Author Archives: wcw

He was the people’s Choy-ce

Undefeated: Choy celebrating after being the only Independent candidate to retain his seat (Pengkalan Kota) in the 1978 election

Undefeated: Choy celebrating after being the only Independent candidate to retain his seat (Pengkalan Kota) in the 1978 election

JALAN C.Y.CHOY

IF THERE is one thing that Penangites are noted for, it has to be their independent streak. Penang remains the only state that has voted out every single one of its chief ministers.

It started with its first chief minister, the late Wong Pow Nee of MCA, then the late Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu and his successor Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon, both of Gerakan.

The state has produced numerous outspoken opposition leaders activists and journalists.

But one person stands out above the rest — the late Choy Chee Yew, or popularly known as C.Y. Choy.

He was part of the Socialist Front and had the distinction of being the third and last mayor of George Town. It became a city by a royal charter granted by Queen Elizabeth II in 1957.

Brief Caption:The Jalan C.Y. Choy in Georgetown.The Star/ Lim Beng Tatt/ 25 July 2013.

True to his route: Jalan C.Y.Choy remains a place with a working class community and home to various traders who have been doing business here for generations.

The Socialist Front was a coalition of the Labour Party of Malaya and the Parti Rakyat Malaya, which was formed to contest against the Alliance comprising Umno, MCA and MIC.

Historian Tan Kim Hong wrote in his research paper that in 1953, 16 intellectuals including D.S. Ramanathan, Tan Phock Kin, N. Patkunam, Lee Kok Liang, C.Y. Choy, Tan Chong Bee and V. Veerapan of the Fabian Society of Penang joined the Pan-Malayan Labour Party (PMLP).

These professionals and teachers, all social democrats, moved to immerse themselves in politics, offering analyses, recommendations and political participation vastly different from those of the moderate trade unionists favoured by colonial officials.

By early 1954, PMLP had come to resemble the British Labour Party, advocating gradual economic nationalisation and a welfare state.

Choy won a city election in 1964 as a candidate of the then Socialist Front but ceased as mayor when the Federal Government suspended local elections two years later as a result of the Indonesian Confrontation.

07.06.1978 Golden Keys of Independent candidate Mr C.Y. Choy at Noordin Street.

Populist: During the campaign season in 1978, Choy’s symbolic set of keys were seen in Noordin Street.

Today, a road has been rightly named after him but ironically by the Barisan Nasional state government under Dr Lim, who had faced Choy in many political battles.

According to a newspaper report, Choy, who worked as an office assistant, was such a populist figure that when he walked into the streets, the people came out to shake his hand.

The Socialist Front later disbanded after its partners, the Labour Party and Parti Sosialis Rakyat Malaya, went separate ways due to the political upheavals of that time.

Refusing to join any other party but still wanting to serve the city folk, he took part in the 1969 general election as a candidate contesting the Pengkalan Kota state seat and won easily.

He remained an assemblyman until his death in 1980 at the age of 73 and Bridge Street, the main thoroughfare of the constituency, was re-named Jalan C.Y. Choy.

Choy’s symbol during his campaign was a set of keys. It was symbolic with independence as he won the seats under that banner.

The Pengkalan Kota constituency has always been a working class area.

Glum faces of defeat: Independent candidate Lim Ewe Chin and his most staunch supporter Mrs C.Y. Choy after the election results were announced in November 1980.

Glum faces:Independent candidate Lim Ewe Chin (centre) and his most staunch supporter Mrs C.Y. Choy after the election results were announced in November 1980.

His humble and down-to-earth approach reportedly endeared him to the voters.

Local historian and publisher historian Khoo Salma Nasution described Jalan C.Y. Choy as a former working-class quarter of the Hokkien community which once supported a triad society.

The shophouses along the whole length of Bridge Street are strikingly regular – most were rebuilt in the late 19th century, replacing houses of wood and attap which had been repeatedly set on fire by the rival society.

Despite having no official position after the Socialist Front deregistered, he still commanded the support of his constituents.

Brief Caption:The Jalan C.Y. Choy in Georgetown.The Star/ Lim Beng Tatt/ 25 July 2013.

Enjoying the morning: Just like other streets in Penang. Jalan C.Y.Choy has some popular coffeeshops.

He often went around the constituency, stopping at five-foot-ways with a typewriter to write petitions and letters to the authorities.

His mostly-illiterate voters called him ‘the father of hawkers’ and by 1974, Choy retained his seat with a 5,000 vote majority. By then, he was nearly 70 years old.

Jalan C.Y. Choy still remains very much a working class area, with its hawkers, traders and blue-collar community.

Every state assemblymen for Pengkalan Kota; from Teoh Teik Huat (DAP), Lim Kean Siew (MCA) and Lee Hack Teik (MCA) has all tried to emulate Choy’s populist image.

They have all come and gone but none will be able to match Choy’s legendary ways and legacy as the fighter of the downtrodden.

Storm in a teacup

The writer is baffled over the resistance to the move to make Titas a compulsory subject. Titas was already mandatory for Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia students more than 30 years ago and it has, he feels, fostered better understanding of different civilisations among the different races.

THE move to make Islamic and Asian Civilisation Studies (Titas) compulsory for university students in private institutions from Sept 1 has kicked up a storm.

But for many graduates of local universities, particularly Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, it has certainly not raised an eyebrow.

Thirty years ago when I was studying at UKM, it was already mandatory for us to pass the Islamic Civilisation course.

It did not matter what we studied; we all had to pass the paper if we wanted to get our scroll at the end of our studies. No one, even Muslims, was exempted and often there were non-Muslims who were top scorers.

As I can recall, none of my friends was converted into Islam, and certainly this writer did not become a Muslim. We didn’t complain about the requirement to pass the ZI course, as it was code-named, as we already knew about the condition when we picked UKM as our choice.

Certainly, taking the course has given me a better understanding of Islam. Like it or not, Islam is the religion of the majority of Malaysians.

The course at UKM was simply an introduction to Islam and it has helped me in the course of my work as a journalist.

As I had sat for Islamic History and Malay Literature in my Sixth Form examination, the ZI course was pretty easy for me. That arrogance and complacency, however, proved to be costly as I did not score as well in ZI as I had expected. The others who did not have that academic background studied harder and performed better in the end.

I still passed the test but it was lectures by the late Datuk Fadzil Noor, who went on to join politics and become a PAS president, and Datuk Dr Haron Din, with his profound story telling of jins and spirits, that caught my interest.

I have continued to collect books on Islam, improving my understanding of the subject, and building up a decent private collection.

Certainly, reading plenty of books on this subject and my ZI classes have benefited me in many ways, particularly in my interaction with friends, colleagues and other acquaintances who are Muslims. I am glad I took the ZI course in UKM.

But I also believe that studying and appreciating the other main religions, especially Buddhism, Christianity and Hinduism, will also benefit all of us.

The idea is not to belittle any religion or to extol one’s belief as more superior, but rather to emphasise the commonalities such as compassion, tolerance, love, sharing and peace.

We all call God by different names and we practise our beliefs in different ways but there will always be many common values and areas because we all believe in the importance of goodness and respect for each other.

In fact, students of Islam in UKM, like in other institutions in the Middle East, are also required to study other religions including Judaism and Christianity.

Likewise, students who want to become Catholic priests and Protestant pastors will need to study Islam at their seminaries.

I have been lucky growing up in Penang and later working in Jalan Mesjid Kapitan Keling, previously Pitt Street. It was always a joy to walk past, or at least drive through, the road which has a mosque, a Hindu temple, a Taoist temple and a church located next to each other.

As a child who grew up in the Chulia Street area, where my grandmother’s home was located, it was common for me to walk through the Kapitan Keling mosque to take a short cut.

Today, two paintings by the late Penang artist Tan Choon Ghee hang on the wall of my home in memory of my childhood days. There is no religious hang-up of having drawings of a mosque in my home.

In Singapore, schools regularly organise visits to places of worship as part of their extra-curricular activities.

We shouldn’t be afraid of learning the religions of all communities. It should not be restricted to just one religion.

Non-Muslims should learn about Islam and at the same time, there is no reason why Muslim students in universities, both public and private, should not study other religions which have been here for centuries.

It should be made compulsory for everyone to study each other’s religion in order to have a better understanding of each other.

In this period of Ramadan, breaking fast with our Muslim friends and colleagues is certainly encouraged. It will be a good way to understand each other’s faith.

Zipping in and out of George Town

Hop On: The tram was a way for locals to get around George Town.

Hop On: The tram was a way for locals to get around George Town.

IT IS a fact that public transport is crying out for attention in Penang, as the roads get more jammed with cars, especially during weekends and long holiday breaks when just about everyone visits the island.

No one would recommend any tourist to wait for the public bus and taking a cab is not so easy either. Unlike in Kuala Lumpur where metered cabs are easily available, if you were to flag down a cab in Penang, chances are the driver will not use the meter.

Most Penangites prefer to use their own transport, which is probably one reason why vehicular traffic is high.

Brief caption: Road sign of Jalan Trem, off Datuk Kramat. (Charles Mariasoosay - 30/06/2013)

In name only: Jalan Trem is a nod to the existence of the Tramway Office in Penang.

And many still use motorcycles, which are suited for short-distance travelling. To the surprise of many outsiders, most women in the state are able to ride the two-wheelers.

Yet, unknown to many young Penangites, the island used to have the best transport system in the country.

Public transport in George Town, especially at the turn of the century, was second to none. The state was the earliest to have tarred roads, electric trams, double-decker buses and cars.

There were also the man-pulled jinrikishas — which are not like the trishaws which are pedalled — and horses!

In fact, George Town was accorded city status on Jan 1, 1957 — the first in the country to be granted such a status. According to the book Old Glimpses of Penang, the first motorcar to make its appearance in Penang was recorded in the state’s annual report of 1903.

It was reported that by the end of that year, there were 80km of roads used by 791 carrriages, 73 gharries, 3,185 public and 323 private jinkrishas, 679 bullock carts and 803 handcarts. Horses and bicycles made their appearances between 1896 and 1900.

The book described that Penangites owned four cars in 1904, but 10 years later, 174 were licensed by the municipal council.

Tram cars were first introduced in Penang in the 1880s when a businessman, one Mr Gardner, set up a steam-run tram service in the Air Itam and Waterfall roads.

“There were 11 cars on those routes in 1890 and the Penang Steam Tramways Co had its headquarters in Western Road,” the book said.

By 1904, when electricity supply came, the trams were run on electricity and more routes were added. Two years later, a 4km route was introduced between George Town and Air Itam.

The tram lines can still be found in Penang Road in front of the Odeon Cinema while the Tramway Office was located in Jalan Tramway (renamed Jalan Trem), off Datuk Kramat Road.

There were many reports of accidents and the trams were described as unreliable with operators losing money from the business.

Difficulties were encountered by the enterprise with declining receipts due to the economic slump in 1907-1908, and the destruction of a bridge in 1909. But by 1913, the trams were making a profit and continued to do so until the trade depression of 1922,” wrote Ric Francis and Colin Rayney in Penang Trams, Trolley Buses and Railways.

Another means of transportation in town was the first regular private bus service which started as early as 1919. Unknown to most Malaysians, it has been recorded that the world’s smallest trolley bus was founded in Penang.

The electric-run nine-seater buses were used as shuttle buses between the Lower Station on the Hill Railway to the Air Itam market.

In the 1970s to 1980s, most Penangites depended on the bus services operated by the municipal council. It had to compete against private operators such as Penang Yellow Bus, Lim Seng Seng, Sri Negara and the Hin Company.

They were easily identified by their colours. You would take the yellow bus to places such as Balik Pulau and Bayan Lepas, the green bus to Air Itam, the blue bus to the beaches and the plain-coloured municipal ones around town.

My colleague reminded me that when he was growing up in Jelutong, his aunt in Balik Pulau would regularly send vegetables and even live chickens via a friendly bus driver to their house at no cost.

Avid numismatist and collector Danny Tan Swee Boon showing some of the old Penang tramway and Penang City Council bus tickets that he has in his collection.

Colourful: Some of the old Tramway and bus tickets.

Ridiculous as it may sound to many youngsters now, many of us then used to collect the colourful bus tickets as a hobby, as one would collect stamps.

There was always a conductor on board who would give you the ticket based on where you are going and occasionally an inspector will join the bus halfway to check that you had a ticket.

The bus was probably the most popular form of transport among students although we had to literally fight our way to get onto the buses daily.

Today, there are air-conditioned buses in Penang but it does not have the colour, nor the efficiency of the network back then. The times are a-changing and Penangites yearn for a proper mass rapid transit system to connect various parts of the island to the city centre.

But it is still a dream, even as development continues to increase the population density, and by extension, the number of cars on the roads.

Readers write

YOUR article brought back sweet memories. House No 28 in Nagore Road (the synagogue) and the three adjacent houses originally belonged to my maternal grandfather, – NgUng Eng.

* * * * *

In typical Penang Peranakan culture, the sons got a house each.The house No 28 was given to the eldest son, my tua ku (uncle). He must have sold the house very much earlier.All the children and grand children’s lives revolved around house No 26.

Every school holidays we would pass time at No 26 where the household was dominated by our grandmother. Our grandfather passed away before I was born.

My mum was about 13 years old then. Our grandmother was a real dragon lady. Anybody causing any mischief would get a cubit (pinch) from her. I miss her a lot.

My parents, uncles and aunties would gamble away in the hall. Come tea-time everybody will stop their activities while the nyonya kuih man would drop by. He would be carrying laksa soup on a pole on his shoulder while balancing a tray of kuih on his head.

Since my grandmother passed away, the three houses owned by my uncles were sold.

Nagore Road evokes sweet memories of my childhood. We would peek inside the synagogue when we hear noises inside and without fail we would get a scolding from the elders.

– GK Pak Chan, Xavierian class of 1970

* * * * *

I truly appreciate your article on June 29 about Gottlieb Road, especially the photo of the Penang Chinese Girls’ High School.

I happened to pass through this busy road with my grandson Michael Wong at the wheel.

He also drove me to Air Itam as it was few decades since I last went there.

I made a point to walk to the tortoise well, located half way to the Kek Lok Si Temple.

I was hoping to take the new furnicular train up Penang Hill but it did not materialise because the place, being a Saturday, was terribly congested with construction work in progress at the foot of the hill.

We also went to Gurney Drive, Esplanade and Padang Kota Lama. I wanted to savour the famous char koay teow at Kota Lama. But we had to abandon the idea because the queue was too long and I had to rush to catch the flight home to Subang at 5.30pm.

However, we did manage to enjoy tandoori chicken, naan and chicken briyani at Restoran Kapitan in Chulia Street.

– S.Ragunathan, Petaling Jaya

* * * * *

I wanted to let you know how much I enjoyed reading Penang’s History, MyStory.

Your articles are nostalgic to me because I was in the police force in Bukit Mertajam from 1975 to December 1978.

I used to go to the Chemistry Dept in Jalan Tull and during the night, I would visit several cabarets, nightclubs and discos.

I wanted to point out in one of your articles where you said Seberang Prai was also called Prai. Seberang Prai is divided into Utara (Butterworth), Tengah (Bukit Mertajam) and Selatan (Nibong Tebal).

Prai was a small Indian settlement between Chai Leng Park and Sungai Prai estuary. I am now retired, aged 65 and residing in Damansara. – Anonymous

It’s back to square one

The Egyptians wanted democracy but they have ended up endorsing a military coup, something that they could not have imagined a year or two ago.

FOR the past one week, I have been spending my leave in Europe, reading through all their newspapers and following their coverage of the political situation in Egypt.

It’s pretty clear that many European leaders are at a loss on how they should react to the military coup there.

When Mohamed Morsi was arrested, one top British leader immediately deplored the action of the army. A democratically elected leader, he argued, should not be forced to step down by the army.

The Foreign Office, meanwhile, later said that it was an inevitable change, suggesting that while it was a coup, the world needed to recognise that the army only moved in after millions of Egyptians took to the streets to protest against Morsi.

Some even said that more people were involved in this massive protest than the one that had brought down the army-backed dictatorship of Hosni Mubarak in 2011.

Any coup is clearly detested by Western democrats and Morsi was democratically elected in June 2012 after the fall of Mubarak.

But judging from the Western reactions, it is clear that the Muslim Brotherhood with its Islamist approach is naturally not palatable in Europe.

And who can blame the Europeans? Just two years ago, the Egyptians had clashed with the army and police in the streets to bring down Mubarak.

Now these protesters are welcoming the same security forces, which still comprise many of Mubarak’s supporters, to overthrow Morsi’s government.

Many in the judiciary, who had previously backed Mubarak, are now involved in the next phase of action after conspiring with the army to topple Morsi. And they are being cheered on by the people in the streets who hated the Mubarak establishment.

Quite simply put, the revolution in June 2011 has gone around and come back to the same position.

The Egyptians thought Morsi could bring hope and change but after two years, they reckon that things are more or less the same, if not worse.

There was no democracy under Mubarak and, under Morsi, despite his promises, there was none either.

And now that the army is in charge, many doubt if any form of real democracy will prevail, even as the people wait for a date to be set for fresh elections.

Under Morsi, protesters who opposed him were reportedly violently crushed by the police and by Muslim Brotherhood members.

The Interior Ministry, which Mubarak had used, was also used by Morsi to punish protesters and, in many cases, it was said that many of his opponents were killed.

Under Mubarak, there were substantial Christian representatives in the government but under Morsi, their numbers shrank.

The Coptic Christians, many of whom were strong supporters of the revolution that ousted Mubarak, learnt the hard way that Morsi was turning a blind eye to attacks on Christians in Egypt.

There were many minority groups who supported Morsi but, once in power, his concern for them diminished. For these minorities, it is a classic case of being careful with what you wish for.

Morsi also reportedly pushed to lower the retirement age of judges so that he could clear the way for his allies to be appointed. Judicial intervention was something he had openly detested previously.

And now the vicious circle repeats itself. Following the coup, the pro-Morsi media has been shut down while the pro-army media has taken on an inflammatory stance.

For the common people of Egypt, it’s back to square one. They have ended up endorsing a military coup, something that they could not have imagined a year or two ago.

Two years back, the angry people of Egypt got rid of a dictator but then elected an incompetent leader who had no idea how to run a country.

There’s a lesson here. The Egyptians wanted democracy but promises by politicians must always be followed by real work and proper planning.

The institutions that provide the checks and balances must be in place.

The lesson for Europe is that their leaders cannot be too simplistic and idealistic in attaching political labels on different regimes.

The Syrian government has been painted as dictatorial but what about the freedom fighters who want to take over?

Images on YouTube of freedom fighters purportedly cutting off their opponents’ body parts and eating them like cannibals have had a chilling and terrifying effect across the continent.

Surely, these people who claimed to fight Assad on religious grounds cannot be the type of people they want to take over Syria.

The world will be watching Egypt closely as those who fought against Mubarak at Tahrir Square are now on different sides.

Morsi’s supporters have found victory snatched from them and their only solution would be to go to the streets again.

The danger is when the streets become the battleground, government work in a real democracy can never be done.

Life’s a beach in Penang

Fun times: (Clockwise from left) The writer at two with his mother Yeoh Poh Choo and father Wong Soon Cheong at Batu Maung.

Fun times: (Clockwise from left) The writer at two with his mother Yeoh Poh Choo and father Wong Soon Cheong at Batu Maung.

IT IS hard to explain to someone outside Penang, especially those staying in the Klang Valley, how wonderful life can be on the island.

Even those of us who have left the island to pursue our careers and set up new lives elsewhere will sing the same tune, as if our time on the island is permanently captured in a time capsule.

The so-called Penang diaspora is a living testimony to the saying that “you can take a Penangite out of Penang, but never the Penang out of a Penangite”.

Apart from those who venture out in search of greener pastures, there are, of course, many who will never leave the island.

They will never give up their lifestyle for the fast-paced life of Kuala Lumpur, for example, even if the career options are more plentiful.

For me, having migrated to the Klang Valley such a long time ago, I can only reminisce about my early days, my growing-up years where memories seem to be strongly embedded.

Where else but in Penang — except maybe in some East Coast states — where the beaches are just a short distance from your school, office or home.

For those of us who studied in St Xavier’s Institution at Farquhar Street, we had a seafront at the end of our football field.

After a game of football, we would sit near the seafront, where we would enjoy the strong crushing sounds of the waves hitting the wall, as we closed our eyes to let the wind blow against our faces.

Fishing was not allowed but on occasion, we would be able to throw our lines into the sea and take home a fish or two for dinner.

Our neighbour — Convent Light Street (CLS) — was luckier. Many of their classrooms faced the sea directly!

No wonder Captain Francis Light and Sir Stamford Raffles, who later went on to discover Singapore, chose to work and live at the site where CLS is now located.

For most families, a Sunday outing meant going to Gurney Drive, Tanjung Bungah, Batu Ferringhi or Teluk Bahang for a swim.

It also meant digging bucketfuls of siput remis or shellfish in the sand.

Working at the Pitt Street — now renamed Jalan Mesjid Kapitan Keling — office of this newspaper, we would sometimes take a slow walk to the nearby Esplanade for our meals.

In the evening, when work was completed, my colleagues and I would drive to Gurney Drive to have some hawker snacks before heading home.

During the 1970s until the 1980s, the annual dragon boat races were held off Gurney Drive and at night, the road would be turned into an illegal racing track.

The races would only begin after midnight and dragged on until 2am, with cheering at strategic spots, particularly at the roundabout.

Where the condominiums of 1 Gurney Drive (or PG1 as it is commonly known) now stand, there used to be an old hotel and restaurant called The Shanghai, which was THE place for important functions like weddings during the 1960s.

But that is known only to people in their 60s and 70s.

For us young journalists, Gurney Drive was where we would meet to have endless rounds of beer at the restaurants facing the promenade.

And the conversations would often be about the interesting interviews we have done with tourists at Batu Ferringhi.

There was such a thing as the “beach beat” then but during the 1970s, this tabloid was rather racy in nature.

While it could not deliver the Page 3 topless girls similar to The Sun in the United Kingdom, there were regular pictures of tourists in bikinis. The Home Ministry then was obviously less strict!

By the time I joined The Star, for the first time in 1980, there were already fewer such interviews as the newspaper had moved on to be more serious in its reporting.

Still, the beaches continued to be a source of news stories which included foreigners swimming in the nude at the freshwater pools at Chin Farm in Batu Feringghi.

There were the occasional raids by the authorities and the newsmen would be happy to tag along.

Batu Ferringhi or Foreigners Rock has many personal memories for me as I used to camp along the long stretch of beach as a teenager with my school friends.

My parents did not even bother to ask where I would be camping.

All I did was tell them that I would be camping for three days or nights.

April 1999 The balancing rocks.

Unique feature: Large boulders are a common feature on beaches in Batu Ferringhi.

On one occasion, all our canned food was stolen while we were sleeping. Needless to say, the camping trip had to be cut short.

As we grew up to be young adults, many nights were spent at the then famous disco, Cinta, at the Rasa Sayang Hotel.

It was only natural that I chose the Rasa Sayang Hotel to propose to my wife at an expensive Western restaurant.

But as a true reporter, there’s always a story behind every event.

The salad, for example, came with a big wriggling worm which certainly took away much of the romance of the evening.

Midway, a colleague of my wife approached us from another table because her boyfriend did not have enough cash to pay for their meal.

Today, the hotel has been renamed Shangri-La’s Rasa Sayang Resort and Spa, and it is surely one of the best beach hotels in Penang.

SHANGHAI HOTEL, FORMERLY CHUNG THYE PIN'S SEASIDE BUNGALOW

A landmark: The Shanghai Hotel used to be a popular venue for important functions in the 1960s.

The beach culture was so ingrained in me that on my first visit to The Star office in Petaling Jaya, I strolled into the newsroom in my shorts and shocked many!

But it was so natural in Penang island, where most of the time, we would be in our shorts and sneakers!

It would be a lesson from then on that my life in Kuala Lumpur will no longer be a stroll on the beach.

Download the PDF version of this story.

Related story:

Jalan Yahudi to Jalan Zainal Abidin the real Zainal

Jalan Yahudi to Jalan Zainal Abidin — the real Zainal

A colourfu l life: The late S.M. Zainul Abidin was a judo champion when he was still teaching and his grandchildren always gathered around to celebrate his birthday. The photos are reproduced from the book, Pengkisahan Riwayat Hidup Haji S.M. Zainul Abidin, published by Dimensi Eksklusif (M) Sdn Bhd.

A colourfu l life: The late S.M. Zainul Abidin was a judo champion when he was still teaching and his grandchildren always gathered around to celebrate his birthday. The photos are reproduced from the book, Pengkisahan Riwayat Hidup Haji S.M. Zainul Abidin, published by Dimensi Eksklusif (M) Sdn Bhd.

I WOULD like to thank readers for pointing out the error in the history behind Jalan Yahudi, subsequently renamed Jalan Zainal Abidin, published in this column on July 6.

I had wrongly identified Zainal Abidin with the noted Malay writer who was better known as Za’aba. The road is actually named after S.M. Zainul Abidin, one of Penang’s pioneer educationists, whose name is also spelt as Zainal Abidin.

The letter below from his youngest son Zainul Arshad is reproduced in full to put the matter in context. There is also another letter from another reader who also pointed out the same error. I am given to understand that many readers had called Zainul Arshad about this matter and he has taken the initiative to write us the letter.

I record my deepest appreciation to readers of this column who have constantly given me feedback, and pointed me to the right direction when needed.

It reminds me that much of local history is passed down orally, from generation to generation. We should all strive to know our own history. In writing this column, I have found that it is difficult to find the definitive records of many of the personalities that have roads named after them.

I believe all local authorities should make it a requirement to document the history of all the roads under their jurisdiction, old or new, for public record. Even new developments named after people or events must be documented so that those who come after us will have a proper record. The little stories that surround our neighbourhoods are a rich legacy that should be preserved.


The road is named after my father

I read your article Penang’s History, My Story titled “Leaving only tombs behind”. Since I was born and bred in Penang I always look forward to reading this weekly column.

I had wanted to send you a book about my father in the hope that you may write something about him being the pioneer educationist and politician in Penang. But before I could do that your article on the Jewish cemetery appeared.

I have to point out an error in your article. Zainal Abidin Ahmad has nothing to do with Jalan Zainal Abidin. He was not a Penangite. Jalan Zainal Abidin (although wrongly spelt) was named after my late father S.M. Zainul Abidin. I am his youngest son.

S.M. Zainul Abidin was one of Penang’s pioneer educationists. Among his former students were Tunku Abdul Rahman, Tuanku Syed Putra Jamalullail (Raja of Perlis), Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu and Tuan Yusoff Rawa.

He taught at the Penang Free School for 20 years before becoming headmaster of the Francis Light School in 1938. He retired as Inspector of Schools in Penang. Zainul Abidin was the first Malay to obtain a B.A. degree (externally) from London University in 1933.

He was also a founder member of Penang Umno and was responsible for getting a piece of land from his good friend, the late Hamid Khan, to build the Umno building in Penang.

S.M. Zainul Abidin was selected by Tunku to stand as a candidate in Malaya’s first Parliamentary election in 1955. He won handsomely as an Umno candidate in the north-west constituency whilst Chee Swee Ee of MCA won in the north-east constituency.

One of S.M. Zainul Abidin’s sons is the wellknown broadcaster, the late Datuk Zainul Alam. Interestingly enough, my late father stayed at No 35, Jalan Zainal Abidin (Jalan Yahudi), two doors from the Jewish cemetery, from 1929 until his death in 1969. — Zainul Arshad S.M. Zainul Abidin


The wrong Zainal

I am a fan of history and naturally an avid reader of your Saturday articles. You wrote that Jalan Yahudi was re-named Jalan Zainal Abidin in memory of Za’aba.

However, I think it is not so. I think it was attributed to S.M. Zainal Abidin, who was a member of the 1955 Federation Legislative Assembly.

I am told by old-timers that Zainal Abidin’s home was situated just behind the present Umno building at the junction of Macalister Road and Jalan Zainal Abidin.

Hence, lending credence that it was named after a local personality rather than Za’aba who originated from Negri Sembilan and had no real links to Penang. – Abdul Fareed Abdul Gafoor

Our flag flies high in London

Tan Sri Liew with Najib, Cameron and Johnson at the Battersea project launch.

BATTERSEA has become the most talked about word in London. Malaysians travelling to this city over the last few days have been asked the same question by Immigration officers on arrival: “Are you here for Battersea?”

At Bayswater in Central London, one of the city’s most cosmopolitan areas with significant populations of Arabs, Greeks and even Brazilians, I was asked by an Arab salesman at Whiteleys if I was from Kuala Lumpur and whether I was attending the Battersea Power Station development launch.

British friends, especially those with links to Malaysia, also asked for help to get invitations to the Battersea regeneration event on Thursday.

Everyone wanted to be part of history. It is safe to say that there has never been any property groundbreaking event in Europe which was attended by two prime ministers and the mayor himself!

All three – Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak, David Cameron and Boris Johnson – endorsed the project, declaring the enormous economic benefits that would be brought to the city.

Foreigners, including house buyers, see the Battersea property project as a good investment. Londoners see thousands of jobs being created and, better still, a RM4bil underground rail line in the works.

It was exactly 30 years ago on Thursday when the Battersea Power Station stopped producing power for the city but, as SP Setia boss Tan Sri Liew Kee Sin rightly pointed out, that power is back again in Battersea to bring a planned RM38bil development to the area.

It is a massive project by all counts, with the first phase comprising a block of 865 apartments that will be completed in two years. All the apartments have been sold, mostly to Malaysians, Singaporeans and Hong Kong buyers.

The project, which is backed by Sime Darby Bhd and the Employees Provident Fund (EPF), is unprecedented for a Malaysian consortium in one of the world’s biggest financial centres. The icing on the cake is that Liew beat Chelsea football club boss Roman Abramovich to the prized land, where Stamford Bridge, the club’s stadium, is not far away.

Local residents associations also lent their support to the Malaysians as they feared Abramovich’s plan to relocate the stadium to Battersea could cause traffic disruptions but bring few new jobs to the area.

After 30 years, life will be rekindled at the abandoned coal-fired power station once the project is in full swing. Located on the south bank of the River Thames, the station once generated about a fifth of London’s electricity.

It was used as the backdrop for Pink Floyd’s Animals album in 1977 and this writer has been made to understand that talks are ongoing to convince the remaining members of the hugely successful band to reunite for a charity concert at the iconic site.

In more recent times, Battersea was used to launch the Conservative Party’s election manifesto, according to Boris Johnson.

At one point, it was bought by John Broome, chairman of Alton Towers, who wanted to turn it into a British Disneyland. Hong Kong businessman Victor Hwang wanted to turn it into a shopping mall but the plan never took off.

The groundbreaking event by Najib and Cameron saw plenty of history being made. The two premiers carried out bilateral talks for 30 minutes on the upper floor of the site sales office – where the show unit is located!

Johnson, as usual, cycled his way to Battersea while it has to be recorded here that a Malaysian bomoh was flown all the way to London to ensure the unpredictable British weather was beaten. Whether it was the bomoh’s expertise or sheer luck, the rain stayed away.

Now that the fanfare is over, the real work needs to be done. The sales of the first phase have been a roaring success. SP Setia, in fact, had to turn away buyers.

The real challenge would be the subsequent phases. Getting Arab investors and buyers for the higher-end units would bring higher value to the project. There is also a need to secure sales from European, American and East European buyers.

Liew, who is well known for his down-to-earth approach, played down his visionary role in making the Battersea project a success. Instead, he attributed the success to the backing of Najib and the British leaders. He consistently reminded journalists, who billed it as Malaysia’s success story, that he has never felt so proud of being a Malaysian, a sentiment shared by his countrymen regardless of their race at the event.

But the reality is that Battersea is really a feather in his cap. His leadership, professionalism, dynamism and commitment have made this first step to changing the skyline in London possible. He has successfully flown the Malaysian flag in England.

This should serve as a reminder to Permodalan Nasional Berhad, the giant Malaysian asset management company that now owns the majority share in SP Setia, that Liew should be allowed to carry on his work with no interference.

In the day-to-day management, Liew and his men know their job inside out and they have the track record to prove it.

Let the professionals do their job and I am sure his financial backers, Sime Darby and EPF, would feel the same way. Their concern is that their investments must see good returns, that’s all.

The Jewish community in Penang is all but gone leaving only tombs behind

Honouring Za’aba: Jalan Zainal Abidin used to be known as Jalan Yahudi

Honouring Za’aba: Jalan Zainal Abidin used to be known as Jalan Yahudi

IT used to be called Jalan Yahudi but it has been renamed Jalan Zainal Abidin, after the prolific Malay writer who is more popularly known as Za’aba.

By renaming the road, the Jewish legacy in Penang, and for that matter, in Malaysia, has been erased.

But the country’s only Jewish cemetery which was set up in 1805, is still in existence there.

It is well-maintained but most of the time, the gates are locked, perhaps mindful that it could be the target of anti-Semitic elements.

Located between Burmah Road and Macalister Road, the small cemetery escapes the attention of Penangites who use this link road, as it is tucked behind high walls.

According to a report titled A Penang Kaddish: The Jewish Cemetery in Georgetown — A case study of the Jewish Diaspora in Penang (1830s-1970s), the oldest Jewish tombstone in the cemetery is dated July 9, 1835.

Penang’s only synagogue used to be in Nagore Road.

It is dedicated to a Mrs Shoshan Levi, believed to be the benefactor who donated the land where the cemetery stands.

Many of the Jews buried there were British subjects, including one Louis Victor Cohen, a former army officer, who died on Oct 9, 1941 at the age of 23, according to an article by Hismanshu Bhatt.

There are about 107 graves located in the cemetery, with the most recent tombstone dated 2011, of David Mordecai, a former E&O hotel manager. He died just short of his 90th birthday and was believed to be the last ethnic Jew on the island.

According to a report online, “55 friends and neighbours attended the burial, among them a handful of Jews. With his passing, the only Jew to hold a Malaysian passport is Mordecai’s niece Tefa Ephraim, who now lives in Sydney, Australia.

Mordecai was the son of David and Mozelle Mordecai, who came from Baghdad to Penang in 1895.

David Mordecai Sr was active in the tin and rubber industries under British rule and a colonial turf racing enthusiast in Penang and Singapore.

A good number of Jews used to live openly in Penang until the end of the 1970s, when many emigrated.

The local Jewish community reportedly comprised Jews of Sephardic origin who live among the Kristangs (people of mixed Portuguese and Asian ancestry), including those who came from Iraq and India.

The first known Jew to make Malaya his home was Ezekiel Aaron Menasseh in 1895.

Menasseh claimed to be the only practising Jew in Malaya for three decades but the general census of Jewish settlers in Penang (1881-1941) showed that 172 Jews already lived there in 1899, according to a news portal.

It is said that during the Japanese occupation, the Penang Jewish community was evacuated to Singapore.

After the war, a majority of Jews had stayed on in Singapore or emigrated to Australia, Israel and the United States.

One report has it that by 1963, only 20 Penang Jewish families remained in the country.

Penang’s only synagogue, located on 28, Nagore Road, closed down in 1976 as the community could no longer fulfill a quorum of 10 or more adult Jews assembled for purposes of fulfilling a public religious obligation.

An article in the portal Free Malaysia Today, dated March 18, 2011, entitled “The Last Jew to leave Penang,” featured an interview with one Joseph Hayeem Abraham Jacobs, whose grandfather Hayoo Jacobs moved from Singapore to Penang, where he stayed at the island’s synagogue in 1929.

Jacob’s father Abraham grew up juggling a myriad of professions including that of a fighter pilot and professional boxer. At one point, he even enjoyed a French dairy board consular status with the French government. He eventually met and married Tan Kok Choo who would go on to become a popular RTM broadcaster,” the portal reported.

“It was a normal childhood, we went to school, we played with the neighbourhood kids. Everyone knew we were Jews but no one cared. That’s the beauty of Penangites,” said Jacobs.

The Penang synagogue is today the office of a print, design and digital business.

While most of the early Jews were of Caucasian origin, there were also many of Indian stock from India.

Closer to home, the most famous Jew was David Marshall, the first Chief Minister of Singapore.

He also accompanied the first Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman to meet Chin Peng, the Communist Party of Malaya head, in the Baling Talks.

In Penang, Gottlieb Road is named after Felix Henri Gottlieb, a German lawyer of probably Jewish descent, who worked for the British government in Penang between 1846 and 1882.

But it would not be fair to leave out the legacy of Za’aba, of which the road is now named after.

Zainal Abidin Ahmad (Sept 16, 1895 to Oct 23, 1973) remains one of the most respected Malaysian writers and Malay language experts.

The Jewish cemetery in Jalan Zainal Abidin with neat rows of Hebrew-inscribed headstones, testifies to the existence of a sizeable Jewish community then. – filepic

Every student of Malay literature is expected to know his name — that is how much respect has been accorded on to him.

In Kuala Lumpur, there is a road named after him at Taman Tun Dr Ismail and many colleges or residential hostels in Malaysia are named after him as well.

Zainal Abidin was born in Negri Sembilan and had his early education in a Malay school but went on to study at the premier St Paul’s Institution in Seremban. He became the first Malay to pass the Senior Cambridge in 1915.

Although he began teaching the following year, soon he enrolled in the Malay College in Kuala Kangsar and in 1924 he studied at the Sultan Idris Teachers’ College, now a university.

He also studied and lectured at the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London, where he completed his Masters at the age of 59, and finally taught at University of Malaya in Singapore.

According to the National Archives of Malaysia official portal, Za’aba was considered the pioneer of Malay language grammatical rules, which were vague at that time.

He was given the responsibility to draft the school curriculum, was a translator, lecturer and during the Japanese era was handed the responsibility to write books that could be used in Malaya and Sumatra.

The portal said in 1946, he was appointed a committee member of the Legislator Committee of Umno Charter Bill.

Za’aba, who was later conferred the Tan Sri title, died on Oct 23, 1973 at the age of 78.

Za’aba’s legacy will remain as he is one of the biggest names in Malay literature, whose works have been translated into many languages.

 

Readers write

I WAS a boarder at the St Xavier’s Boarding School in Burmah Road, opposite the Pulau Tikus Convent secondary school from 1949 to 1954, before continuing my secondary school years at the new SXI building in Farquhar Street. We were the new occupants of the newly-completed school building.

The boarding school was set up by the La Salle Brothers for poor boys and orphans. And it also took in paying students from all over Malaya. 

The lower classes studied at Noah’s Ark (so called because the wooden and attap building looked like a boat). There were eight to 10 classes conducted there. 

All those who passed their annual school examination could be promoted to higher classes at St Xavier Branch School at Kelawei Road.

It faces the St Joseph’s Novitiate which trained Catholic novices to be Christian Brothers of the La Salle Order. The school being situated in a Eurasian enclave had many Eurasian teachers and many Eurasian pupils and students.

One of my teachers was Dudley Rozells, younger brother to Colin. Colin never taught me but he was a hero to the school population as he was a Penang state sprinter and the school’s athletics coach.

Jimmy Boyle, who lived just across the road from the school was also the school’s sports coach and was famous as a musician. He coached me on the 80-yard hurdles.

One must say of the Eurasian community that they made a big contribution in sports, music, education and in community service.

In addition to the teachers, I remember some names of families living next door to the Church of The Immaculate Conception such as Sheila Labrooy, Marie de Souza and Carmen Coombs, who were good friends to the boisterous boys of the St Xavier’s Boarding School. 

The Church of The Immaculate Conception, Pulau Tikus is a heritage building. It had its bicentennial celebration two years ago.

The church records are intact for those who wish to research the early history of Penang.

There are some early writings dated from the 1800s and the names of all parish priests who served the church consecutively corresponding to the 200 years of its establishment.

– Anthony Lim, Penang

If you have any feedback to share, email mystory@thestar.com.my


The correct Zainal Abidin

It has been pointed out to me that Jalan Jahudi was renamed Jalan Zainal Abidin in honour of a renowned educationist in Penang. Please read this story for context and clarification.

Crack down on criminals

In place of the EO, a new law to deal with hardcore criminals, with a built-in mechanism to stop abuses by the authorities, should be drawn up.

DRUGS, gambling and corruption – that’s the root cause of crime. You don’t have to be a criminologist to know where we have gone wrong, and what we have done, or not done, to stamp out the disease that is eating us up.

It has been reported that over 60% of snatch thieves caught are drug addicts. The statistics also show that half of the 30,000 prisoners have a history of drug use.

Home Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi has also said that 48.2% of the prisoners had been found guilty of drug trafficking, possession and other drug-related offences.

Then there is the huge growth of illegal online gambling operations in towns and cities particularly in Selangor and Kuala Lumpur.

There are strong suspicions that, hiding behind the façade of Internet cafes, these gamblers, mostly youngsters, are resorting to criminal activities to “fund” their habit, according to Malaysian Crime Prevention Federation vice-chairman Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye.

“Some of them would do anything, including stealing and robbing, to get money. Initially, they start by stealing money from their parents and family members, and gradually move on to the streets. Most of these people have become habitual gamblers,” he said.

The media, including this newspaper, have regularly exposed illegal gambling outlets which offer online casino games.

One bold operator reportedly even distributed leaflets offering discounts, loyalty points and even original jerseys of English Premier League clubs to new gamblers!

Last year, The Star reported on the many illegal e-casinos with gambling programmes and live games broadcast from the Philippines. Despite the exposé, many carry on with business as usual.

Even the few that were raided and supposedly closed down have re-opened, according to my colleague who went undercover to investigate these places.

The underground gambling business has thrived simply because the operators know the authorities would never allow for legitimate outlets, be they outlets or clubs. The Genting Casino is likely to be the first and only casino ever to be sanctioned in Malaysia.

The result is that illegal gambling dens, whether in the form of cyber cafes or online casinos, have mushroomed.

The Home Ministry has a tough job on its hands. Zahid has proposed for a centralised body to be set up to coordinate enforcement and prevention efforts in curbing drug addiction and drug-related offences.

He has said that the body could be made up of personnel from the Customs Department, Health Ministry, Immigration Department, the National Anti-drug Agency (AADK) and the police.

Zahid is known as someone who means business but for the war against crime, he needs plenty of support.

Just look at the huge number of cyber cafes and massage outlets that come under the purview of the local councils. The police cannot be expected to raid every outlet as there are genuine ones too but the councils must do their part to keep an eye on the errant ones.

There are also strong suspicions that corrupt policemen and council officers are allowing the e-casinos to continue doing business.

Something does not tally here. Many of these outlets are known to the public and yet they appear to be unknown to the authorities. Can the public be faulted if they think there are crooked and rogue elements in uniform?

Regulated gaming outlets are frowned upon because of political and religious reasons, but illegal gaming outlets flourish as a result. And because they are illegal, there is also a loss in gaming taxes which would have been good revenue for the government.

Morale within the police force is low. The good cops feel they have been blamed for everything and, worse, they find that their hands are tied in crime-fighting.

The Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM) research team on crime and policing has rightly said that the Emergency Ordinance, although criticised as a draconian, inhumane and undemocratic law, did serve its purpose in effectively dealing with terrorists, secret societies, criminal gangs, recidivists and organised crime members.

USM Associate Prof Dr P. Sundramoorthy said that most EO detainees in the last three decades were those alleged to be involved in violent gang activities, extortion, kidnapping, gaming, and in executing the day-to-day operations for organised/syndicated crime bosses.

Almost 2,000 criminals were released after the EO’s repeal last year. Since then, according to police officials as reported in the media, most of those released are back in business and they are more dangerous and commit crimes openly without regard for public safety.

Sundramoorthy, as the principal researcher of the team, said the nature of their crimes were generally violent, inhumane and cruel.

His team has a question for Malaysians: “The research team on crime and policing from USM would like to ask all law-abiding and peace-loving citizens: To what extent are we willing to give up safety for the sake of liberty and democracy?”

Perhaps there could be a middle ground – a new law to detain criminals with a built-in mechanism to stop abuses by the authorities which can include a review committee comprising ex-judges, retired police officers, welfare officers and elected representatives from both sides.

The bottom line is, we cannot expect our cops to deal with hardcore criminals the gentlemen’s way. The criminals should simply be locked up.

Colonial law stalwarts

A GERMAN Jewish lawyer who founded the Free-masons lodge, a colonial lawyer and activist fighting for the rights of the locals and a British magistrate who arrived in Penang only to find that he had lost his job, were among those whose legacies live on.

There are at least five roads in Penang that honour colonial lawyers. The most famous has to be the busy Gottlieb Road.

The road is named after Felix Henri Gottlieb, a lawyer in the Straits Settlement between 1846 and 1882.

But his name would probably remain unknown and even inconsequential to most Penangites, who ply the road daily.

Gottlieb Road is the site for Penang Chinese Girls’ High School, the biggest girls’ school in Penang.

The road used to be congested at all times of the day especially during after school hours, when it is packed with school buses.

But Henri is more important than we think. He was one of the most colourful characters of the Straits Settlement.

He was also a true Penangite as he was born on the island. His father was the island’s first harbour master George Felix Gottlieb in the 1830s.

Both father and son were active Freemasons in Penang.

According to local historian and publisher Khoo Salma Nasution in her book, More Than Merchants: A History of German Speaking Community in Penang, Henri set up Freemason lodges in Penang and Taiping, Perak.

The Freemason movement has regarded itself as a global secular fraternity that carries out social and charity work where its members are taught these precepts in ancient forms.

Frowned upon by Muslim and Christian groups, the Freemasons including those in Malaysia, have openly conducted their activities by setting up websites with pictures of their members.

It is to show that the Freemasons are not a shadow group, as portrayed in Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code.

In fact, those interested in their activities can apply to be members while the press has been invited to observe their work.

In Penang, the Penang Masonic Temple is a historic building that stands out at the Brown Road and Jalan Utama (formerly Western Road) junction.

According to a report, the land to build the Temple was acquired in 1926 and the foundation was laid on Dec 17, 1927.

Designed by architect Howard Leicester, the building was built by contractor Lee Ghee Sok.

Another well-known lawyer of old Penang was James Richardson Logan, who was honoured with the Logan Memorial at the Supreme Court Building in Leith Street.

Logan Road, which runs from Perak Road to Anson Road, is also named after him.

Logan was regarded as a champion of the rights of the non-Europeans in Penang, as he dared to represent the natives.

He came to Penang with his elder brother Abraham and began a law practice.

In an age where the rights of the natives were often suppressed, he skilfully fought in a case of an Indian sireh planter against the East India Company, according to a posting.

Today, the famous landmarks are the Loh Clan Association, the LohGuanLye Specialists Centre, the Penang Specialist Maternity Centre and the Methodists Girls’ School.

Edward William Presgrave was another big name of the legal fraternity during the colonial days of Penang.

Presgrave Street is known in Hokkein as sah tiau lor or third street, and is today part of the city area known as the Seven Streets Precinct.

Presgrave Street is regarded as a working class neighbourhood.

Presgrave & Matthews is one of the oldest legal firms in the Straits Settlement. It was founded on Jan 1, 1879.

The original partners being Arthur Edward Clark, barrister-at-law, and Presgrave, who was a member of the Legislative Council.

Then, there is Dickens Street, which a short one-way street linking Penang Road with Transfer Road.

A plaque in the road has wrongly attributed the name of the street to novelist Charles Dickens (1812-1870) whose works included Oliver Twist, David Copperfield, A Tale of Two Cities, A Christmas Carol and Great Expectations.

In reality, Dickens Street was named after John Dickens, a British magistrate who arrived in George Town in 1801.

According to a report, upon arrival, he found that his services were no longer required as the Straits Settlement had set up a Recorder’s Court instead.

RAD Hogan was another lawyer who has a road named after him.

Hogan Road is a small road off Vermont Road, a minor road off Jalan Residensi.

Vermont Road is named after one of the military officers during the late 19th century.

Both Vermont and Hogan roads house quiet, leafy neighbourhoods.

The legal fraternity in Penang has a long history and its colonial style court complex is surely one of the most beautiful heritage buildings in this country.