop owner Mohd Najib Husen.

They were accused of serving the IS movement in Iraq, according to police.

Then PAS secretary-general Datuk Mustafa Ali announced their immediate expulsions following the police disclosure, saying they were mere ordinary members.

In Afghanistan, PAS branch committee member Zainon Ismail aka CN Al Afghani, also joined the fight and even published a 112-page book with pictures of himself and other Malaysians championing the same cause.

Even the late Kelantan mentri besar’s son, Nik Adli Nik Abdul Aziz, was detained under the ISA for involvement in the radical Kumpulan Mujahidin Malaysia (KMM) movement in 2001.

There are many others. You only need to do a search online to find out more. The party may have officially condemned these radicals by sacking them, but it’s fair to suggest that it continues to attract members with the plan of setting up an Islamic state in Malaysia as the ultimate goal.

Our security forces must be commended for their vigilance and network of intelligence in keeping Malaysia safe, sound and sane.

Don’t count on our politicians, who just want to strike deals without bothering about the long-term consequences.

So, there are good reasons why Malaysians should worry when PAS members put up an act with fake swords, spears, and other weapons. It may be cosplay to PAS, but not to others.

Passé protocols


Setting a casual tone: A tie-less Anwar (right) and Defence Minister Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan on their way to the first session of the 15th Parliament on Dec 20. — AZLINA ABDULLAH/The Star

MINISTER Hannah Yeoh did something unique recently by turning up ahead of an event’s scheduled start and getting straight to the point.

Upon entering the packed venue of the townhall talk with sports industry players, she found the first three rows reserved for the ministry’s heads of departments.

The Youth and Sports Minister then did the unexpected by inviting participants who had been forced to stand at the back to move forward to fill the front rows.

The civil servants vacated their seats and sat behind Yeoh, who then went on to moderate the session herself.

The stakeholders included gym owners, tournament organisers, coaches, and sports science and medicine practitioners.

No time was wasted in the no-frills meeting. The routine fanfare associated with functions to welcome invited VIPs was unceremoniously discarded.

While Yeoh preferred to play down her actions, a video of what happened is making its rounds on social media.

When she was appointed to the job, she also gave a standing order that officials need not wait as a welcoming committee to greet her at functions.

These officials certainly have bigger fish to fry than join politicians in the entourages that seem to follow them everywhere they go.

There may be a necessity for a few officials to accompany a minister to answer questions or record issues requiring follow-up action, but the perception, arguably, is that these politicians crave a sense of self-importance and authority.

To put it bluntly, it merely inflates their egos and encourages delusions of grandeur.

We hope Yeoh’s practice will continue and won’t just be a case of a new broom sweeping clean.

Haven’t we seen newly elected YBs post pictures of themselves travelling in economy class but then slowly getting used to being in business class, even for a short trip?

When Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim decided to do away with the tie, he sent a powerful message of being someone who wants to get down to business and be hands on.

Here was someone who had no time for ornamental fripperies, as one report put it.

The more conventional gentlemen would say wearing a suit without a tie seems incomplete – even naked.

But I’m glad that the less formal and dress-down trend has taken off. We are emulating what the Singapore Parliament did long ago, allowing their male ministers and MPs to choose to wear a shirt without a jacket.

The tie-less approach has also been adopted at the Australian House of Representatives and Senate.

But more importantly, we need to create a new culture. Can the PM send a message down that there’s no need for a bunga mangga, kompang, silat and lion dance welcome unless there’s a festive element involved?

Not only is time wasted but funds are unnecessarily used, too, even if they are relatively paltry sums.

Malaysians should also dispense with the obligatory salutations by a speaker addressing titles and naming the important guests present. By the time the names of every Tan Sri, Puan Sri, Datuk Seri, Datin Seri, Datuk-Datuk and Datin-Datin are addressed, at least five to 10 minutes have gone by.

It also makes the untitled guests feel less important, which should never be the case.

Worse, it reaffirms the perception that Malaysia is probably the country with the greatest number of titled people. Police reports have been made of impostors who brazenly crow about their titles when they, in fact, have none.

Many African countries have stopped such long salutations and their speakers simply start their speeches or remarks with the standard, “Ladies and gentlemen, all the rules of decorum have been observed” or “Honourable delegates, distinguished ladies and gentlemen”.

Of course, protocols need to be observed and upheld when royalty is invited to grace events.

Finally, we should do away with having to hand VIPs gifts, which is a very Malaysian way of thanking guests. However, there’s a common fate that befalls these cenderamata – they all end up gathering dust in some corner of the ministry’s offices.

The better ones, of course, end up in the minister’s office and, sometimes, the waiting room, but we can only guess where the unwanted ones go.

Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, as the PM of the Pakatan Harapan government after the 14th General Election in 2018, suggested that fruits, flowers and food be given instead.

But when a minister has at least four to five functions a day, what is the YB going to do with all these items with a limited shelf-life?

No wonder his idea didn’t take off, it was simply impractical.

These entrenched exercises in protocol will not disappear overnight, but gradual changes need to be made now.

Voice of reason


Showing the way: Sultan Ibrahim (centre, in red) arriving at the state-level Thaipusam celebration at a temple in Skudai on Feb 5, along with other Johor state officials. — THOMAS YONG/The Star

IT makes perfect religious sense. There’s absolutely nothing contentious about the Johor religious affairs committee announcing a fatwa (religious decree) advising Muslims against participating in rituals of other faiths.

Other beliefs would echo that sentiment too. As a Christian, I certainly wouldn’t take part in a Thaipusam ritual or hold joss sticks when I attend a Taoist funeral.

When my Muslim friends pray, I would do the same in my own way. It’s done differently, of course, but the objective is the same in all prayers, which is always to ask for the best.

It is Taoist tradition to attend the Qingming festival, or tomb sweeping day, to honour the departed, especially family members, and I do so but refrain from engaging in the rituals.

We live in a multi-religious and multiracial country, so for most of us it would be disrespectful to stay away. Nothing can stop me from attending these important events, even if they could be religious in nature, and I think most of us are unwavering in our own faiths.

But it was the lack of clarity that led to some minor confusion. Johor Ruler Sultan Ibrahim Ibni Almarhum Sultan Iskandar had to issue a statement to clarify the matter.

It was a case of Johor exco member Mohd Fared Mohd Khalid not clearly answering questions posed by reporters at a press conference, even though the statement was precise. It became more confusing when State Mufti Yahya Ahmad reportedly said Muslims in Johor were barred from “observing” Thaipusam processions under the fatwa.

Observing and participating are two different things entirely. It was ambiguous because observing could also be interpreted as participating.

If it meant keeping away, then it would certainly be impractical because there would be Muslim policemen and Rela officers involved in crowd control.

For that matter, even Muslim reporters and photographers would be assigned to cover the event. Also, there would be Muslim onlookers when the processions pass through the streets, for example.

But Yahya could have been misquoted in the article, or perhaps something was lost in translation, or this was simply down to poor writing by the news portal.

His Majesty must be commended for not shying away from attending a luncheon hosted by the Indian community in conjunction with the Thaipusam celebrations at a temple in Skudai, Johor Baru.

He was joined by Johor Mentri Besar Datuk Onn Hafiz Ghazi; state Tourism, Environment, Culture and Heritage Committee chairman Raven Kumar; and state Health and Unity Committee chairman Ling Tian Soon.

Sultan Ibrahim later reaffirmed the “Bangsa Johor” concept, saying the racial and religious diversity of Johor will always be recognised and respected.

His Majesty rightly said the fatwa issued by the Johor Islamic Reli-gious Council was in no way in conflict with interfaith values of tolerance, unity and understanding as espoused under the “Bangsa Johor” concept.

“The fatwa only prohibits Muslims from taking part in other religious rituals. It is a guideline for them. They can still attend festive events of other faiths.

“Other religions must also respect Muslims’ sensitivities. It is a two-way street. We must be sensitive to each other’s religious obligations to get along,” His Majesty said.

It’s important for our leaders to attend events involving other faiths, even if it’s something symbolic like a simple lunch or tea during Christmas, or just to break fast with Muslims during Ramadan.

If Malaysians have no problem embracing public holidays to celebrate the festivals of other faiths, then we should be rejoicing the occasions together as Malaysians.

If these national leaders are unable to attend, then they should at least have the decency to send a senior representative.

But there shouldn’t be lame excuses. These politicians seem to be quite happy to show up at places of worship to canvas for votes during elections but suddenly can’t make an appearance when the polls are over.

They can give an excuse once, but let’s see if similar justifications are concocted in the following years.

The Council of Churches Malaysia (CCM) must be commended for lauding the guidelines provided by the Johor authorities.

CCM general secretary Rev Jonathan Jesudas said non-Muslims should appreciate the limits that Muslims are subject to under syariah laws when inviting Muslim colleagues or friends to their festivities or celebrations.

“The clarity provided by the Johor Islamic religious affairs committee is welcome and will definitely promote greater harmony and interaction among the various religious communities in Malaysia,” he said.

Rev Jonathan also noted how Malaysians from various religious communities would join each other in celebrating religious festivals.

“Open houses are definitely a signature practice of Malaysians where all will visit one another, enjoy delicacies and the hospitality of their neighbours and friends who are celebrating.

“This is so much a part of life that in our joy, we hardly stop and recognise that this is religious harmony and tolerance.

“It is also the cement which holds the Malaysian community together, distinguishing us from the other nations in the world,” he said.

The most important reminder came from the Sultan of Johor, when he said that it’s better to emphasise the commonalities and values of all religions than dwell on their differences.

Again, it looks like we must depend on our Rulers to drive common sense home into our politicians’ heads.

Daulat Tuanku!

While on holiday, take the time to visit the dead


George Michael is buried next to his mother and sister. — Photos: FLORENCE TEH

Wanting to visit a cemetery as a touristic pursuit may seem strange to most people, especially the superstitious Chinese, but I was still keen to check it out, even though the Chinese New Year was imminent.

After all, I don’t practice feng shui nor am I a Taoist, so neither convention nor tradition held me back.

Having made numerous trips to London in the past, I’ve checked the essential tourist and shopping stops.

So, this time, I decided to take on a completely different route. My family members were in disbelief, but I was, well, dead serious.

I decided to visit the sprawling Highgate cemetery, which has drawn visitors from all over the world.

It may seem morbid, but cemeteries are truly peaceful places with their leafy and manicured landscapes.

On my trip to Argentina in the 1990s, I went to pay my respects to Eva Peron, the famous late Argentine politician and actress who served as First Lady from 1946 until her death in 1952, as the wife of President Juan Domingo Peron.

The lady is, of course, the inspiration behind the musical Evita and the soundtrack was made famous by Madonna’s rendition of Don’t Cry For Me Argentina.


The columnist at Karl Marx’s tomb, which is one of the main attractions at Highgate.

It took me a while to locate her modest tomb at the Recoleta Cemetery in Buenos Aires and since then, I’ve been pretty hooked on cemetery excursions.

I checked out the Makomanai Takino cemetery in Hokkaido, with its beautiful lavender-covered landscape, during the autumn of 2018.

It’s easily the most beautiful memorial garden I’ve seen, what with over 150,000 lavender plants.

Fast forward to January 2023. The Highgate cemetery has been described as a place that has captivated visitors “by the evocative atmosphere and magnificent Victorian memorials,” with many coming to see the resting place of its famous residents.

It’s peculiar that this private cemetery, which charges a £10 (RM52) entry fee, promotes Karl Marx, the founder of communism, as its biggest attraction.

Marx, the German philosopher, economist and revolutionary socialist, is renowned for his books Das Kapital and The Communist Manifesto. His memorial, with his huge bronze bust sitting on top of a rectangular marble plinth accompanied by gilded lettering of his famous line “Workers of all lands unite”, is an easy find.

There are several tombs of communist admirers nearby, but ironically, directly opposite Marx’s tomb is that of liberal political theorist Herbert Spencer.

Another popular site is that of writer Mary Ann Evans, described as England’s greatest Victorian novelist, who used the male pen name George Elliot.


The lavender-covered Makomanai Takino cemetery in Hokkaido, Japan, which the columnist and his wife visited in 2018.

She wrote seven novels including Silas Marner, The Mill On The Floss and Middlemarch. A plaque celebrating her work and life has been erected in Westminster Abbey.

But these days, the biggest draw is George Michael, who is also buried here.

It was an oversight to not have done my research prior to visiting Highgate, so the result was an unnecessarily lengthy search.

The legendary 1980s singer, known for iconic hits like Careless Whisper, Faith and Last Christmas (with sidekick Andrew Ridgeley in Wham!), has a headstone inscribed with his real Greek name Georgios Kyriacos Panayiotou.

It’s just a simple rectangular marble slab with the epitaph: “Beloved Son, Brother, Friend”, and he is buried next to his mother and sister.

George was found dead, aged 53, on Christmas Day, 2016, at his home. Tragically, it was his last Christmas.

Highgate is also the final resting place of Prof Man Fong Mei, a poet, physicist and philosopher, who invented the world’s first disposable needle for acupuncture.


Malcom McLaren’s grave at Highgate has a bronze death mask.

The inscription aptly reads, “a positive thinker who bridged East and West with passion and generosity”.

But my favourite grave must be that of Malcolm McLaren’s, with its bronze death mask.

He managed punk rock royalty from either side of “the pond”, guiding both the New York Dolls and later, the Sex Pistols, to superstardom. In fact, he even claimed to have invented punk. McLaren was married to the late fashion designer Vivienne Westwood.

He was also the original drummer for the band Siouxsie and the Banshees, which was part of the punk rock scene of the 1980s.

I spent almost two hours walking in the cemetery, with over 170,000 plots, and it wasn’t enough because there were just too many famous personalities here, especially writers and journalists, which interested me most.

Maybe on the next London trip, I will visit the Kensal Green cemetery, where Queen frontman Freddie Mercury, famous for his many hit songs including Bohemian Rhapsody, We Are the Champions and Radio Ga Ga, is buried under his real name Farrokh Bulsara.

These well-known figures may be gone, but their inspiration and legend live on.


The grave of writer Douglas Adams, who wrote the best-selling Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy. A bouquet of pens is the hallmark at his tomb head which simply says ‘Writer’. — Photos: FLORENCE TEH

The endless stream of fresh flowers placed at their tombs by visitors is a testimony to how they’ve touched people’s lives.

But in the case of writer Douglas Adams, his grave has bouquets of pens.

He is most known for his best-seller The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Galaxy, a trilogy of five books that sold over 15 million copies. However, the tomb head has only one word – “Writer”.

The words on tombstones speak volumes and sometimes, for a legend, less is certainly more.

Yeoh – our pride and joy


Starring role: Yeoh portrays a frustrated laundromat owner saddled with tax problems in ‘Everything Everywhere All at Once’. — Handout

Malaysians rarely get cast so prominently, but the Golden Globe award winner is no greenhorn and she could well win the Oscar for the best actress category.

OVER the past few weeks, Tan Sri Michelle Yeoh has been a busy bee jet-setting across continents.

She made a quiet visit home here on Dec 24 and after that, appeared in talk shows and interviews in the United States and England.

She was interviewed on CNN by Christiane Amanpour and before that, by British talk show host Graham Norton in London.

Her appearances are important in the run-up to the Academy Awards since it’s just a month away – March 13, to be precise.

History is about to be created. The Malaysian icon stands a very good chance of winning the Oscar for the best actress category for her role in Everything Everywhere All at Once.

She faces stiff competition, but she has already created history by being the first Malaysian to secure this nomination.

As one report put it, it has taken 95 years for the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences to recognise an Asian woman in its best actress category.

Earlier this year, she had already filled our hearts with pride by winning a Golden Globe award for best actress in a musical/comedy for the movie, the second Asian to clinch the prestigious award.

Yeoh is honest about the movie, which can be viewed on Astro, saying it can be confusing but has resonated with many parents, especially immigrants who would do everything for their children.

The sentiments of their parents may not mean much to the young who see things differently, but the underlying message is about love, relationship and embracement.

It’s about having conversations with their children, which many Asian parents often struggle with.

Yeoh plays Evelyn Quan Wang, whose father is upset about her eloping with a man, with whom she runs a laundromat facing a pile of tax issues.

On top of that, she must struggle with a rebellious lesbian daughter, an incompetent spouse and an ageing and senile father she must care for.

Suddenly, she finds herself having to save the universe from a super villain named Jobu Tupaki, too. Talk about tipping the scale.

One thing stands out from all these high-profile interviews – Yeoh is articulate, intelligent, humorous and speaks impeccable English (with the Malaysian accent proudly intact, without the pretentious clipped Western tone many are only too happy to adopt), and she knows when and how to deliver the right sound bite to make her interview newsworthy for each show.

Yeoh also proudly wears her Asian roots on her sleeve yet maintains a broad outlook with an international appeal.

Obviously Yeoh is media savvy and comfortable to take questions without a script.

Yeoh has worked very hard to get where she is. Her solid credentials include roles in blockbusters such as James Bond movie Tomorrow Never Dies, Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon and Crazy Rich Asians, all of which have raised her profile.

But Everything Everywhere All at Once, with interdimensional roles and newfound powers to fight bizarre dangers from the multiverse, is her first starring role.

With 11 nominations at the upcoming Oscars, the movie is poised to win many awards but the world, especially Asians, will be cheering for our Ipoh girl to win the best actress award.

Standing in her way is Australian actress Cate Blanchett, who plays Lydia Tar in the psychological drama film Tar, about an imposing female conductor in Berlin preying on women.

News reports are billing it as a neck-and-neck race with Yeoh having a slight edge, but for now, Yeoh is the most sought-after guest in talk shows, which will surely help her in the contest.

This year’s Academy Awards 2023, which will be held on Monday at 8am, will surely be the most watched ever by Malaysians.

We will be rooting for our pride and joy, our hero. Whatever the outcome, she remains our darling and Malaysia is enormously proud of her.