


Unity in diversity: Anwar displaying a list of new Cabinet members on Friday night. The lineup has been welcomed as a reflection of the diverse unity government that the Rulers had suggested. — AZHAR MAHFOF/The Star
You can’t please everyone all the time, but Malaysia has, at least, resolution and a way forward now.
IT’S infinitely unnerving when politicians rely on a combination of race and religious issues to garner support.
Social media is littered with videos of these politicians dangerously peddling their lethal and toxic sentiments to push their desperate agendas.
Unfortunately, these tactics appear to have worked for certain parties, as evidenced by the votes in the recent 15th General Election (GE15).
It may seem preposterous but there’s certainly a market for such toxic stories, buyers of which, tragically, include young voters.
The majority of Undi18 votes, unfortunately, went to those who advocated hard-line religious practices.
Ironically, one of the prime movers of Undi18, Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman, nearly lost his seat.
It’s one thing to attack corrupt politicians and suggest an alternative, but the treacherous level it has degenerated to is an entirely different prospect.
From promising a passage to heaven to Jewish plots and an alleged Chinese-led unity government, it has become a no-holds-barred onslaught.
The Prime Minister has found himself accused of being an Israeli spy, while others have been called LBGT+ supporters and communists, thanks to one imaginative and fertile mind.
Even the Rulers have been criticised, although in a more subtle way, but the tone of discontent is palpable. They have ignored the line, for sure.
The election is over. His Majesty called for a unity government with Perikatan Nasional – comprising Bersatu, with PAS – invited to join the government, but Perikatan declined.
It was no surprise because Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin wouldn’t have fancied playing obliging subordinate to Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, who was the choice of the Rulers for PM.
While Bersatu leaders have stated their preference to be in the Opposition, PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang’s hysterical outbursts haven’t quite tickled Malaysians’ funny bones.
He may have 49 Members of Parliament but he must surely feel anguished at being out of power at the federal level, especially with such a big bloc of lawmakers.
But PAS needs to get a grip.
The events of GE15, which led to an inconclusive result, have proven that no single political coalition can form a government without the participation of all Malaysians, including Sabahans and Sarawakians.
No doubt Perikatan has won over the Malay heartland, especially the “fixed deposits” of Felda settlers, and even the Putrajaya constituency, the government’s seat.
But Perikatan can’t hope to form a government if the rest of the country doesn’t subscribe to PAS’ politics.
It’s unfortunate that the Opposition is now nearly all- Malay, but, fortunately, the government bench is more diverse. There’s obviously nothing for PAS to brag about.
The party needs modern and progressive leaders if it hopes to achieve its aim. It needs a kinder and more open narrative to win over the rest of Malaysia, and not just the East Coast of the peninsula.
PAS is arguably regarded as a party dominated by religious leaders with qualifications from West Asia, but lacking strong fundamentals in finance, economics and the sciences.
A constant barrage of statements reeking of Talibanism isn’t going to help them.
Umno will now need to work on its lost Malay ground. It must cleanse itself of its tainted and corrupt image which has scarred the party.
President Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, like it or not, has plenty of work to do. He can’t preach the virtues of being in a unity government and be seen as the person who almost single- handedly killed Umno and Barisan Nasional.
Perlis fell to Perikatan by default, and now the state has a PAS Mentri Besar for the first time.
The polls are over. Malaysia needs to get back to work and brace itself for a tough 2023. There’s simply no time for unproductive politics.
It’s better for the new Federal Government to dedicate itself to making Malaysia a country we can all be proud of, with the rest of the world viewing us favourably.
Leave the dogmatic religious hardliners alone. Stop talking of banning PAS or arresting its leaders, as we will only create martyrs of them, an because, ultimately, it’s more important that the unity government proves its mettle.
If needed, appoint good PAS lawmakers who can contribute to their positions. Why not? There is good talent in all parties, and on both sides of the divide, too.
Let bipartisan politics be a part of a developing, mature democracy, where substance matters more than form.
As Chinese military strategist Sun Tzu said in The Art of War, “Keep your friends close, but keep your enemies closer”.
If the unity government is genuine, let it be an inclusive government.
Those of us who know Anwar will concur that he doesn’t give up on anyone. He will meet everyone, including those who’ve bad-mouthed him, to win them over.
His policy has always been that if he can’t have them aligned with him, he would want them to, at least, not oppose him. It will be harder this time, though.

IT’S certainly not a perfect list of Cabinet line-up. Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim just has been pulled from all sides, including by some powerful figures, who insisted on their choice of representatives in Cabinet.
The Prime Minister took a longer time than expected to finalise his list as party members and partners in his new Unity Government bombarded his phone with messages and suggestions.
There were endless meetings with stakeholders which dragged late into the night as the deadline approached.
Even his 3pm press conference to announce the list had to be postponed until 8.15pm and even that began late.
The PM had to honour his pledge for a leaner Cabinet and at the same time, balance the demands of his partners.
Although it looked like Anwar had to labour through some horse-trading and appeared to be weak, the reality is his predecessors had taken a longer time than he did.
Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad took 11 days to fully complete his full line-up after the GE14 in 2018, which many have forgotten.
Anwar is in a more complicated position. Despite having a two-thirds majority in Parliament, Malaysia is in uncharted waters.
Malaysia has never had a Unity Government comprising partners, which has just fought a bruising election against each other.
Many made open pledges of not wanting to work together and tore each other to bits during the recent campaign.
But now, they are in the same government, and they will most likely make strange bedfellows and would need a period of adjustment to keep the government intact.
The period of instability and uncertainties will probably cause some turbulence, but rational-minded Malaysians certainly want this government to work.
The alternative, with many hard-line theological politicians, seems unpalatable. Perhaps even dangerous to multi-racial Malaysia.
In 1969, after the race riots, the Barisan Nasional government was formed which included the then opposition PAS and Gerakan.
It was not called a Unity Government, but the new coalition government worked and functioned effectively under Tun Abdul Razak.
Fast forward to 2022, Anwar is certainly sitting on the hot seat. Besides having to face a strong Malay and religious centric opposition, PAS, with 49 Members of Parliament, will continue to throw doubt on his leadership.
Already, the Islamist party has used the narrative that the Pakatan Harapan government is dominated by the DAP.
Like it or not, Umno president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi has thrown PH a lifeline for Anwar to be the PM and lead a federal government. Anwar is indebted to him as without Zahid, he wouldn’t be PM.
Zahid’s inclusion has earned the wrath of PH members but let’s not forget that he also faces the same emotional wrath from Barisan parties.
We do not live in a perfect and idealistic world. Realpolitik is the order of the day. Politicians say things they do not mean, and quoting Italian philosopher Niccolo Machiavelli, the end justifies the means.
There has also been a lot of backlash against the inclusion of former banker Datuk Seri Tengku Zafrul Aziz, who lost in the Kuala Selangor parliamentary constituency.
But this is not a new practice. Previously, political leaders who had lost in the elections have been made Senators and appointed to ministry positions.
This time, PKR’s Saifuddin Nasution, who lost in his bid for the Kulim Bandar Baharu seat, now heads the powerful Home Ministry while Barisan Nasional secretary-general Datuk Seri Dr Zambry Abdul Kadir, defeated in Lumut, is now the Foreign Minister.
For some reason, Zafrul has been targeted but like former Health Minister Khairy Jamaluddin, both are young talents that Malaysia needs.
Both unfortunately lost in the GE. Likewise, it is sad that PKR vice-president Nurul Izzah Anwar was beaten in Permatang Pauh by PAS.
But the inclusion of popular Segambut MP Hannah Yeoh is certainly welcome although she would actually be more suitable as Tourism Minister, given her personality, than Youth and Sports Minister,
Sarawakian leader Datuk Seri Tiong King Sing, who is Tourism Minister, will be more cut out for an economy related portfolio although it can be argued that tourism is a crucial revenue earner.
They are bright sparks in Malaysian politics that are ready to cut across the political divide and practise bipartisan politics in a mature manner.
Not many, like Zafrul, are ready to leave high-paying positions in the corporate world for politics. How many of us, who prefer to whine, are prepared to take up such a bold move?
It is important that Anwar now focuses on facing the headwinds of 2023. He has correctly put more emphasis on the economy, cost of living and food security, which will affect the people the most.
Besides the economy, the government needs to prove that it can deliver. If it does, then it does not need to focus its attention on politicians who rely on race and religion to win support.
There should be no place for the politics of revenge and vindictiveness by the new appointees. Leave the civil servants alone.
Malaysians want to see the end of corruption, a better education system, healthy economy, fairer government and one that can make Malaysians feel proud of their country again.
BREAKING NEWS: Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim is still putting the final touches to his Cabinet line-up and contrary to some media reports, will not be naming them on Thursday (Dec 1).
The Prime Minister spent the entire afternoon Wednesday (Nov 30) – with all appointments cleared – to focus his full attention on the Cabinet composition.
Highly placed sources said there had been intense lobbying from partners of the unity government.
“The list will probably be trimmed to maybe 25 ministries but he (Anwar) is certainly juggling as this is unprecedented.
“He has to take into account many political interests, and yet, trim down the Cabinet to a decent size,” the source added.
Under Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin’s tenure as prime minister, there were 32 ministers, while Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob led a government with 31 ministers.
It has been speculated that there could be two Deputy Prime Ministers with Umno president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamid being much touted as one and another possibly from Sarawak.
Gabungan Parti Sarawak’s Datuk Fadillah Yusuf, who was Works Minister, has been speculated by the media to be the one taking the second DPM post.
Parti Keadilan Rakyat is almost certain to keep the powerful Finance Minister post. Should a Finance Minister II post be created, then it is possible it may go to Umno.
Another key position is the dominant Home Affairs Minister portfolio which both PKR and Umno are eyeing.
Speculations that the Cabinet is ready and that the Cabinet line-up announcement would be announced Thursday emerged after the Istana Negara Facebook account posted on Wednesday four photographs showing Yang di-Pertuan Agong Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri’ayatuddin Al-Mustafa Billah Shah receiving the Prime Minister.
It was reported that His Majesty had granted an audience to Anwar on Tuesday, which then led to talks that the complete list of the Cabinet had already been presented to the king.
It is understood that Anwar’s first weekly meeting with the Yang di-Pertuan Agong was held yesterday (Tuesday) instead of the usual Wednesday, following the Council of Rulers’ meeting that took place yesterday and today.
Berita Harian quoted PKR information chief Fahmi Fadzil as saying that he understood that the announcement would be made as soon as possible, but he did not have any information about it.
”I don’t have any information. Some journalists have contacted (me) and I don’t have any information about this matter.
”What I understand is (it will be announced) as soon as possible, but I have no information about the period of time,” he said.
It is understood that while the possible appointment of Ahmad Zahid as DPM has become an issue among Pakatan Harapan leaders and supporters, they also acknowledged that he was a key figure in the formation of the coalition government.
“The harsh reality is that without Zahid, there is no PH-led unity government. We have to consider that.
“The Perikatan Nasional with Bersatu and PAS will gladly welcome him and Barisan into their ranks and form the Federal Government.
“Let Anwar have the space to draw the list but there will be no announcement tomorrow, as of now,” the source added.

Great expectations: Anwar – pictured here receiving congratulatory calls from world leaders in the Prime Minister’s Office in Putrajaya – will have to move fast to heal a nation sick of politicking. — PMO
WE’RE clearly living in interesting but also strange times. When Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim was sworn in as Prime Minister, it was also nomination day for two seats.
They were the Padang Serai parliamentary and Tioman state seats, where voting had earlier been suspended following the deaths of two contenders.
Fascinatingly, Barisan Nasional, which is a member of the Unity Federal Government, is pitted against Pakatan Harapan, which helms the government.
They will face off in these two places. It will be interesting to see Barisan and Pakatan’s sales pitches. In fact, there will be state elections in Penang and Selangor in seven months, where the two sides will need to outwit each other. And if there’s a by-election in Sarawak, Gabungan Parti Sarawak (GPS), which has joined the Federal Government, will find itself in the same awkward situation.
Just two weeks ago, Barisan was accused of being a corrupt coalition, along with Umno president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi. The slogan being bandied about then was a vote for Barisan equalled a vote for Ahmad Zahid, who faces a slew of corruption charges.
But in the past few days, he has been heralded as a saviour who made the unity government a reality. We’ve been encouraged to look at the “larger picture” – a tainted man is now rescuing us from PAS.
Suddenly, all is forgiven and forgotten. Barisan is no longer a party for traitors who sold their greedy souls for power.
There was despair earlier, when at one point reports circulated about Barisan being in the Opposition bloc.
Ahmad Zahid was also criticised by his rebellious ranks for Umno’s dismal performance, but they then found themselves labelled opportunists instead, for previously wanting to back Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin as PM.
Ironically, Muhyiddin is the same guy who campaigned against Ahmad Zahid and corruption on his Perikatan Nasional platform. It worked perfectly, as Bersatu, along with PAS, swept the Malay heartland and crushed Umno’s vote bank, including in the Putrajaya parliamentary constituency, which fell to Perikatan.
Malay voters had obviously forgotten this was the same man who warned them about PAS.
But having 49 PAS MPs was enough to scare off many Malaysians. Not just non-Malays who voted overwhelmingly for Pakatan, but also many Malays, especially those in urban areas.
The fear of a “Green Tsunami”, as it’s now branded, with PAS theologians imposing its religious agenda, was just unpalatable for many.
For a while, those who gloated over Pakatan’s victory also privately wondered if it was a case of being careful what you wish for. They had presumed the rest of the country would share their political allegiance.
Pakatan was short of a simple majority while there was the possibility of Perikatan forming a Malay- and Islamic-centric federal government.
But God works in mysterious ways, goes the adage. Anwar, who was dismissed by many and seen as not fated to be PM, proved everyone wrong. He will turn out to be the best person to take on PAS MPs on the other side.
Anwar may not be a theologian, but he has credentials. He can quote Quranic verses with a smattering of Arabic, and he has plenty of Arab allies, too. Never mind his past controversies because we’re not voting for a priest or ulamak.
He is surely not an angel but a true-blue politician who will bend rules and principles. Ultimately, though, he’s the best of our lot.
It’s not easy to find a Malay leader who enjoys such strong support among non-Muslims.
But Anwar needs to work his charm on the conservative Muslims who voted for Perikatan. Like it or not, the number of combined votes earned by Perikatan, Barisan, GPS and GRS (Gabungan Rakyat Sabah) is much higher than those handed to Pakatan.
Meanwhile, PAS needs to take a hard look at itself to understand its optics problem. No party or coalition can hope to form a government by preaching to just one community or religion. It would be disastrous for multiracial Malaysia.
Politics is about selling hope, as Anwar successfully has done. The jury is still out on whether he will deliver on his promises to Malaysians, so we’ll have to hold him to that.
Many of us who gave up on Malaysia and its politicians have found that, finally, we can recover what we’ve lost and still salvage the situation.
Certainly, our Rulers have placed their faith in Anwar as the man who, in the opinion of the King, can command majority support in the House.
His Majesty has allowed Anwar to put together a unity government in the shortest time.
Now it’s up to Anwar, as the 10th PM, to prove he can hold the fort and steer us through the many challenges ahead, especially the strong economic headwinds.
He needs to fix our education system at all levels, as it has progressively gone down the drain. It won’t and can’t be done overnight, but it must begin now.
There’s no time for vindictive politics or rhetoric, which scarred the 22-month Pakatan government in 2018 and led to unprecedented apologies issued by the DAP recently to close a chapter with GPS.
The lesson learned here is that politicians shouldn’t be arrogant or resort to burning bridges. After all, no one knows what the future holds.
Let’s hope we see younger Malaysians such as Rafizi Ramli, Hannah Yeoh, Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman and Steven Sim, with a balance of experienced MPs from Barisan and GPS, in the Cabinet. Possibly even technocrats appointed to certain ministries.
It’s wishful thinking, of course. If only Nurul Izzah Anwar, Khairy Jamaluddin and Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz had won. And we hope for more women in the Cabinet.
Malaysia must move on. We are simply worn out from all the politicking.
There is little time for Anwar to celebrate. Time is not on his side. We want to see results, and quickly, too.
Congratulations Saudara Anwar Ibrahim and may you succeed in restoring Malaysia to its former glory!

It is understood that His Majesty will be seeking the opinions of the Rulers on the impasse in the formation of a federal government.
The meeting will begin at 10.30am and it is expected to last at least three hours.
Palace sources said the special meeting would be crucial.
The Yang Dipertuan Agong has been trying to put up a unity government comprising Pakatan Harapan and Perikatan Nasional but has failed so far.
The Rulers are expected to be briefed on the legal procedures as a hung Parliament has taken place.
The Conference of Rulers is also scheduled to be held on Monday (Nov 28).

KUALA LUMPUR: Barisan Nasional leaders have indicated that the coalition was ready to remain in the opposition and would not be part of either a Pakatan Harapan- or Perikatan Nasional-led government.
The tone has already been set that Barisan, which has unexpectedly become a kingmaker, decided not to support either coalition.
Barisan leaders, who continued their discussions until late Monday (Nov 21) night, have continued their meetings Tuesday (Nov 22) morning.
It is understood that the stand being conveyed is that Barisan would rather be outside any government.
On Monday, Umno deputy president Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan set the tone by saying Perikatan and Pakatan should consider setting up a government instead, saying that Barisan was prepared to be the opposition.
He said Barisan would be ready to provide checks and balances and be a responsible opposition.
Umno supreme council member Datuk Armand Azha Abu Hanifah has also reportedly said he was convinced that Barisan would be better off that way.
He said the coalition had to accept the people’s decision of not wanting it to be in the government.
It is understood that component party leaders found that the grassroots were against joining a Pakatan government after the incessant criticism against Barisan.
“During the campaign, Pakatan said a vote for Barisan is a vote for Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi but now it looks like a vote for Pakatan is a vote for Zahid,” a Barisan leader said.
Ahmad Zahid, the Umno president and Barisan chairman, has come under intense pressure to quit and take responsibility for the heavy defeat in the 15th General Election.
He has also been called out by other Umno leaders for his readiness to strike a deal with Pakatan.
Umno leaders also said it was difficult for them to convince their members that Barisan would work with DAP.
Non-Malay Barisan leaders said they would be “drowned” by the 40 DAP MPs in Pakatan while backing Perikatan meant working with PAS leaders who had taken a strong religious stance and were pushing the Islamist party’s hard-line agenda.
Barisan leaders also said they were prepared to work out a confidence and supply agreement (CSA) with any minority government to ensure the country remains stable.
Confidence and supply agreement (CSA) is a political arrangement in a hung parliament in which an opposition party agrees not to vote against a minority government to pass votes of confidence or budgetary matters.
ANYONE who went on the campaign trail would have noticed that the posters of Umno president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi were almost non-existent in places where Barisan Nasional was contesting.
The instructions given out by most Barisan candidates was that Ahmad Zahid had become a liability.
Both Perikatan Nasional and Pakatan Harapan had hammered home the point that Barisan was associated with corruption.
Any picture of Ahmad Zahid, who is still facing a slew of corruption charges, unfortunately was a stark reminder.
He himself only managed to keep his Bagan Datuk seat with a few hundred votes.
The writing on the wall is clear and any responsible leader should know what to do.
Almost every speaker at Perikatan and Pakatan ceramah harped on this issue linking Ahmad Zahid and corruption. The only difference was that in the mega gatherings of Pakatan, confined mostly in urban areas, the voters believed Pakatan would win enough to form the Federal Government.
The analysts said Pakatan would win big but not enough to hit the simple majority of 112.
But many Pakatan diehard supporters chose to believe in Kita Boleh.
Over at Perikatan, the coalition parties quietly worked the Malay heartland with the same message. There was no need for mega gatherings like Pakatan.
The surveys and pollsters did not seem to correctly register the Malay voices, with all saying Pakatan was leading – which was accurate – except that they didn’t take Perikatan seriously until the last 48 hours.
But for many Malay Undi18 voters who also detested corruption – their preference was Perikatan, especially PAS.
The fact that PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim and Muda chief Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman were given a fierce fight by their opponents, even trailing at some point, is evidence that many Malays did not share the ideals of Pakatan.
Possibly they include the many Malay youths who embraced the Islamic values espoused by PAS and the many preachers who are hugely followed on social media.
These influential Islamic personalities have millions of followers each and even PAS theologians enjoy this celebrity status.
Most non-Malays living in the cities have little knowledge of this Islamic phenomenon.
In Permatang Pauh, the PAS candidate who beat Pakatan’s Nurul Izzah is Ustaz Muhammad Fawwaz Mohd Jin, 39, with a degree from Al Azhar University in Egypt.
The father of 11 children listed himself as a preacher and a CEO of an Islamic foundation.
The reality is that DAP or its supporters will not be able to change the course of history alone as the Chinese population is just about 25%.
With the gerrymandering exercise and malapportionment, the Chinese votes only have about 20% more value than the votes of the rural areas.
In short, the huge Chinese turnout will just increase the votes of the Pakatan candidates in the urban seats but will not increase the number of representatives.
As an example, Pakatan-DAP’s Gobind Singh Deo won with a whopping majority of 124,619 votes. He polled 143,619 votes against Perikatan (18,256) and Barisan (13,806).
Gobind actually cast his vote in Penang, where his address is located.
The biggest winner is PAS – which had 18 Members of Parliament before dissolution but has reached 49 this GE15.
It controls Kelantan, Kedah, Terengganu and now Perlis with a large share in Pahang.
The Islamist party will now demand a larger share of Cabinet representation with an eye for the powerful positions. After all, it has more seats than Bersatu.
The policies and directions of the federal government are set to change.
If Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin becomes Prime Minister, then he has to bring Malaysia together and reassure everyone that Malaysia is multiracial and multireligious.
The Perikatan manifesto has clearly stated that it is committed to the Malay agenda and Islam, and his recent remarks on Jewish Christian prayers have remained fresh in the minds of many non-Muslims. He has said he was quoted out of context. And Perikatan also made it clear that it respected and recognised the position of Malaysians of other faiths.
Politicians on both sides of the divide have said things that they shouldn’t have said and then denied them, just to win votes.
The elections are over, and the winners have been declared. Malaysia cannot remain divided.
PAS surely understands that it needs a sensible and acceptable narrative and optics.
Its leaders cannot continue to issue statements that spook the country. The fact is that the same yardstick that may be “standard” in Afghanistan or elsewhere in West Asia cannot be applicable in Malaysia.
But then, we hope the parties from Sabah and Sarawak would be able to provide the checks and balances to ensure that moderation is practised.
For the first time in Malaysia, we have a hung parliament.
It means no one party can form a government on its own. Not Bersatu, PAS or GPS – every ethnic group needs the backing of another.
Pakatan may or may not be in government, but we should not forget it has the largest number of seats.
In the end, the red Pakatan wave was strong but it wasn’t enough. It was the PAS green tsunami that made the difference.
