Author Archives: wcw

Reality bites

WHILE it has finally dawned on PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang that no political coalition can hope to form the federal government without the support of non-Muslims, he has yet to realise why many of us aren’t consumed by the party.

The task of convincing non-Muslims voters to change their perception of the Islamist party isn’t its partner’s Gerakan, but his.

Until last week, PAS Members of Parliament were still haggling over the call by Dewan Rakyat Speaker Tan Sri Johari Abdul to stop using the word “kafir” on non-Muslims, particularly DAP MPs.

The point is, even Umno members, who are mostly Muslims, have been called kafir for working with MCA and MIC previously.

Those who watched the televised proceedings would have seen the Speaker clasping his hands and pleading to PAS MP Mohd Misbahul Munir Masduki to refrain from using the word as the latter continuously tried to justify its validity.

To the Parit Buntar MP, kafir simply means non-believer. If that’s the case, how does he justify his party having called Umno members kafir, too?

Johari said it had sensitive connotations and that “non-Muslims” would be a more pleasant word to the ears of those being addressed.

Just a few months ago, Hadi blamed non-Muslims for being corrupt, pendatang, anti-Islam and made other damning accusations, but now, he has woken up and realises he needs non-Muslim support.

It didn’t occur to him during the recent state elections, presumably because he was so sure the Green Wave would be sufficient.

But after failing to win in Penang, Selangor and Negeri Sembilan, and the by-elections in the Pulai parliamentary and Pelangai state constituencies, PAS has stopped dreaming and is now getting a dose of reality.

It doesn’t matter that the Opposition has experienced a vote count increase because ours is modelled after the first-past post system. So, even if a candidate wins by a single vote, it’s still a win.

By now, it must be obvious that no political coalition can form the federal government without the support of Sabah and Sarawak.

So, besides the non-Muslims, there are other bumiputra and Muslims, including those in major cities, who don’t find PAS palatable.

To its credit, PAS has recruited many professionals into its fold, but it’s still a party dominated by theologians. They call the shots, and they dictate the narratives and plans of the party, and the kind of government if they were to come into power.

It’s not merely about whether non-Muslims can still wear shorts in public, but the fear of losing our lifestyles, or what’s left of it.

Hadi has never distanced himself from statements issued by his party leaders calling for an end to all concerts and even cultural celebrations, for example. The two PAS-ruled states of Kelantan and Terengganu have even killed certain aspects of Malay culture, saying some elements were against Islam.

The first thing Hadi did as Terengganu Mentri Besar in 1999 was to demolish a replica of a giant turtle at a roundabout in Kuala Terengganu, saying it was akin to idol worshipping.

A year later, then Terengganu PAS state executive councillor Wan Hassan Mohd Ramli reportedly vowed to tear down every sculpture in the state, including those of prawns and squids in Marang.

The irony, if not hypocrisy, is that when PAS worked with DAP and PKR during the Barisan Alternatif era in 1998, the political actions were justified by the party. The DAP politicians then weren’t infidels yet somehow, they are viewed that way now.

Likewise, current PAS ally, Gerakan, isn’t kafir, presumably because they are seen as moderates in the eyes of PAS.

I’m certain Gerakan won’t subscribe to the formation of an Islamic state in Malaysia or endorse the full implementation of syariah laws, so where does that leave the party?

Hadi has stopped short of saying that those who are against him or the party are “anti-Islam” and “promoting Islamophobia.”

Of course, it has nothing to do with religion. The grouse is the political system that Hadi and PAS aspires to doesn’t sit well with many of us.

For a start, it’s important for emerging PAS leaders to have continuous engagement with non-governmental organisations, especially the media and even non-Muslim groups. After all, the party has more credibility than Gerakan.

Many media members have said that their calls to PAS leaders have been left unanswered with their aides privately revealing they don’t feel comfortable talking to the press.

The party had even imposed a ban on its candidates from speaking to the media during the recent state polls.

But an engagement must start. It holds 43 of the 222 seats at the Dewan Rakyat, which must surely be treated seriously and respected.

Like it or not, it’s a mainstream party, but it must act like one, too. If its leaders are still preoccupied with the dressing of women nurses, flight attendants, questioning the organising of concerts, calling people kafir and barring women gymnasts from Sukma2024 by citing non-syariah compliant attire, then PAS shouldn’t be surprised why it isn’t getting traction from non-Muslims and even many Muslims.

PAS must stop seeing those who disagree with it as enemies. All of us are stakeholders who want a better Malaysia. After all, this country belongs to all Malaysians.

New King to be elected tomorrow

In time-honoured tradition, the Conference of Rulers will make their decision.

THE country’s nine Rulers will elect the next Yang di-Pertuan Agong during a special meeting of the Conference of Rulers tomorrow.

An official announcement of the next king is expected to be made after Friday prayers.

This election will be for the country’s 17th king for a five-year reign since it attained independence over six decades ago.

While the nation has the only elected constitutional monarch in the world, the process is also based on a rotation agreed to by the Rulers.

It is both a tradition and a convention which has been respected and upheld in the royal institution.

The election is stipulated under the Federal Constitution to choose a new king and his deputy under a five-year term.

Only the nine Rulers who are members of the Conference of Rulers can take part in the secret balloting.

The Conference of Rulers began their two-day meeting yesterday at Istana Negara.

This 262nd meeting of the Conference of Rulers was chaired by the Sultan of Johor, Sultan Ibrahim Almarhum Sultan Iskandar.

A pre-meeting involving just the Rulers was held the day before.

According to reports, the first cycle of the rotation, from 1957 – when the office of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong was established – to 1994, saw Negri Sembilan at the top of the election list, followed by Selangor, Perlis, Terengganu, Kedah, Kelantan, Pahang, Johor and Perak.

The term of the present King, Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri’ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah, will end on Jan 31 next year.

So, the next Yang di-Pertuan Agong in line will be the Sultan of Johor.

The deputy is expected to be the Sultan of Perak, Sultan Nazrin Muizzuddin Shah Almarhum Sultan Azlan Muhibbuddin Shah.

The Rulers place great respect on tradition and precedence to the institution and its time-held process of choosing a king.

While there is an election, the Rulers are unlike ordinary politicians.

It’s fair to say that the royal institution is the only one which Malaysians have high regard and respect for.

Although the Rulers are viewed as the custodians and protectors of Islam and the Malays, they have all displayed fairness and moderation to all Malaysians, regardless of their race or religion.

Malaysians have high regard and respect for the Rulers and possibly feel that this is the only institution they can place their trust in.

All eyes will be on the Sultan of Johor, who is regarded as an outspoken and forthright ruler.

His Majesty has consistently expressed his views openly on the need to protect the unity of the people, in particular Bangsa Johor.

Malaysians are looking forward to his reign as the next Yang di-Pertuan Agong and we are confident His Majesty will bring the needed fresh and positive changes to push Malaysia forward to a new level.

The installation of the new king, in a ceremony steeped in royal Malay customs and traditions, formally marking his reign as head of state, is expected to take place in July next year.

It will be a historic moment as apart from the Rulers and their respective consorts, many royal figures will also attend the ceremony.

Standing with the Palestinians

GENOCIDE, holocaust or simply an annihilation of the Palestinians in the tiny Gaza Strip. At least one of those descriptions is certainly accurate about what’s happening in the Middle East.

It’s called a strip precisely because it’s just a narrow 360 sq km piece of land wedged between Israel, Egypt and the Mediterranean Sea.

The Gaza Strip, which has about two million people, is one of the most densely populated areas in the world.

But humanity is now about to witness the comprehensive decimation of the community there.

Water and food supplies have been cut, with no power reaching the hospitals either. No one is spared as Israel has ordered everyone, including hospital patients, to get out before the ground offensive begins.

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has aptly called it a “death sentence” by Israel.


Relatives attend the funeral of Christian and Muslim Palestinians who were sheltering at a Greek Orthodox church in Gaza City, killed in Israeli airstrikes that hit it on Thursday. The Israeli military said it was targeting a Hamas command centre nearby. — AP

Basically, ordinary Palestinians who aren’t even Hamas members, will now lose what’s left of their race. The tiny enclave with no real government or army, stands to even lose its people’s dignity.

While many of us are outraged at the unravelling atrocities, we need to first understand certain fundamentals.

Presently, the Palestinians live in the Iran-backed Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip, while in the nearby West Bank, it’s administered by Israel with some degree of autonomous rule by the Fatah- run Palestinian Authority.

No sane person could condone the kidnapping or killing of Israelis by Hamas. Violence isn’t right and it’s hard to justify such actions in any circumstance. Young people attending a music festival have been taken hostage and made into human shields.

But the ordinary people in Gaza are now paying the price for the attacks by Hamas.

It will be an assault by the Israelis that the people on the Gaza Strip can’t win, and it’s tragically disappointing that the United States doesn’t want to initiate a ceasefire or de-escalation.

The US has, instead, provided more fire power to its ally for complete destruction. It has just committed billions of dollars to strengthening Israel. Whether US President Joe Biden’s intentions are to broker a deal or appeal to Israel to provide routes out of the conflict zone, he will inevitably be going to Israel to support Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

The world isn’t going to believe that it was Hamas who bombed the crowded Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital that killed 3,000 people.

The hospital, built in 1882, is in the Zeitoun neighbourhood in the south of Gaza and managed by the Episcopal Church in Jerusalem. Before this, health authorities and medical organisations had reported Israel forces deliberately bombing ambulances and health facilities in Gaza, breaching international rules that catalogue such acts as war crimes.

There’s an abundance of reports documenting these systematic attacks and medical personnel being targeted and killed.

If the world does nothing except issue condemnations, that won’t be enough to end the conflict. Only the superpowers can pressure and stop Israel, and certainly not Malaysian forces, so let’s not kid ourselves.

The Arab world is in a similar bind because some nations have diplomatic ties with Israel, but they have appropriately decided not to meet Biden over a hastily called summit. It’s a strong signal to Biden and Israel of the great unhappiness of the Arab world even though some of these countries are not fans of Hamas.

I’m glad that Members of Parliament from all parties and ordinary Malaysians of all faiths have registered their outrage and joined in the noble protest.

It’s not merely a conflict between Palestinian Muslims who are further oppressed by the Jews from Israel. It’s much more complex than that.

Palestinian Christians have seen their land robbed from them and they get the same treatment as their Muslim brothers when they enter Israeli-occupied areas.

I’ve witnessed personally the humiliation suffered by the Palestinians. Yes, there are Christian Arabs and Christian Palestinians.


Tragically disappointing: Protesters rallying against the Israeli military operations in Gaza in Washington DC. Only the superpowers can pressure and stop Israel but the United States doesn’t seem to want to initiate a ceasefire or de-escalation. — AFP

Likewise, there are Muslim Arabs who have Israeli citizenship and live in the country. Jews, by the way, are not Christians, and not all Israelis or Jews are Zionists. There are many secular Jews who don’t subscribe to the religious practices of their community.

The danger here in Malaysia is that many Malaysians lump all Israelis under the category of the hated “Orang Yahudi” like how some evangelical Christians typecast all Israelis as God-fearing and righteous “God’s chosen people.”

In fact, in 2021, church leaders in Jerusalem condemned attacks on Christians across Jerusalem and the Holy Land. “Fringe radical groups” with strong Jewish links were responsible for physical assaults and vandalising churches.

There are many video-clips on YouTube which clearly depict Christian pilgrims being spat at and abused.

As the anger festers and grows in an unending cycle over the conflict area, memories of my pilgrimage to Jerusalem in 2005 have come flooding back. I had wanted to travel to the Holy Land again in 2022, but the Malaysian general election put paid to those plans.

Malaysians aren’t allowed to travel to Israel since we have no diplomatic ties, but thanks to the Malaysian government’s flexibility, restricted trips to Jerusalem are allowed for religious purposes.

I remember my guides were a Muslim driver, Ahmad Badawi, and an Arab Christian, Jerries Farra. The latter spoke excellent Bahasa Indonesia because he often had to chaperone Indonesian pilgrims, the most visitors from South-East Asia to Jerusalem.

Farra, who could quote Bible verses in Bahasa Indonesia, was often emotional when he spoke about the unfair practices, alerting us to the wall being constructed on the West Bank then.

I lost count of security checkpoints manned by Israeli soldiers outside towns such as Bethlehem, Jericho and Nazareth, all biblical sites, but under the control of the Palestinian Authority.

Palestinians were often stopped randomly at roadsides and the simple act of entering their hometowns could become six-hour ordeals, affecting their productivity and hampering their movements.

How would you feel if occupiers did this to you and your family for 60 years?

How many Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces just this year? The answer: a staggering 4,200 people including over a thousand children and 800 women, with more than 15,000 injured. This figure is likely out-dated by now.

Do I believe that the Israelis didn’t bomb the Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital? Not at all, and it’s even sadder to hear Biden, and especially CNN, trying valiantly to defend the Israelis.

When Shireen Abu Akleh, a Palestinian-American reporter and acclaimed correspondent for Al Jazeera, was shot dead on May 12, 2022, the world was served the same denial.

She was killed by a sniper while performing her duty reporting on Israel’s raid in the Jenin refugee camp despite wearing distinctive identification as a journalist.

Unfortunately, the West has refused to acknowledge the root causes of the problem.

In the coming weeks, maybe even days, the Israeli tanks will roll into the streets of Gaza. If they think they’ve finally won the war, they’re grossly mistaken because after 60 years of conflict, little has changed despite their huge arsenal of modern weapons and financial backing.

As children watching the old Hollywood westerns and TV shows, we naively believed the cowboys were the good guys while the Red Indians were savages. Not anymore because we all now know that the cowboys were pilfering the native Americans’ land and slaughtering them.

The world has become better-informed. We don’t have to rely only on CNN to understand what’s transpiring in the Gaza Strip.

The Palestinians have been provoked, attacked, killed and trampled upon for over 60 years, doesn’t the West get it?

With Palestine we stand.

Internal affairs

IT’S unprecedented to hear about a top police officer admonishing a room full of the most senior cops from the Criminal Investigations Department (CID), and then uploading a video of the shelling online.

When these CID officers from around the country gathered for a closed-door meeting, they surely would have expected some tough words from Bukit Aman CID chief Comm Datuk Seri Mohd Shuhaily Mohd Zain.

He had already built a reputation for his commitment towards cleaning up the force and getting rid of rogue policemen.

Mohd Shuhaily has received the backing of Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Razarudin Husain and his deputy, Datuk Seri Ayob Khan Mydin Pitchay.

The CID officers, who hold sensitive positions, were told that they had to declare their assets.

The officers include those in the Intelligence and Operations Division, Anti-Vice, Gambling and Secret Societies Division (D7), and head of the CID Division at district police headquarters.

While many Malaysians perceive cops as corrupt, Mohd Shuhaily went a step further by revealing that some officers were willing to risk their comrades’ lives for payment from syndicates by providing false information during operations.


Stern warning: Comm Mohd Shuhaily has put his CID officers on notice that he’s very serious about cleaning up corruption in their ranks – and his message is still reverberating on social media and among the public. — LOW LAY PHON/The Star

So operations end up failing, but more gravely, the lives of policemen are compromised.

Even informants could be exposed, if such dangerous liaisons exist.

Basically, some in the team are willing to kill each other for money.

This happens because there’s no supervision at the lower levels (contingent and district levels) to monitor the lifestyles of officers and their subordinates.

It’s a chilling revelation. To be corrupt is one thing, but to hear of cops who are prepared to let their colleagues be wiped out is another thing entirely.

Corruption has long been entrenched in the police force, but its extent is beyond the imagination of most Malaysians.

It has been a week since Mohd Shuhaily’s warning during the CID Director’s Mandate Ceremony at Universiti Sains Malaysia.

But the message is still reverberating on social media, with the public talking about it and anticipating what could happen next.


File photo of 14 individuals, including a police station chief and two officers, arrested by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission over a protection racket. The public knows there are corrupt cops but perhaps we don’t realise the extent of the rot. — Filepic/The Star

“How can a sergeant afford an Alphard, Vellfire, or Mercedes? Have their superiors or supervisors ever asked how they can afford luxury vehicles or declared their assets?” Mohd Shuhaily asked.

For Malaysians reading this, we’d be wondering how these policemen could be so brazen as to flaunt their wealth and flashy lifestyles with no fear of retribution?

How can their supervisors be oblivious to their inexplicable wealth unless they close an eye or, worse, are part of the cartel?

A month will be up soon when CID officers hand in their declarations about their assets, and it will be interesting to see what ensues.

The demand is simple – just explain how they can afford luxury vehicles and other items. Their wives have also been ordered to issue separate declarations.

A new order is growing at Bukit Aman as the new team of top officers takes command.

State police officers who have provided false information have found Bukit Aman teams descending upon them and their turf.

These top officers bent on cleaning up are aware that their mission is not going to be easy.

It won’t happen overnight either, and they will face hurdles and sabotage, which could be costly to their careers and even their lives, as their enthusiasm for rehabilitating the force could lead to loneliness and frustration.

They will have to deal with powerful figures who are well-connected and viewed as untouchable. They can only succeed if they, too, have the backing of the top political leadership.

Mohd Shuhaily, who just started work in August, has earned the respect and support of Malaysians.

His directive was officially uploaded by the police for another reason – for the warning to reach every level of the police force and not just the CID.

Without doubt, there are many clean, decent and good cops at all levels.


Mohd Shuhaily seems to have always taken a slightly unusual path – here he is (left) when he was Kuala Lumpur police chief discovering the problems of being blind in the city. — Filepic/Sin Chew

But Mohd Shuhaily also shared about the daily struggles of policemen, saying a constable’s take home pay is merely RM1,500 a month.

He said the moment someone signs up to be a constable, the person would automatically be in the B40 (low income) category.

Urging his CID officers to be more caring, he lambasted some for not even knowing about the welfare of their team members, saying some officers don’t even turn up for work. Some stop going out on operations, claiming to be specialists.

Our cops certainly deserve a better pay structure and perks if we want them to be more financially secure and able to fight corruption and its temptations.

May the force be with you Tuan Razarudin, Ayob Khan and Mohd Shuhaily! God has put you there for a reason.

Be afraid of God because we’re only answerable to Him and not man.

Grain of truth

THE local rice supply shortage has rudely rattled most of us. Naturally, it’s been followed by the traditional finger pointing.

The grain has inexplicably vanished from supermarket shelves, while the price of imported rice has spiked.

The facts indicate that we’ve neglected food production – including rice farming – for decades. How many of us, especially our politicians, are truly concerned about the matter or have provided sound solutions?

The country spent about RM76bil on food imports last year, an increase from 2021’s RM64bil.

Basically, 60% of Malaysia’s food is imported. We are highly dependent on food and beverage products, especially raw materials for food processing such as wheat, dairy and other ingredients.


Crop crunch: Rice farmer Muhamad Syafiq Afandy Muhamad Sofi inspecting his padi after a flood in Kedah. Extreme weather events have threatened rice production in many countries including Malaysia. — Bernama

Malaysia doesn’t produce enough to feed us. Cameron Highlands can’t supply sufficient amounts of vegetables, and the result is us having to import them from China, Indonesia, Argentina, Thailand and India.

The price of rice spiked when India, which accounts for 40% of the world’s supply, decided to halt rice exports recently.

There was also an earlier report by Reuters saying Vietnam intends to cut its annual rice exports by 44% to four million tonnes by 2030.

But Vietnam has since denied the report, saying it will maintain the status quo.

There are many reasons why rice production has suffered. Climate change has led to erratic weather that has threatened production in India and other countries. Malaysia hasn’t been spared either.

Floods, droughts and heat stress have been contributing factors, with the agricultural sector’s share of the nation’s GDP declining from 43.7% to 7.1% between 1960 and 2021, reveal reports.

But the situation has worsened. The national rice average yield is low, at a little over three tonnes per hectare.


In most supermarkets, only imported rice is left on sale but its price has spiked. — Bernama

The country’s self-sufficiency rate was only 65% in 2021 compared with the set target of 75% in the 12th Malaysia Plan (2021-2025).

Even Bangladesh is self-sufficient in its rice production, fish, meat and eggs. And so is Myan-mar, with a self-sufficiency rate of 179.4%.

The debate may be raging over the local rice shortage, but no one seems to be able to give a definite reason for its absence from supermarkets.

There are many conspiracy theories, including blaming the present unity government and sole importer Padiberas Nasional Bhd (Bernas), hoarding by wholesalers and millers, and suppliers repacking and mixing local rice with imported rice to make bigger profits.

Against this backdrop, many Malaysians have reduced rice consumption as the country becomes more affluent and health conscious.

But for the B40 (lower income) group, rice is a staple food, and the lack of local rice is detrimental, and predictably, the situation has been exploited politically.

According to reports, rice per capita consumption has declined over the years from 120kg in the 1970s to 77kg in 2022.

But rice imports have still risen, going from 1.06 million tonnes in 2021 to 1.11 million tonnes in 2022.

We are feeling the pinch, or pain, now because the ringgit’s value has diminished. Food production cost has also gone up because of the war in Ukraine, which has affected feed for animals as well as fertiliser.

There have been calls to end Bernas’ monopoly as the sole rice importer, but many analysts are doubtful others, if allowed, are prepared to meet the conditions imposed by the government on Bernas.

Few are aware that the caveat includes buying very bad quality padi from local farmers.

The Edge quoted Sarena Che Omar, Khazanah Research Institute deputy director of research, as saying, “When you buy low quality rice, you make a loss because there is a price floor”.

She has some advice: “If we want to get rid of Bernas because we think that monopolies are so bad, we must make sure we put in place [someone] who will take care of the stockpile.

“Until we settle all this, we had better be careful about what we want to kick out, as that entity may be the one keeping things going on as usual.”

Bernas is paying RM1,280 per tonne even for poor quality padi because that’s the price floor. Nothing less because that’s the deal.

So is there a shortage of local rice? According to The Edge, which quoted an Agriculture and Food Security senior official, at the current rice stockpile level, it would be sufficient under normal circumstances, excluding a war or a prolonged natural disaster.

The Agriculture and Food Security Ministry needs to be given plenty of support and attention if Malaysia is serious about wanting to be self-sufficient in food production and reducing our food import bills.

We need to address some serious issues, which are the reasons for the decline in local padi production.

The price of padi is low, it is difficult to source for labour, more padi fields are being converted into development land, especially in Kedah and northern Perak, farmers are mostly senior citizens, while its low price is not making it viable for commercial farming.

We need to improve rice production beyond Kedah, Kelantan, Perlis, Perak and Selangor. The risk is too high for Malaysia to be dependent on just these few states.

If diseases or climate change affect these states, production is undoubtedly hit, immediately. Certainly, we need help from China to improve our yield using modern technologies.

It’s serious food for thought for our leaders, policymakers and stakeholders.

PM Anwar keeps everyone guessing on Cabinet reshuffle


THE Prime Minister is certainly keeping everyone, including his Cabinet members, guessing when he will announce his new line-up. On the surface, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim may not be in a hurry to unveil the list, but the tight window period means news is imminent.

The next few days will be crucial as speculation on the changes will shift into higher gear. On Sunday, Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Zahid Ahmad Hamidi, lent weight to the issue at hand by saying the Cabinet may undergo a reshuffle, which “will be soon.”

He said one of the reasons for the reshuffle was to fill the ministerial post for Domestic, Trade and Cost of Living, following the death of Datuk Salahuddin Ayub in July.

Prior to this, Anwar had said he would “think about” a reshuffle, when pressed by reporters if such a plan was in the pipeline. His delay in making the announcement has prompted analysts, the media and even some senior Parti Keadilan Nasional leaders to examine his schedule for the next few days for possible clues.

He leaves for the United Arab Emirates’ capital Abu Dhabi for a two-day trip on Wednesday and will be back in Kuala Lumpur on Friday. It’s unclear if he would unveil the new Cabinet list just a day before the Pelangai by-election in Pahang, which is the next day, Oct 7.

It’s well within his rights to do this because a by-election has no bearing on a Cabinet reshuffle. But like all changes, not everyone will be pleased, and it could, in fact, be turned into a point of contention by the Opposition, should there be reason.

The first of the coming Dewan Rakyat sittings will be on Oct 9, with the Budget to be presented on Oct 13. It will be more difficult to make any changes once Parliament is in session because ministers would have to field questions from Members of Parliament.

While staff from the respective ministries would be the ones entrusted to prepare replies to the questions from MPs, it would certainly be better if ministers themselves face the MPs.

It would be unfair to newly appointed ministers to handle such a task as the person could also be getting supplementary questions, which may not have written replies on hand. The last thing the Prime Minister needs is fumbling ministers who can’t provide comprehensive answers to questions from the Opposition.

The Dewan Rakyat meeting will drag on until Nov 30, which is the longest meeting for the year. With Anwar keeping his cards close to his chest, the dates ahead, which involve the Dewan Rakyat, provide an idea of how little room he has to manoeuvre.

If it’s merely to fill up a single post, then it could hardly qualify to be labelled a reshuffle. As Anwar enters his first year as PM, it makes sense for him to make meaningful alterations to the Cabinet. If it’s merely a rotation of ministers, then there won’t be any added value.

Malaysians expect him to name new entrants and drop a few non-performers to make the reorganisation impactful. But as the guessing game continues, all kinds of speculations have surfaced, including one involving Selangor Mentri Besar Datuk Seri Amirudin Shari, who is also Gombak MP, being made a Cabinet minister.

This is unlikely since the 10-member Selangor executive council has seven new faces. It will make more strategic sense for Amirudin, an experienced leader, to take on the 22-member state opposition led by Datuk Seri Azmin Ali, who is a former MB.

News portals have realised that gossip on Cabinet changes garners high views, even if there’s little truth to it. But they do make a good read.

So, as Zahid has said, the reshuffle will be very soon, and it can’t be done when Parliament is in session or at the end of the year.

Just another day in the august House


Screaming match: Radzi lost his cool when Anwar (below) took a swipe at him for laughing while the PM was explaining the DNAA issue. — Bernama

IT’S not the first, and neither will it be the last time the Dewan Rakyat descends into chaos, with our Members of Parliament screaming at each other, hurling abuses, and then staging the traditional walkout protest.

Malaysians have become accustomed to this form of shenanigans from some of our not-so-honourable members of the House.

We can no longer keep track of the instances when Parliament degenerates into a circus with uncouth language used by both sides of the divide.

Ultimately, all this tells us is that meaningful debates are rare commodities within its walls.

The theatrics and poor conduct of these recalcitrant lawmakers have always overshadowed the painstakingly research-driven speeches of their more responsible and well-meaning colleagues.

We’ve long given up hope that Dewan Rakyat could be like Westminster, where MPs engage in constructive, witty and refined exchanges.

The usual rowdy MPs in our Dewan Rakyat may have disappeared, but they have been replaced by new ones. It seems like the assembly line churning them out never stops.

Last week, the special sitting of the Dewan Rakyat saw two back-to-back yelling matches on the first day. What a ceremonious start.

Tensions boiled over Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi’s discharge not amounting to an acquittal (DNAA) for his 47 graft charges involving Yayasan Akalbudi funds.

Perikatan Nasional MPs staged a walkout from the Dewan Rakyat following a protracted argument when Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim was delivering his winding-up speech on the 12th Malaysia Plan mid-term review.

The House was thrown into pandemonium when Anwar took a swipe at Datuk Dr Radzi Jidin (PN-Putrajaya) for laughing when he was explaining the issue.

We are used to all kinds of petulant behaviour involving politicians inside or outside Parliament, but some level of respect must surely be accorded, even if the MPs concerned feel strongly about their stand.

In moments of anger, some of us respond in a way we regret later. Radzi is often seen as someone who maintains his composure, so his outburst at Anwar came as a curveball.


Former Economic Director at the Prime Minister’s Office Shahril Hamdan, the co-host of a podcast with Khairy Jamaluddin, said Radzi “scored an own goal” while KJ said Radzi fell “into a trap.”

Former Economic Director at the Prime Minister’s Office Shahril Hamdan, the co-host of a podcast with Khairy Jamaluddin, said Radzi ‘scored an own goal’ while KJ said Radzi ‘fell into a trap.’ — Bernama

But the bottom line is there must be some parameters. Regardless of our positions, we must all show restraint.

Let’s have some class, dignity and decorum. We may have our political differences, but we need to respect each other’s views.

In Anwar’s case, his sodomy conviction was fully pardoned by the previous Yang di-Pertuan Agong in 2018, with Anwar saying that the King found his conviction a travesty of justice.

To bring it up in Parliament, even if briefly, and in a moment of anger, is surely unbecoming.

A “free” or “full pardon” wipes the slate clean of a conviction, as legal expert Prof Shad Saleem Faruqi had written about the implications of a royal pardon. So, the convict is released from all the penalties, legal disabilities and disqualifications.

It has been the tradition of mainstream media not to dwell on prior convictions of personalities who have been pardoned by His Majesty the King.

They’ve included former Selangor Mentri Besar, the late Datuk Harun Idris, who was jailed for embezzlement and graft of funds, and a former minister, the late Datuk Mokhtar Hashim.

The latter was sentenced to death for murder in 1983 before receiving a royal pardon in 2020.

The news portals today, however, have taken a lesser approach.

Many have not spent enough time in court reporting to understand the full meaning of someone who has been pardoned.

Insinuations of any kind against those who are recipients of a royal pardon, whether in the Dewan Rakyat or worse, online, would be out of place. It doesn’t constitute freedom of expression.

The aftermath of Radzi’s outburst is that all political secretaries to the unity government have called for the former Education Minister to be barred from Parliament.

The PM’s senior political secretary Datuk Seri Shamsul Iskandar Md Akin said the group was now writing to the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Law and Institutional Reform) Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said, to call for Radzi’s suspension.

Having covered Parliament for decades as a reporter, I’ve often wondered if the public knows that after such hijinks, these MPs often adjourn for coffee, slap one another’s backs, and enjoy each other’s company.

By now, we should know that MPs can scream at each other today but tomorrow, they could be sitting on the same bench. Or having tea together outside.

Welcome to the world of Malaysian politics. It’s not for the faint of heart.

David and Goliath

RENOWNED animal activist Christine Chin and her family have been residing on a 38,000 sq ft piece of land in the northern reaches of Ampang for 11 years in a luxurious Asian-styled villa tailored to her interests and lifestyle.

In addition to her collection of art pieces and objects, there’s also an office in the house for the chairman of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) Selangor.

Naturally, a large well-landscaped and lush garden is also home to rescued dogs and pets of friends, which come to her when their owners are away. The compound also offers a clean and comfortable space when rescuers seek her assistance for temporary housing of animals.

It was a fulfilling and idyllic existence, until late 2016 when her nightmare began.

It was a rude end to everything she had wanted to build her life around. In fact, it was the beginning of a traumatic roller coaster ride, both emotionally and financially.

The developer of the East Klang Valley Expressway (EKVE) and Ampang Jaya Municipal Council appeared at her doorstep one day and informed her that her property encroached on state land, when in fact, the property owner had a title deed refuting their claims.

Fast forward to 2023, and the EKVE remains uncompleted and has become an eyesore. Residents in the area are also upset because Chin has been spending too much time and money fighting the case.

“Every morning, I wake up and see this ugly structure, which is just metres away from my home. It’s coming to six years now.

“The delay has given us immense anxiety and financial distress. We can’t even sell the property with this dangling over our heads, literally.

“I doubt that anyone wants to take over (buy it) when they see the incomplete highway and its proximity to our home. Don’t forget the legal issues also.”

The crux of the issue is that Article 13 (1) of the Land Acquisition Act states that there must be adequate compensation for a property acquired.

But the unhappiness for Chin and other residents is that the state government is taking ages to provide compensation.

She had written several letters to Selangor Mentri Besar Datuk Seri Amirudin Shari but, with no resolution forthcoming, she has had no choice but to pursue legal solutions.

The builder of the EKVE, which is a RM1.55bil 36km highway between Ukay Perdana and Bandar Sungai Long in Kajang, has a 50-year concession to run the highway and it is supposed to have been completed in 2019.

It has continued to seek an extension because the project is mired in multiple complex legal issues and logistical delays.

Chin said she had even been blamed for the delay but believes “this a good lesson for all citizens as our rights should not be taken away”.

While fighting for compensation, dialogues were had about redesigning the elevated U-turn to avoid the property, six years after the compulsory acquisition completed in 2018.

This redesign prompted Bukit Antarabangsa, Beverly Heights and Taman Sering Ukay Residents Association to file protest letters to the Malaysian Highway Authority (LLM), calling for the authorities to evaluate the new design and provide reassurance that it has followed safety standards.

The association chairman Brig Jen (R) Datuk Mohd Arshad Raji reportedly said the current redesign appeared too sharp and narrow for vehicles, saying it would be prone to accidents for motorists, especially those living in Ukay Perdana, Bukit Antarabangsa.

Arshad, who is also the Army and Police Veterans’ National Patriots Association president, said the highway’s construction stopped at a bend because it encroached on private land where compensation was not paid.

The Land Administrator has now issued an award, known as Borang H, to the property owner for the hefty sum of RM11.2mil, but not a single sen has been paid.

The Borang H is a notice of award and offer of compensation made by the land administrator in respect of a compulsory land acquisition.

But soon after the award was issued, the developer, EKVE Sdn Bhd, a subsidiary of Ahmad Zaki Resources Bhd, took legal action against Chin and four state agencies for alleged fraud and negligence.

In court documents filed on Oct 30, 2019, the defendants included the Land Administrator of Gombak, Registrar of Titles, Selangor, State Directors of Land and Mines, Selangor, and Director of Survey and Mapping, Selangor.

The EKVE has not only earned the rap from residents but even drawn the attention of former prime minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri, who said in 2021 that the construction of the highway had caused floods because drains were clogged, thus disrupting the drainage system in Hulu Langat.

He said clogged drains caused the water to rise quickly with Hulu Langat being the worst-hit area during the massive floods then.

In March, the Works Ministry said the EKVE was 91% complete and that it would be opened in stages starting 2024 – which is just months away.

It certainly doesn’t look that way. Most importantly, this story needs to be told because while most people would simply accept similar compulsory land acquisitions quietly, the property owner chose to fight back.

She’s not against development and she understands the spirit of the Land Acquisition Act, but she is merely fighting for what is right and fair, and importantly, hopes to be treated with respect.

She fights a lonely and expensive battle, but she’s not letting it go that easily.

Tasteful tapestry

THE numbers were beyond the expectations of the organisers when more than 10,000 people of various races and ages showed up to participate in the Keretapi Sarong 2023 (KS2023) recently.

While most wore the sarong and the kain pelikat to the event, many also turned up in their traditional attire to add colour to KS2023 to celebrate the love for Malaysia and its diversity.

This year’s theme, Ethnicity and Unity, was accompanied with a strong fashion show, a flash mob and joget lambak, replete with the 1960s and 1970s music filling the air, revealed news reports.

I wish I was there. It must have been the party of the year. I’ve promised myself that I’ll be there next year with my buddies.

One news report that touched me was a Bernama story accompanied by a video of a Peranakan couple, John Roland Goh, 71, and Lai Joo Lian, 70, who were up by 6am to get ready and be part of the programme.

They were dressed in traditional Baba Nyonya attire, a short kebaya and sarong, as well as a Malaysian batik shirt.

For Lai, KS2023 was nostalgic because it allowed her to recall her teenage years and provide the opportunity to see the different types and patterns of clothing worn by today’s younger people.


Nostalgic event: Lai (second from right) with her friends in Nyonya kebaya and sarong at the recent Keretapi Sarong 2023. The 70-year-old was up by 6am to get ready to be part of the programme. — Bernama

What I liked most about this event is that Malaysians voluntarily turned up all decked in their best. That’s the best part of spontaneity – it’s real and raw.

It was a reminder that Malaysia is safe.

Without politicians spewing toxic race and religion narratives, Malaysians are well clued-in on how to respect each other.

Whether it’s the joget lambak or ronggeng, most Muslims love and appreciate these cultural facets without being frowned upon.

It’s common knowledge that wayang kulit (shadow play) and menora (a Siamese theatre dance) have been banned by the PAS state governments.

The traditional dance, kuda kepang, was once banned but is slowly returning with some tweaks to parts that apparently infringed on religious sensitivities previously.

The songkok, for example, is just a Malay headdress and has no religious connotations. A baju Melayu is just incomplete without the songkok.

Why should anyone make a fuss if it’s compulsory to wear a songkok to an istana event?

I’m proud that the brass band of my alma mater, St Xavier’s Institution, had a velvet songkok as part of its uniform.

I happily and proudly wear a songkok with my baju Melayu during Hari Raya open houses.

And I can’t ever recall the Indian saree becoming an issue until recent years. Suddenly, sarees are deemed inappropriate and offensive by certain groups or institutions because it traditionally exposes midriffs and backs.

It’s a classic case of ignorance because this elegant dress was never designed to attract unwanted attention – it’s just the way it is and has always been. How has it suddenly become a crime now?

Last week, a school in Kajang found itself in the news when it allegedly barred its students from wearing the saree during the National Day celebrations.

This isn’t the first nor will it be the last time unless the Education and Higher Education Ministries put a stop to this nonsense by issuing a circular saying the saree is acceptable – not just for schools but at university levels, too.

Make it clear and leave no room for doubts or discretions. Engage Indian cultural and religious leaders on this dressing issue if clarity is needed.


The elegant saree was never designed to attract unwanted attention and can be worn in varying degrees of modesty. — The Star

Teachers and lecturers should stick to what they are hired for – teach – and not make judgment calls on what is moral according to their individual standards and prejudices.

Anyone who has been caught in these situations before would know it’s usually a lone voice who imposes his or her stand on others.

It suddenly becomes a decree that no one dares challenge this person if he or she has some religious authority, but there may be no credence to this at all.

Each time an incident like this crops up, the authorities step in and put out the fire quietly.

By now, it’s well-known that most rape cases in Malaysia happen in rural areas, where the victims are conservatively dressed. The predators are largely familiar to the victims and have even included relatives.

According to a report in the New Straits Times on March 16, Kelantan has one of the most sexual crime cases in the country.

Bukit Aman Criminal Investigation Department director Datuk Seri Abd Jalil Hassan said most of the sexual crimes reported in Kelantan in the past few years were rapes.

“Eighty per cent of the sexual crimes reported in Kelantan involved children,” he said after launching Kelantan police’s Child Interview Centre (CIC) in Kota Baru.

Asked about the higher number of sex crimes involving children compared with adults in Kelantan, Jalil said he believed the lack of attention by parents to their children was a contributing factor.It has nothing to do with the dressing of flight stewardesses or nurses, which seems to be the obsession of some lawmakers.

Certainly, wearing shorts and skirts above the knees isn’t the cause of sex crimes.

So, the last thing we need in our schools and universities are self-appointed custodians of morality banning sarees, which is simply disrespecting the traditional culture of fellow Malaysians.

The actions of such teachers don’t only deprive students of their right to represent their cultural identity, but also runs contrary to the inclusive values espoused in the “Malaysia Madani” concept advocated by the unity government.

If we don’t stop this, the Iban warrior may no longer be seen wearing his shorts at National Day or Tourism Malaysia events.

So, kudos to the organisers of KS2023 for bringing tradition and fun to all Malaysians.

KS2023 director Shamsul Bahrin Zainuzzaman hailed the programme as having successfully achieved its main objective – to see Malaysians in ethnic attire travelling on public transport while promoting the multicultural sarong.

“I am wearing the traditional attire of the Bidayuh ethnic group as a sign of support, and we also saw many other friends from various races taking part in KS2023,” he told Bernama.

The Keretapi Sarong was introduced by non-governmental organisation Random Alphabet in 2012 before being taken over by LOCCO in 2017, involving thousands of participants travelling on public transport wearing either batik or pelikat sarongs as the de rigueur attire.

Anyone ready to organise a saree event soon? There’s certainly a dire need for education.

Despite its flaws, Malaysia Airlines is ours

TRANSPORT Minister Anthony Loke recently posted a picture of his hot meal including the signature satay, which is served on Malaysia Airlines (MH) business class, when he flew to Kuching to attend a Cabinet meeting and the Malaysia Day celebrations.

In his Facebook post, he assured that the airline was resuming its hot meal service in phases and that MH is taking efforts to ensure services would be back to normal as soon as possible.

Without question, Malaysian Hospitality has taken a beating over the past few weeks. Passengers, especially those who had paid hefty prices for their business class tickets, have been furious. Rightfully, too.

Original Penang Kayu Nasi Kandar boss, Buruhan Mohamed, in an interview expressed his dismay but said he would continue to fly MH.

It’s the same with me. I have always been a supporter of MH, not just because it’s our beloved national carrier, but it has the best crew.

I think I can say this with some degree of qualification after having flown to over 60 countries on many different airlines.

Last week, I flew to Hong Kong and Beijing on business class, and my carrier, Cathay Pacific, ran out of blankets. The dim sum that was served was certainly below par. I expected more from CX which would surely know what an acceptable dim sum should be like.

On a recent flight on KLM, I was served fusion Asian food by so-called master chefs, according to the introduction on the menu. Perhaps, it was made for Westerners to suit their taste buds.

British Airways are notoriously bad when it comes to food. On a recent flight from Zurich to London, in economy class, I had to pay for my coffee.

You only get a bottle of water and the flight attendant looked like she was forced to do her job. It’s my choice for the worst airline. But maybe not, the American airlines are probably on the “worst” list, too.

In 2022, it was reported that all BA’s shortest domestic and European flights would not receive any catering at all, while some longer European flights under an hour and a half in flight duration, ‘’may also go without food’’ with passengers given vouchers to buy food in the airport before boarding their flights.

This year, it was reported that BA passengers were fed Kentucky Fried Chicken – a leg each – on a 12-hour flight after the plane’s catering carts were said to be not properly chilled with the food having to be disposed of.

Of course, these wrongs by other airlines cannot justify the missteps by MH. Two or even more mistakes by others doesn’t make MH right and a hungry passenger is an angry passenger, regardless if it’s business or economy class.

But many of us have grumbled, if not, suffered over the quality of food on MH provided by Brahim’s Food Services, which had a 25-year concession to handle in-flight catering.

To be fair to the MH management, which has come under heavy criticism, it’s a legacy issue that the present team must handle.

Ending the contract of Brahim’s brought a lot of cheers but these teething problems are the price that MH is paying.

The battle on the “termination of convenience” clause which Brahim’s refused to accept, clearly shows the airline’s seriousness about cleaning up all its legacy contracts, be it with local or international companies.

It is noteworthy that the financial restructuring in 2020-2021 gave the airline group the opportunity to holistically repair its balance sheet and address decades-long legacy issues, resulting in a reduction in liabilities of over RM15bil, and eliminating RM10bil in debt.

The battle continues as the airline renegotiates other contracts that are nearing its term, and this time around it was Brahim’s.

Whilst this was ongoing, Brahim’s pulled the brakes and served MH with a service discontinuation notice, giving the airline only two months to prepare itself.

Any setup would have been faced with teething problems given the extremely short lead time, what more the airline business with its highly regulated and complex processes involved.

In short, the longstanding catering contract between Malaysia Airlines Bhd (MAB) and Brahim’s Food Services (BFS) ended on Aug 31, 2023 after extensive negotiations between the two parties since Q4 2022 did not result in an amicable agreement.

BFS had in early June 2023, served MAB with a notice of service discontinuation effective July 1, 2023, while discussions were still ongoing for a new contract. BFS subsequently retracted the notice and agreed to extend service until Aug 31, 2023.

The question is why didn’t MAB appoint a new caterer sooner?

“While negotiations with BFS were ongoing, MAG had also considered other short- term and long-term solutions for its overall catering plan, which all require extensive preparation.

“It is impossible to shift to a new provider within a short span of time, hence MAG was working towards continuing the contract with BFS. Our alternative caterer, POS Aviation, operates on a much smaller scale and is not able to expand in time to accommodate all MAB flights. In total, MAB serves 40,000 inflight meals a day from KLIA,’’ it said in a reply.

But the biggest misreporting by some media was the claim that MH had stopped serving meals when the airline’s FAQ section, MH clearly stated that meals will still be provided.

However, it being a full-service carrier, it noted that passengers were allowed to bring their own food subject to certain conditions.

So, what happens now? Full hot meal services won’t be available for a while as MH is prepared to only say in phases.

The high lifts equipped with proper storage capabilities (chillers) have arrived earlier than anticipated and we hope for Malaysia’s sake, passengers will have their full hot meals offered soon to all destinations.

To make up for this, MH should perhaps offer higher Enrich miles as a reward to its loyal passengers who are still committed to MH.

But despite all the hiccups, MH will remain my choice simply because it offers direct flights, and no other airline greets me with ‘’welcome home to Malaysia.’’